لم تُترجم هذه الصفحة بالكامل بعد. يظهر بعض النص أدناه أو كله بلغة English، وهي لغته الأصلية.
Why Our Work Cannot Carry Ultimate Meaning
Vanishing
Cam Stephens · Grant Church
Our work will never completely satisfy us on its own; meaning cannot be found in labor apart from God.
- الواعظ
- Cam Stephens
- الكنيسة
- Grant ChurchBaptistWinnipeg, Canada
- التاريخ
- زمن القراءة
- 14 دقيقة
- عدد الكلمات
- 3,063 كلمة
- اللغة
- الإنجليزية
المقاطع الكتابية
الوسوم
الفئات
شخصيات كتابية
الخلاصات
في هذه العظة▾
Why Our Work Cannot Carry Ultimate Meaning
When we first meet someone, the question of work almost always comes up early. Before hobbies, pet peeves, or family history, we ask, "What do you do for a living?" We often attach a person's profession to their introduction as if how they put food on the table were the most important thing one could know about them. Out of everything we could share about ourselves, we default to how we make money. That shows where our culture places its priorities and where we are encouraged to find identity, meaning, and purpose.
This is not a new temptation. Jesus was a carpenter, Peter a fisherman, and Paul a tentmaker. Throughout the early church, people are identified by their jobs: Simon the tanner in Acts 9, Lydia the cloth dealer in Acts 16, Aquila and Priscilla the tentmakers in Acts 18, and Zacchaeus the tax collector in Luke 19. We know these details because someone recorded them and judged them important. In Jesus' day, as in ours, what a person did for work was central to how others saw them.
The Preacher's Search for Meaning
The preacher of Ecclesiastes, King Solomon, has been searching for where meaning is ultimately found. He began with wisdom and the accumulation of knowledge. He then turned to worldly pleasure, indulgence, possessions, and success. Last week he looked at whether meaning comes from comparing ourselves with others. Each time he concluded that none of these pursuits offers a pot of gold at the end of the rainbow. Each one is like chasing the wind: temporary, like a breath that does not last and cannot ultimately satisfy.
Now he turns to work, asking in verse 22: "What has a man from all the toil and striving of heart with which he toils beneath the sun?" The ultimate question is about the net gain of our lives. Does the surplus we acquire through our labor give the life we have lived here its meaning?
"I Hated All My Toil"
The preacher gives his conclusion before he even states the question: "I hated all my toil in which I toil under the sun" (verse 18). He does not pull any punches. "Work stinks," he says. Most of us can relate at least in part. We may use different language than hate, but we understand that work is not where we find the happiness, fulfillment, and purpose we are looking for. Like wisdom, self-indulgence, and comparison, our work will never completely satisfy us on its own.
The preacher does not stop there. He explains why work is so unsatisfying, because we might be tempted to think the problem is simply that he was in the wrong line of work. Would he have been happy as a plumber, a teacher, or an accountant? He makes clear that his conclusion is not only about himself. It is a universal statement: work of any kind is not where any of us will ultimately be fulfilled, and expecting it to give us ultimate meaning is a futile experiment.
Solomon gives three reasons that our work is vanity.
First: Others Determine the Success of Our Labor
"I hated all my toil in which I toil under the sun, seeing that I must leave it to the man who will come after me. And who knows whether he will be wise or a fool. Yet he will be the master of all for which I toiled and used my wisdom under the sun." (Ecclesiastes 2:18–19)
The long-term success of our work is not up to us. No matter how many hours we put in, how hard we work, how pure our motives, or how brilliant our strategies, the end result will be at the mercy of someone else.
- An architect's buildings will eventually be left in someone else's hands, and a later decision may lead to their misuse, neglect, or demolition.
- A restaurateur's reputation for fresh food can be cheapened the day the business is sold and a new owner changes suppliers to cut costs.
- A CEO's healthy work culture can be undone the moment a replacement is hired.
- A landscaper's meticulously kept property can become overgrown after only a season or two of neglect.
Every task we do on this earth can be undone by those who come after us. Whether they prove wise or foolish, they will pass it on, and the dice are rolled again.
Solomon's own history confirms his worry. He was the richest and wisest king of Israel at the height of its success, yet he left the kingdom to his son Rehoboam, who within 17 years lost most of his father's wealth, provoked ten tribes to rebel, triggered a civil war and the division of the nation, and presided over widespread idolatry. Within two decades of Solomon's death, nearly everything was ruined. None of us will see the end of our toil under the sun. We will all leave it in the hands of others, and that should give us perspective on how much we invest in our work and how much of our identity we wrap up in it.
