Don't Put God in a Box: Understanding the Second Commandment
The Ten Commandments Series, Week 2
Matt Adams · Foundation Church Belfast
True worship requires encountering God as he has revealed himself in Scripture, not reshaping him to fit our preferences or control his power
- Preacher
- Matt Adams
- Church
- Foundation Church BelfastReformedBelfast, United Kingdom
- Date
- Read time
- 13 min
- Word count
- 2,852 words
- Language
- English
Scriptures
Tags
Categories
Bible characters
Key takeaways
In this sermon▾
Understanding the Second Commandment
We find ourselves in week two of a series exploring the Ten Commandments. Last week we looked at the first commandment—"You shall have no other gods before me." Today, we turn to the second commandment, which addresses a truth that may seem uncomfortable: it is possible to worship the true God in a false way.
The Problem: Trying to Control God
What if we could sing to God, pray to him, and come to church every Sunday, yet the God we are worshiping is not the God who revealed himself to us in the Bible? This sounds impossible, but the second commandment confronts us with this reality.
The root issue is this: we want a God we can understand, see, and approach on our own terms. We want a God that fits nicely into our lives—one who agrees with our ambitions and affirms the decisions we make. We want to put God in a box.
But the God of the Bible cannot be placed in a box. He is not a creation of our imagination or a product of human hands. He does not exist to serve our purposes. He is the almighty creator God. He rules over us and commands us to worship him as he truly is.
Three Truths About God
Before we explore this commandment, we need to remember three essential truths about God:
First, God is almighty. He is the creator God—all-powerful, majestic, and holy. He spoke and the universe came into existence. When God appeared before the Israelites at Mount Sinai, "the smoke of it went up like the smoke of a kiln and the whole mountain trembled greatly." Imagine a mountain trembling before the almighty God.
Second, God commands us to obey. God has liberated his people, brought them out of Egypt, kept his promises to Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob, and sent Christ to die for us on the cross. Yet he commands obedience. But this is not a law of oppression. James 1:25 describes "the perfect law, the law of liberty." Deuteronomy 6:24-25 reminds us: "The Lord commanded us to obey all these statutes, to fear the Lord our God for our good always, that he may preserve us alive as it is this day." The law is good for us. It sets us free.
Third, God is a God of grace. When we fail, when we sin, when we break the commandments, God does not abandon us. Out of his love for us, he sent his Son to die on the cross.
What Is God Commanding?
The second commandment is clear:
"You shall not make for yourself a carved image or any likeness of anything that is in heaven above, or that is in the earth beneath, or that is in the water under the earth. You shall not bow down to them or serve them."
God is commanding us: do not make a carved image of me. This is distinct from the first commandment. The first commandment rejects all other gods. The second rejects the wrong worship of the true God. God wants to be served in no other way than he commands.
Old Testament Examples
Jeroboam's Golden Calves: Jeroboam was the first king of the northern kingdom of Israel after Solomon's death. He decided to create two golden calves and told the people, "This is the God that brought you out of Egypt." These were not new gods or different gods—they were meant to represent Yahweh himself. Jeroboam and the people worshiped them.
Micah's Carved Image: During the period of judges, a man named Micah built a chapel with a carved image of God inside. He even had his own private priest. When a group of 600 men attacked and took the image and the priest, Micah risked his life and the life of his neighbors trying to recover it. His sin against the second commandment spread consequences through Israel.
These examples show us that God does not want us to worship carved images. He does not want us to create an object representing him and gather around it in worship.
Why Does God Forbid This?
Neither Jeroboam nor Micah believed God actually looked like the objects they created. But they intended to control God's power. They wanted to possess the very power that rescued the Israelites from Egypt. They were trying to put God in a box—a box they could see, move around, and control.
To put God in a box misunderstands his majesty. It tries to make the incomprehensible comprehensible. The irony is that we do not control God. God is almighty. God controls us.
The Ark of the Covenant Lesson
First Samuel 14 provides another instructive story. The Israelites were attacked by the Philistines and lost 4,000 men. In desperation, the elders decided: "We'll bring the ark of the covenant to battle. That will mean we will win. God will be with us."
When the Israelites saw the ark, they shouted in joy. The Philistines heard this and thought, "God is in their camp. Surely we will be destroyed." But the Philistines did not flee. They kept fighting. The Israelites were defeated and lost 30,000 men.
