لم تُترجم هذه الصفحة بالكامل بعد. يظهر بعض النص أدناه أو كله بلغة English، وهي لغته الأصلية.
Misplaced Hope
Chasing Meaning
David Paukovitz · Park Near North
When we place our hope in human justice or self-protection, we end up exhausted; true justice and rest are only found in God, the Good Shepherd.
- الواعظ
- David Paukovitz
- الكنيسة
- Park Near NorthOtherChicago, United States
- التاريخ
- زمن القراءة
- 18 دقيقة
- عدد الكلمات
- 3,860 كلمة
- اللغة
- الإنجليزية
المقاطع الكتابية
الوسوم
الفئات
شخصيات كتابية
الخلاصات
في هذه العظة▾
Failed Shepherds and Misplaced Hope
Good morning. My name is David, and I'm excited to open God's word with you today. Before we dive in, I want to start with a confession.
I suffer from what's clinically called prospective memory impairment—or as some say, I'm a "space cadet." In layman's terms, I'm constantly losing my stuff. Although I'd argue they're not lost; they're simply misplaced. I lose my phone, wallet, keys, glasses. I've purchased countless coffee cups and water bottles over the years because I've misplaced them. To make matters worse, I have a child who suffers from the same affliction and is constantly borrowing my things. It's a cycle of losing and finding—sometimes weeks or months later.
I remember last winter when I misplaced my wallet. After a couple of months, I called the bank and ordered a new credit card and ID. Then it turned up six months later.
Although it's fun to joke about losing physical things, this morning in Ecclesiastes chapters 3 and 4, the writer helps us discover that more than just our keys and wallets have gone missing. What we've misplaced is far more costly than any physical belongings: it is our hope.
The Series: Life Is Gift, Not Gain
We're continuing in our series in the book of Ecclesiastes. If you're just now joining us, welcome! A couple of weeks ago, I mentioned a phrase that summarizes Ecclesiastes: life is gift, not gain. Last week, Pastor Nate explained the gift of time—that we're given time as a gift to enjoy, not a guarantee to hold on to.
In verse 11 of chapter 3, the writer says, "God has made everything beautiful in its time." In our passage today, the preacher looks out at the world and recognizes a disconnect between the world as it is and the world as it should be. His hope is misplaced. And if we're honest, so is ours.
We put our hope in human justice or self-protection, we end up exhausted. And true justice and true rest are only found in our good shepherd.
Before we dive in, I want to reference a second passage: Ezekiel 34. Ezekiel was a prophet speaking to God's people in exile in Babylon—people whose king led them into ruin. In Ezekiel 34, God paints a powerful picture of what went wrong: His people are His flock, and the leaders are the shepherds. And the shepherds have failed the sheep. We'll keep that picture in mind as we explore Ecclesiastes. It helps us understand what the preacher is feeling and points us to where our hope actually belongs.
Part One: Failed Shepherds
Let's read Ecclesiastes 3:15-20:
That which is already has been. That which is to be already has been, and God seeks what has been driven away. Moreover, I saw under the sun that in the place of justice, even there was wickedness. And in the place of righteousness, even there was wickedness. I said in my heart, "God will judge the righteous and the wicked, for there is a time for every matter and for every work." I said in my heart with regard to the children of man that God is testing them that they may see that they themselves are but beasts. For what happens to the children of man and what happens to the beasts are the same. As one dies, so dies the other. They all have the same breath. The man has no advantage over the beast, for all is vanity. All go to one place. All are from dust, and to dust they all return.
The preacher's frustration here seems bitter, raw, and real. He looks out at the world and says, "Things are messed up." In verse 16, he tells us why life feels so unfair: the very places supposed to protect us—judges, leaders, institutions—are filled with wickedness. The innocent go unprotected and the wicked go unpunished.
For some, it may bring comfort to know you're not alone in this feeling. But I'm sure many of us read this and think, "How is it 3,000 years have passed and nothing has changed?" It's like cheering for the Detroit Lions or Buffalo Bills—it feels hopeless.
The Picture from Ezekiel 34
Remember the picture from Ezekiel 34? Here's where it comes in. In the ancient world, kings and leaders were often called shepherds. Through Ezekiel, God had a strong word for the shepherds of Israel:
Ah, shepherds of Israel who have been feeding yourselves, should not shepherds feed the sheep? The weak you have not strengthened, the sick you have not healed, the injured you have not bound up, the strayed you have not brought back, the lost you have not sought. And with force and harshness, you have ruled them.
In the place of justice, there was wickedness. The ones meant to protect the flocks were the ones feeding on it.