Second: Others Enjoy the Fruit of Our Labor
"Sometimes a person who has toiled with wisdom and knowledge and skill must leave everything to be enjoyed by someone who did not toil for it. This also is vanity and a great evil." (Ecclesiastes 2:21)
Even if we are successful, the fruit of our labor often goes to people who did nothing to earn it. The preacher considers this not only unfortunate but evil. We see it constantly: the children of a wealthy developer inherit a fortune with no respect for how it was built and no work ethic beyond spending it, and this rarely turns out well for either the inheritance or the next generation. In more ordinary homes, the houses our toil made possible are sold and their proceeds split among relatives, often through conflict, while the bank accounts of those who come after us grow from our years of effort.
Some might object that leaving a legacy for our children is a good desire, and it is. But the theologian Daniel Akin responds that even the legacy game fails, because our descendants will eventually waste what we worked so hard to build. Statistics suggest that in over 60 percent of cases, inherited wealth is gone by the end of the second generation. Wealth does not ensure comfort or happiness for the next generation, because like everything else under the sun it is temporary.
Leaving money behind is not wrong. Parents want their children to be secure. The danger is that in pursuing a strong future for our children, we sacrifice a strong present with them. We trade time with them now for money for them later. As Timothy Keller writes, "Work can convince you that you are working hard for your family and friends, while you're really being seduced through ambition to neglect them." I have never met anyone who wished their parents had worked more so they could have a larger inheritance. What people long for is one more day to talk, laugh, hug, and say "I love you."
Third: We Are the Ones Who Pay the Price
"What has a man from all the toil and striving of heart with which he toils beneath the sun? For all his days are full of sorrow, and his work is a vexation. Even in the night his heart does not rest. This is also vanity." (Ecclesiastes 2:22–23)
While others determine the success of our labor and enjoy its fruit, we are the ones who pay the price. Work brings sorrow, frustration, and vexation, and it often follows us home as anxiety. Many of us already know that work is hard, that it costs energy, time, and sometimes our sanity. Others of us, like the preacher for a time, are tempted to elevate work and look to it for validation and purpose, whether in the work itself or in what it brings: money, possessions, power, respect, or opportunity.
The preacher warns that the consequences fade and are left to others, but no one helps us carry the cost. Our paycheck may cost us our energy and sanity. Our reputation as a hard worker may cost us time with family and friends as we work overtime to impress the boss. A work email on our phone may cost us our mental health and the peace of being away from work. If we are honest, sometimes we pay more to work than it actually pays us.
That extra few thousand dollars in the bank will never be worth the games and recitals we missed. A promotion near the end of a career will never outweigh the homemade cards that say "world's best mom" or the love of a present husband or the presence of a faithful friend. The preacher's warning is this: be careful, because you are paying with a currency you cannot get back to secure something you will not keep.
Work Is Not the Enemy
So why is work vanity, according to the preacher? Because others determine the success of our labor, others enjoy the fruit of it, and we pay a steep price. Yet we need to work. Work is essential. Whether we grow our own food or earn a paycheck to buy it, we work to live. The conclusion is not that work is bad, and the action step is not to quit our jobs.
The warning is for those who elevate work above where it belongs, seeking worth and purpose through it or through what they believe it will provide. We can and should find satisfaction in our work, and we can and should enjoy some of its fruit. But if we look to our work to find purpose that outlasts today, we will not find it there.
At this point the preacher, who has offered few qualifications along the way, qualifies his words about work:
"There is nothing better for a person than that he should eat and drink and find enjoyment in his toil. This also I saw is from the hand of God, for apart from him, who can eat and who can have enjoyment?" (Ecclesiastes 2:24–25)
At first glance this seems to contradict everything he has just said. But the difference lies in one variable: God. In verses 18 to 23, work is vanity apart from God. In verses 24 and 25, the preacher says that enjoyment in work is a gift from the hand of God, and that apart from him no one can truly eat or find enjoyment at all.
Work as a Gift from God
The preacher qualifies everything he has said about work. Nowhere does he tell us to quit our jobs. It is true that we can enjoy some of the fruit of our labour, but if we look to our work to find purpose that transcends today, we will not find it there.
"There is nothing better for a person than that he should eat and drink and find enjoyment in his toil. This also I saw is from the hand of God, for apart from him, who can eat and who can have enjoyment?" (Ecclesiastes 2:24–25)
At first glance this seems to contradict everything he has just written. But the difference lies in one variable: God. In verses 18 to 23, work is vanity apart from God. In verses 24 and 25, enjoyment in work is a gift from God's hand, and apart from him no one can truly eat or find enjoyment at all.
God has entered the conversation. He gives meaning to what is under the sun. Our work can serve three important purposes when we see it as a gift from God rather than a god to serve: our provision, our joy, and God's glory.
Our Provision
The preacher asks, "Apart from God, who can eat?" Our sustenance comes from God, and for most of us he provides it through our work. If there is food on the table because of this month's paycheque, God has provided it through your work. Work is a gift from God for your provision.