The Israelites thought they could control God by bringing the ark. But the ark itself is not God. When the people tried to substitute it for trusting and obeying God himself, it became useless.
How much more dangerous, then, are the images that people create of God and worship? God does not want us to create carved images because it misunderstands his majesty and greatness. To capture Yahweh in an image is a fundamental misunderstanding of his very nature.
God's True Majesty
When God made his covenant with Israel and appeared, they did not actually see him. They saw smoke, darkness, and fire. They heard his voice. The mountain trembled with the almighty power of the Lord.
In Scripture, we see representations of God's glory: the emeralds, the throne, the power, lightning, flashes of thunder, the majesty and splendor of God. These stand in vast contrast to the golden calf and other carved images created throughout history—mere objects compared to the true majesty of the creator of the world.
True worship is not about possessing a religious object. It's not about creating a visible image or using religious practices. It's about faith and obedience to God. We cannot reduce God, contain him in an ark or a box. Any attempt to do this is an affront to God himself. He is the almighty God who controls us. He is magnificent.
The Warning and the Blessing
The second commandment includes both a warning and a blessing:
"For I, the Lord your God, am a jealous God, visiting the iniquity of the fathers on the children, to the third and fourth generation of those who hate me, but showing steadfast love to thousands of those who love me and keep my commandments."
God is a jealous God. This word describes God's zeal for his people. He desires our soul affection. He demands our exclusive devotion. He wants us to completely serve him and no one else.
The warning: if the head of a family turns away from God and worships images, this can have disastrous consequences for the family. Our sin affects those around us, especially when we are in a position of trust—as parents, leaders, or authority figures in the church. This is not saying we are punished for someone else's sins, but rather that our sin has real impact on our families and those we influence.
The blessing: God is a God of grace. When we fail and turn to him in repentance, he covers us through the blood of Christ. Verse 6 says: "but showing steadfast love to thousands of those who love me and keep my commandments." The almighty creator God shows favor to those who keep his commandments. What motivation to live our lives as he commands!
Is This Relevant Today?
You might think: "I don't create carved images of God. I don't have golden calves in my garden. Surely this commandment doesn't apply to me."
But I have news for you. This commandment is incredibly important for us today. It is incredibly important for the church today.
Here's how: Behind the golden calf and other physical images is a perspective—a way of thinking where people want to create an image of God that differs from revelation, an image they can control. There is little difference between the thought process that goes into making that image and the actual physical creation itself.
One commentator says: "Human understanding is a workshop where idols are continually being crafted."
Crafting False Images in Our Minds
Seeing God in a different way than he has revealed himself to us is breaking the second commandment. We can very easily fall into this trap—seeing God how we like him to be rather than how he actually is.
We can morph God into a worldly image that fits with our beliefs, worldview, and values:
- We can imagine God like Santa Claus—bringing us presents, and when we're bad, the punishment isn't that bad.
- We can create a God in our heads who is friendlier or stricter than he is.
- We can focus on God's judgment of sin while completely ignoring his grace.
- We can forget that God is a loving God as well as a holy God.
- We can see God as a vending machine—there only when we need something. Press the buttons, insert the prayer, and out comes divine healing or comfort.
- We can create a God that fits our ambitions, pushing away the parts of God we don't like.
Brothers and sisters, this is wrong. This is the sin of the second commandment. We are replacing the almighty God with an image of something else, just like the Israelites did.
Pursuing the True God
Instead of seeing God how he actually is—how he has revealed himself to us—we forget our very purpose. As the Shorter Catechism says, "Man's chief end is to glorify God and enjoy him forever." God must be glorified exactly how he has revealed himself to us. This results in our true enjoyment.
Watering down God, changing him in our heads and beliefs, destroys our true enjoyment of him.
To keep this commandment and resist our temptation to change God, we must throw ourselves into Scripture. We must remind ourselves through his teaching of who he actually is. We must embrace the totality of his revelation and learn what he has done. The true image of God is revealed in Scripture, and this will help us push out the false images we have crafted in our heads.
It's not only because he commanded us—though he did. The real reason is because he is the almighty God. Because he created us. Because he spoke and the universe came into existence. Because he is holy. And because he loves us. He sent his own Son to die for us on the cross. All these truths are the motivation we need to obey him out of love.