Now, I want to be careful here. It's easy to hear this and immediately put a face on it—someone in Washington, a CEO who cashed out while employees lost everything, a landlord who never fixed the heat. But Ecclesiastes and Ezekiel aren't handing us a list of people to blame. They're holding up a mirror to us. This passage has a way of turning the finger back toward every single one of us.
Who Is the Preacher?
We haven't talked much about the writer. He calls himself Koheleth, which literally means "a person who gathers people and speaks to them." The opening suggests he may be Solomon, a man unparalleled in wisdom and wealth. But I question this.
Unlike our government with its three branches, Israel had no checks and balances. They had a king—that was it. If Solomon was the writer, he would be both lawmaker and law keeper, the highest authority to enact justice. It would be strange for him to complain about injustice when he's the person who could change it. He was the court. He was supposed to be their shepherd.
But whether he was Solomon or not, his words are godly wisdom for us today. Look at the language of verse 16: "In the place of justice, in the place of righteousness." Justice and righteousness have been misplaced.
Calling something misplaced assumes there is, in fact, a place where it belongs. And if there is a place for justice and righteousness, then in each human heart we have a longing for that. That's why we can look out at the world as it should be and say, "Something isn't right." Deep down, we know one of two things must be true:
- Either a better world once existed, or
- A better world will one day exist.
Either option points to a Creator who made the world perfectly or will one day make it perfect. Or both.
God's Response to Injustice
And that's exactly where the preacher goes in verse 17. His answer should demand our attention:
God has made everything beautiful in its time, and there will be a time where God judges both the righteous and the wicked.
Then in verse 18, he says something startling. God uses the injustice of the world to test us—to show that left to ourselves, we are no different than the animals. We're born, we die, and we're put in the dirt.
Are we mere beasts? Well, humans have one thing animals don't. I'm not talking about higher thought, emotion, or unique fingerprints. I'm talking about the desire for avenging. In the words of Bonnie Tyler, "I need a hero." We see that longing everywhere—on picket signs and posts, all saying the same thing: "I want peace. I want justice, and I want it now."
This desire for accountability is a good thing, but two issues arise:
First, no level of justice will actually undo the wrongdoing of the world. No sentence served will bring back the lives of those taken in innocence.
Second, we—you, me, and every human being—we chose evil. When it comes down to it, we only want justice as long as we're not the one sitting in the defendant's chair. The preacher includes himself in this. We fixate on everyone else's injustice and forget that we, too, are mortal sinners standing before a righteous and just God in a courtroom.
Ezekiel says the same thing. After God confronts the shepherds, He turns to the flock and says, "As for you, my flock, behold, I judge between sheep and sheep." It's not just the leaders on trial; it's the sheep too.
If this was Solomon, then what he writes—"In the place of justice there is wickedness"—he's actually writing it about the darkness of his own heart. He's confessing the depravity of his own soul. In other words, "I don't know whether I am righteous or I am wicked, but what I do know is that I will be judged."
The Line Between Good and Evil
Alexander Solzhenitsyn, a Russian writer who spent about eight years in a Soviet labor camp, helps pinpoint this tension:
If only it were all so simple. If only there were evil people somewhere committing insidiously evil deeds, and it were necessary only to separate them from the rest of us and destroy them. But the line dividing good and evil cuts through the heart of every human being. And who is willing to destroy a piece of his own heart?
The Bible would say it's not just a piece of our heart; it's the whole thing.
This brings us back to verses 18-20. Koheleth reminds us that we are like the animals—we are frail, mortal, bound to space and time. And we, too, will return to the dust from which we came.
The Puritan pastor Richard Baxter once said, "I preach as never sure to preach again, as a dying man to dying men." That's what Koheleth is doing here. He's a dying man talking to dying men and women. And when we remember that we are dust, we defer and waive our right to hold a gavel.
At the end, we are not the ultimate judges. Second Corinthians 5 paints this clearly:
For we must all appear before the judgment seat of Christ, so that each one may receive what is due for what he has done in the body, whether good or evil.
We want to keep everyone else accountable to their failures, but there is no indication that God will consult us on the last day. But He will ask us this: "How were you accountable to what you knew to be true?"
Two Clear Applications
So what should we do with this? Two clear applications:
First, we are to examine ourselves.
Second, we are to place our hope in the character and promises of God.
Lamentations 3 sums both up well:
Let us test and examine our ways and return to the Lord.
I think it's wise to consider the importance of community here. Your discipleship will only go as deep as your accountability. Many of us know a lot of Bible, but we lack the people we need in our lives to keep us accountable to actually walk in it. One simple way is to examine yourself among trusted voices who can speak the truth in love and help you return to the Lord.