Some will push back and say they earn their own paycheque, and God has nothing to do with it. Moses heard this same objection from the Israelites:
"You may say to yourself, 'My power and the strength of my hands have produced this wealth for me.' But remember the Lord your God, for it is he who gives you the ability to produce wealth." (Deuteronomy 8:17–18)
God gives us the knowledge, skills, capacity, contacts, training, body, mind, energy, and personality through which we do our jobs. Like everything we have, God is the giver. As James writes, "Every good and perfect gift is from above, coming down from the Father of heavenly lights who does not change like shifting shadows" (James 1:17). While we do not pursue work as our ultimate end, we ought to receive it with gratitude for the ways it puts roofs over our heads and food on our tables.
Our Joy
Work is also meant to bring us joy. When we see our work in light of God's ultimate purposes, we can find meaning in what we do. Work is not our ultimate purpose, but purpose and meaning are available in it nonetheless.
In The Gospel at Work, Sebastian Traeger and Greg Gilbert suggest that many Christians fall into one of two problems: they are either idle in their work or they have made an idol of it. We have already addressed the idol. But being idle is just as damaging. If we see work as the enemy, something to simply endure, we rob ourselves of daily meaning and joy. Scripture presents our work as a God-given invitation to participate with him in what he is doing in the world.
Consider the Garden of Eden. Before the fall, God placed Adam in the garden "to work it and to take care of it" (Genesis 2:15). Right after resting from creation, God invited Adam, Eve, and the rest of us to join him as co-labourers, caretakers of the world and instruments through whom he brings about his will on earth. We often assume hard work is the result of sin, as if God's original design was perpetual retirement. That is not true. Work was part of God's good creation before sin entered the world. Sin made work harder (Genesis 3), but work itself has never been our enemy or opposed to joy. Which is why the preacher can say that a person can find enjoyment in his toil.
You may think, "Cam has no idea what I do." Perhaps you need a different kind of work if you feel so strongly. But joy is available in every industry, with some sinful exceptions, because God himself is present in every industry, inviting us to partner with him as he did in the beginning.
Partnering with God in Our Work
What does this partnership look like? Four questions can help us reflect on it this week.
-
How does my work reflect God's character? Where do I see the heart of God in what I do? Is it in fixing what is broken, in thoughtful creativity or pursuing excellence, in upholding justice, or in bringing about order? We should do our best to bring this world more in line with the heart of God.
-
How does my work contribute to God's care for others? Whose needs am I meeting? Whose lives are improving because of what I do? How am I serving my neighbour? Let that motivation fuel us. We should think about who will ultimately benefit from our labour and work hard for their sake. As Paul writes, we are to "serve one another humbly in love" (Galatians 5:13), and that includes our workplaces.
-
Who has God placed at my work to tell about him? Who has God placed in my circle of influence through this job? Do my co-workers, clients, or customers need to know Jesus? How am I using this workplace to ensure those I work with have a chance to hear the gospel? Imagine standing before God and pleading, "I didn't know," when you worked alongside that person for fifteen years. Every person we come into contact with through work is loved by God and needs to know him. Knowing when and how to speak is delicate, and we should ask the Lord to lead us.
-
How can my work bring glory to God? Am I working in a way that honours God? Do my attitude, motives, and conduct align with what he desires? Is my work ethic and my treatment of employers or employees worthy of the calling of Jesus? Paul writes, "Whatever you do, work at it with all your heart, as working for the Lord, not for human masters. It is the Lord Christ you are serving" (Colossians 3:23–24). "But my boss is a jerk" is not an excuse.
When we let these answers shape how we go about our days under the sun, God is honoured and glorified. As the preacher says in verse 26, it pleases him.
Work That Lasts
The preacher returns once more to show how God changes everything about our work:
"For to the one who pleases him God has given wisdom and knowledge and joy, but to the sinner he has given the business of gathering and collecting, only to give to one who pleases God. This also is vanity and a striving after wind." (Ecclesiastes 2:26)
With God in the equation, we are released from the endless cycle of gathering and collecting that we will simply lose anyway. Apart from God, work will prove to be vanity and will never satisfy, because work is not a benevolent master. It takes and takes and gives nothing of lasting significance in return. But for the one who finds worth in God, who fixes their gaze on the one above the sun, he gives all our work meaning. He enters our toil, enlists us in every industry, and uses us in his ultimate work of pointing the world to his great labour: his saving work through death and resurrection, paying the cost so that we might inherit the fruit of his labour forever.
أُعدّ هذا النص بمساعدة الذكاء الاصطناعي من التسجيل الأصلي، وقد يختلف عن الكلمات المنطوقة. راجع التسجيل قبل الاقتباس. الإبلاغ عن تصحيح
استشهد بهذه العظة
للدروس والمقالات وملاحظات الدراسة. يذكر الواعظ والكنيسة ويربط بالتسجيل الأصلي.