How God Calls Us to Worship
God, through Scripture, has revealed the ways we are supposed to worship him:
- Prayer
- Thanksgiving
- Reading the Word
- Preaching and hearing the Word
- Administration of the sacraments—baptism and communion
- Gathering in church
- Removing other idols from our lives
These are the primary ways we should approach the almighty, holy God—so that we do not change who he is, do not craft false images of him in our heads, and do not break the second commandment.
A Warning From History
I want to offer a word of caution. Good intentions often lead to something that isn't good. We must be careful that we worship God as he wishes, not craft other images.
Consider the Vatican in Rome. It is an incredible place with amazing art and architecture. But years ago, when my wife Ashley and I visited with my grandparents, we were taken aback by the idolatry surrounding us—statues in the halls, arches, and gardens. These are not innocent works of art.
There is a statue of Peter whose feet are completely rubbed away from the countless people who touch them. These statues are now worshiped. These images hold special power in people's lives. Many Catholics travel vast distances on pilgrimages to these holy sites, touching these objects. These have become objects that take glory away from God. They have broken the commandments.
In response, we felt led to pray—to pray against the darkness that has fallen, the things that take the joy away from who God really is.
I'm not trying to bash a particular sect or group. But this can happen in many different Christian circles:
- People travel to the River Jordan to collect "holy water." But the water is not holy—God is holy.
- The cross is a powerful symbol, but there is something wrong if the cross becomes the center of our worship, if that actual symbol becomes what we are worshiping rather than the almighty God.
We need to be careful as a church that we do not fall into this practice. This is not a ban against all objects or art. But we must be very, very careful that these objects—whatever they are—do not become more important to us than God himself. We must not produce idols of God.
Thomas Watson said: "The first commandment is about worshiping false gods, and the second commandment is about worshiping the true God in a false way."
A Searching Question
This commandment confronts us with a searching question: Have we made God in our own image? Have we shaped him to fit our preferences? Have we emphasized parts of his character while ignoring others—perhaps the parts that make us feel uncomfortable?
Have we created a God that fits our ambitions, that agrees with our decisions, that lets us live our lives however we want? The temptation is always there. The temptation to have a God we can manage, protect, summon when we need him, and hide away when we don't—like a genie in a lamp. A God who will fit into our lives however we want.
But this is not the God of Scripture.
The God of Scripture
This is not the God who spoke us into existence. This is not the God who made Mount Sinai tremble. This is not the God whose holiness caused his people to stand at a distance. This is not the God who sits on a throne surrounded by glory, worshiped by the host of heaven.
He is not a God we have created. He is a God who created us. He is not a God who exists to serve our purpose. We exist to glorify him. He is not a God who must fit into our lives. We must bring our lives into submission to him.
And yet—and this is extraordinary—the Almighty God, whose glory cannot be contained by anything we can make, has chosen to reveal himself to us through his Word and supremely through his Son, Christ Jesus.
We do not need to invent a God who loves us, because he sent the Savior. We do not need to invent a God who cares, because we read and we see what he has done. At the cross we see it most of all—the love of Christ.
We see God's holiness because sin is judged. We see God's justice because it is not ignored. We see God's grace because Christ gave himself for sinners.
Repentance and Return
When we fail to worship him correctly, when we fall into the trap of creating false images of God, the answer is not to hide away like Adam and Eve in the garden. The answer is to fall on our knees before God in submission and repent. Look again at Christ. Return to his Word. Worship God as he has revealed himself to us.
Let's be a church that refuses to put God in a box. Let's be a church that opens the Scriptures, learns who God truly is, and responds with reverence and obedience—because he is worth it.
Prayer
Father, we thank you so much for your commandments. We thank you for your perfect law—the law of liberation. Thank you that you gave it to guide us, to show us how we can live better lives for you.
Father, help us not to worship you in a false way. Let us not fall into the temptation to change who you really are, because you are perfect. You are holy. You are almighty. You are beautiful. You are exactly who we need.
Father, we thank you that when we slip up, when we fall and fail and fall into sin, you do not abandon us. You do not throw us away. We are still your sons and daughters, and our sins are covered by the blood of Christ who suffered and died for us on the cross. What an incredible gift. What an incredible sacrifice.
Father, help us all to worship you in a true way. What a wonderful God we have. Amen.
Transcript prepared with AI from the original recording and may differ from the spoken words. Check the recording before quoting. Report a correction
Cite this sermon
For lessons, articles and study notes. It credits the preacher and the church and links the original recording.