But here's the tension: If God is just and the line between good and evil runs through my heart, then His justice is not only good news for the oppressed—it's a problem for me.
So where does a person like me place my hope?
Hold on to that question. We're going to come back to it.
Part Two: Failed Sheep
Now we move to our second misplaced hope: a failed sheep. When the shepherds fail, the sheep try to shepherd themselves. Let's look at Ecclesiastes 4:1-6:
Again, I saw all the oppressions that are done under the sun, and behold the tears of the oppressed, and they had no one to comfort them. On the side of their oppressors, there was power, and there was no one to comfort them. And I thought the dead who had already are dead were more fortunate than the living who are still alive. But better than both is he who had not yet been and has not seen the evil done that are deeds that are done under the sun. Then I saw that all toil and all skill and work come from a man's envy of his neighbor. This also is vanity and striving after the wind. The fool folds his hands and eats his own flesh. Better is a handful of quietness than two hands full of toil and striving after the wind.
Koheleth takes another hard look at the world and says, "It's not getting any better." In verse 1, power is abused. Twice he says of the oppressed, "There was no one to comfort him." In verse 4, even our hard work is driven by envy and cutthroat competition.
So what do we do in a world like this? We protect ourselves. Ezekiel 34:6 describes it perfectly:
The sheep were scattered over the face of the earth with none to search or seek for them.
So we try to become our own shepherds.
A Heavy, Dark Place
Before we go on, I don't want to rush past verses 2 and 3. Koheleth looks at a broken world and says that the dead and those unborn are better off than the living. This is a heavy, dark place to be. Some of you know the weight of this today. You know what it feels like to wonder if it's worth waking up.
If that's you, hear me clearly:
You are not a bad Christian for feeling weary. You are not beyond hope. And you don't have to carry this alone.
Despair feeds on isolation. If you feel stuck, take one simple step today—step into the light. You can be raw with God. He can handle your unedited pain and doubt. Break the silence. Tell a trusted person—a spouse, a friend, a pastor, a deacon. You don't have to fix it today. You can just share the weight. Or let us walk with you. I'd invite you to come pray with our team at the front after the service. Reach out to a leader you know. There is comfort and hope waiting for you.
Koheleth's words should bring us comfort: you are not alone in feeling this way.
Three Broken Ways We Try to Shepherd Ourselves
Back to verse 1. In a world like this, how do we protect ourselves? The preacher shows us three broken ways we try to shepherd ourselves:
- Power
- Pursuit
- Passivity
First: Power
In verse 1, power is on the side of the oppressors. One way to protect ourselves in this unfair world is to make sure you're never on the losing side. Get the leverage, the money, the title, the influence.
Now, I'm guessing most of us aren't running a crime syndicate. But there's an acquired version of this: indifference. We protect ourselves by simply not looking at the pain of others. We scroll past the tears. We change the subject. We keep our circle quiet and comfortable.
Notice the preacher says it twice: "They had no one to comfort them." Not because there was no one around who could comfort them, but because no one would.
Second: Pursuit
People protect themselves by outrunning everyone else. Check verse 4:
All toil and all skill and work come from a man's envy of his neighbor.
If the system is rigged, maybe I can just outwork it. Outperform everyone. Bigger house, better resume, kids on the travel team, the best PR.
The preacher calls it what it is: striving after the wind. You can't catch the wind. You can't win a race that never ends, because there's always another one. There's always a faster runner. There's always a better neighbor.
Here's the reality: In the first part of the passage, Koheleth helps us take a pulse—our anger at the world is grounded when the world chooses wrong. But here in verse 4, he shows us that there's an anger and brokenness in us even when our neighbor does good. There's envy. It's not enough for me to have enough. You can't have it either.
Ezekiel saw this in the flock too. The strong sheep weren't content to just eat the good pasture. They trampled the rest. They drank the clean water and muddied what was left. They pushed with side and with shoulder at the weak. That is envy.
Third: Passivity
Finally, passivity. Verse 5 says:
The fool folds his hands and eats his own flesh.
Some of us look at the rat race and the rigged game and we just quit. Check out. Numb out. There's endless ways to do that. Why bother? It may feel like rest, but the preacher says it's slowly eating you alive.
Ezekiel says the sheep scatter on their own and become food for wild beasts. Checking out doesn't actually protect you. It just leaves you exposed.
The Same Result: Exhaustion
Power, pursuit, passivity. Fight, race, or quit. Three different strategies, the same result: exhaustion. Three ways of trying to be our own shepherd, and we make lousy shepherds.
But verse 6 gives us a better way:
Better is a handful of quietness than two hands full of toil and striving after the wind.
This is how most of us live our lives—gripping, defending, protecting with two full hands. Now picture one open hand. Not an empty hand—still full, but open. That's contentment. That's trust. That's saying, "God, you are enough. I have enough."
Listen to how God puts this in Ezekiel 34:15:
I myself will be the shepherd of my sheep. And I will make them lie down.
Here's the thing: Sheep don't lie down when they're anxious. But they do lie down when their shepherd is near. A handful of quietness isn't something we produce; it's something the shepherd gives.
Edward Reynolds calls this "sweet contentment with sufficient provision rather than vexation with great supply."
But hear me—this isn't the fool's folded hands from verse 5. The fool folds his hands in apathy. This hand is open to trust. One quits on life, and the other receives it as a gift.
Remember: life is gift, not gain. Fists are for gain. Open hands are for gift.
What Does This Look Like?
So what does that look like in real life?
- Maybe it's naming a rivalry you've been carrying and letting it go.
- Maybe it's taking a real Sabbath—one day where you stop proving and start receiving.
I had a friend remind me of this this week: We Sabbath not because all the work is done, but to remind ourselves that we are creation, not creator. And in defining our limits, we give glory to the One who is limitless.
- Or maybe it's moving toward someone else's pain, moving toward their tears instead of just scrolling past them.
Pick one. Open one hand.
Where Does Our Hope Actually Belong?
Here's where this all comes together. Life under the sun will never satisfy our hunger for fairness. Not if we expect human courts to deliver perfect justice, and not if we expect our own efforts to guarantee our security.
Underneath everything we've read this morning is the same question: "Why does life still feel so unfair?"
I said earlier that there is a place for righteousness. There is a place for justice. God has called us to act justly and live rightly. And the problem is we haven't. We cry out for things to be fair. But fair means we get what we deserve. And if we're honest, the line between good and evil really does run through our hearts.
We don't actually want fair. Fair means we're sitting in the defendant's chair, and the verdict is in—and it is not in our favor.
The Good News: Grace
But here's the good news: God didn't give us fair. He gave us something far greater.
If you want righteousness, if you want true justice—where do you find it?
This is where Ezekiel 34 turns. After the failed shepherds, God makes a promise:
I myself will search for my sheep. I will seek them out. I will seek the lost. I will bring back the strayed, and I will bind up the injured. I will strengthen the weak. I will feed them in justice.
Did you catch that? Justice and rest from the same shepherd.
Then verse 23:
I will set over them one shepherd, my servant David.
But David had already been dead for 400 years. So God was promising a new David—a son of David. And hundreds of years later, a descendant of David stood up and said:
I am the good shepherd, and I lay down my life for my sheep.
The Answer to Misplaced Hope
Remember the question from earlier? Where does a person like me place my hope?
You can't find it in a better judge. You can't find it in a stronger fence built to protect you. You find it in a shepherd who knows exactly what's in your heart and lays down his life for you anyway. It can only be found at the cross.
Jesus submitted Himself to the greatest act of human injustice in history so that we would be made right with God. An innocent man condemned in a rigged trial. In the place of justice, there was wickedness. And He hung there, abandoned by His friends. He was the oppressed one with no one to comfort Him. The good shepherd became the lamb led to the slaughter.
Romans 3 says:
God remained just and justified those who trust in Jesus at the cross.
The Judge—the one who judges between sheep and sheep—didn't look away from wrong. He took the sentence Himself. Every wrong made right, either paid for there or answered for on the last day.
He entered our mortality. He went down into the dust so that our hope would no longer depend on earthly outcomes. And three days later, He walked out of a grave.
Living in Light of the Cross
This means:
- We don't have to demand justice with clenched fists.
- We don't have to dodge it with locked doors.
- We can bring our own hearts into the light because the verdict was already carried by someone else.
Because God holds ultimate justice and gives ultimate grace, we can unclench our fists. We can stop trying to be our own shepherd. We can let go of the self-defense. And we can live with a handful of quietness.
Remember my wallet? I gave up on it. Six months later, it turned up. But here's the difference: You don't have to go searching for this hope. The good shepherd is the one who goes searching for you.
I will seek the lost.
Saints, hope in human justice will always run out. Hope in our own protection will always wear out. But hope in the good shepherd who laid down his life for you never does.
أُعدّ هذا النص بمساعدة الذكاء الاصطناعي من التسجيل الأصلي، وقد يختلف عن الكلمات المنطوقة. راجع التسجيل قبل الاقتباس. الإبلاغ عن تصحيح
استشهد بهذه العظة
للدروس والمقالات وملاحظات الدراسة. يذكر الواعظ والكنيسة ويربط بالتسجيل الأصلي.





