Faithfulness in Returning | Esther 4 Women's Community Study
Book of Esther Study Series — Session 6
Women's Community Study 6 · Calvary Chapel Costa Mesa
True faithfulness requires a death to self—surrendering comfort, status, and self-protection to join God's redemptive work and identify with the suffering of God's people.
- Preacher
- Women's Community Study 6
- Church
- Calvary Chapel Costa MesaNon-DenominationalSanta Ana, United States
- Date
- Read time
- 17 min
- Word count
- 3,723 words
- Language
- English
Scriptures
Tags
Categories
Bible characters
Key takeaways
In this sermon▾
Faithfulness and True Identity in Crisis
Good morning. This is my first time teaching for the women's community study. I've been told to keep this to about 30-35 minutes, so I'll do my best to honor that time.
Before we dive into the text, I want to say this: I believe the book of Esther has such a powerful message for today. To me, it feels so much like the days we're living in. We often refer to these times as the post-Christian era—there's an absence of God's miraculous presence. The church today isn't always familiar with experiencing divine intervention the way the scriptures describe it.
Like Esther, the church often lacks a distinct biblical identity in the culture. If we're honest, there's a lot of compromise by the church in the West. We often live like the rest of the world while only claiming this distinction. One person put it this way: "We believe the right things but often want the wrong things." I feel that deeply.
This morning, I'm going to focus on Esther chapter 4 for the sake of time.
The Scroll of Joel and Spiritual Awakening
As we read, we come to the place where Esther has made it into the king's court. She's been chosen to be the next queen. She's living in comfort and luxury. But then there's a squabble between Haman and Mordecai. Haman, because Mordecai refuses to bow to him, desires to annihilate all the Jews in the empire. An edict has been sent out, sealed with the king's ring.
When the Jews learn of this threat, they turn to mourning, fasting, weeping, and wailing. Now, this is customary for the Jewish people, but the author seems to be using these specific words intentionally. It's fascinating because these exact words were written 400 to 500 years prior by the prophet Joel.
In Joel 2:12-17, the prophet writes:
"Even now, declares the Lord, return to me with all your heart, with fasting and weeping and mourning... He is gracious and compassionate, slow to anger and abounding in steadfast love, and he relents from sending calamity. Who knows? He may turn and relent and leave behind a blessing..."
I believe the Jewish people—Mordecai and this community—have the scroll of Joel. They see judgment coming, and they actually obey Joel's instruction to return to the Lord with fasting, weeping, and mourning. This is not just cultural mourning; it's a spiritual revival, a return to faithfulness to Yahweh. There is a spiritual awakening happening here, and the author is intentionally dropping these hints so we understand what is really going on beneath the surface.
Esther's Comfortable Distance
Meanwhile, Esther is radically clueless. She lives in the palace—an image of security, comfort, and ease. She's totally removed from this threat, far away from the fight. When she learns of Mordecai's distress, she seeks more details. She's probably never seen anything like this. She can't understand why he refuses fresh clothes, why he's wearing sackcloth and ashes.
Mordecai sends word through her servant about what is happening: an edict has gone out for the annihilation of all the Jews. He asks Esther to go to the king and beg for mercy on behalf of her people.
Esther's response is completely rational given her situation: "No one can go into the king's presence unless invited. This means death for me."
The Choice Between Two Deaths
But Mordecai's message back to Esther is what really interests me. He responds:
"Do not think because you are in the palace you alone of all the Jews will escape. If you remain silent at this time, relief and deliverance for the Jews will arise from another place, but you and your father's family will perish. And who knows but that you have come to your royal position for such a time as this."
This is the climax and turning point of Esther's story. Will she put her life on the line, join in solidarity with the suffering of the people of God, taking up her true identity? Or will she insulate herself from this threat, from pain, from suffering?
Now, Mordecai's warning is particularly interesting. He tells her, in essence, that no palace wall, no amount of luxury, royal status, insulation, or protection will keep her from this threat. But then he gives an even deeper warning: "You and your father's family will perish."
Wait—that's odd. Esther is an orphan. Her family has already perished. Her father's house is gone; they didn't carry on his name. So what is Mordecai really saying?
I believe Mordecai is saying: You have a choice between the threat of death and the death of your true self. You face the death of your identity with the people of God, the death of your connection to God's story and God's hope.
This reminds us that there are things worse in life than dying. There are things worse than physical death. Specifically, to lose who you really are. To never discover that you've been made by God, made for God, supremely loved. To be made for glory, to be made to rule and reign over the new creation with the Lord Jesus Christ. This is a tragedy of all tragedies.
The book of Hebrews describes this with Moses:
"By faith, when Moses had grown up, he refused to be known as the son of Pharaoh's daughter. He chose to be mistreated along with the people of God, rather than to enjoy the fleeting pleasures of sin. He regarded disgrace for the sake of Christ as of greater value than the treasures of Egypt because he was looking ahead to his reward."
What is worse than physical death? To bury your God-given identity. To reject the meaning and purpose that God has placed upon your life. Or as Jesus puts it: to gain the whole world, to be rich in all the ways this life has to offer, and yet not be rich toward God. To insulate ourselves from all fear, threat, pain, and suffering, and yet still lose the very essence of who we are.
The Post-Christian West and Our Divided Loyalties
I see in Esther's story a prophetic story for our time. Since I can remember, people have talked about the end of the Christian era—the post-Christian West. The church has become obsolete. We are unimportant. We are no longer the culture maker, the light to the nations that we once were.
But this hasn't happened by annihilation, as in the book of Esther. It has happened by a slow burn. We have been colonized more and more by the culture around us. Our desires, our identity, our value, and purpose have been shaped by culture, not by the biblical vision, not by the word of God, and not by the spirit of God.
There are so many reasons for this. There is failure by the church to actually live as the people of God. There is failure by Christian leaders to represent the shepherd heart of our King—they pretend to be CEOs and rulers who lord over people, when Jesus said very specifically, "It will not be this way among you."
But there is also what I mentioned earlier: compromise in the way that we live. We live much more like the world around us, rather than with this distinct identity and values shaped by the kingdom of God.
Christian writer Michael Goheen writes in Introducing Christian Mission Today:
"The church of the West often fails to live up to its high calling. This is because it's hamstrung by a low spiritual state, a lukewarm love for Jesus Christ. There's a sickly worldliness and a lack of vital prayer. The reason? Self-satisfaction that comes from comfort, compromise with consumerism and capitalism, and an accommodation to the consumeristic spirit of our age."
In the Western world, we are so enamored with individualism and the freedom to express that individualism. Our culture tells us: "Find a philosophy, a religion, a way of life that gives the most autonomy, the most freedom, and the most ability to express the authentic self."
We hear this all the time—conversations with our children, our grandchildren. They're being inundated with this culture, not just in school and media, but on their smart devices regularly. And it's not even something that's necessarily being taught; it's being caught. They feel it. It's the water they're swimming in.
Freedom Without Meaning
I think the conversation we need to have as parents, as grandparents, as those who truly believe in the biblical vision, is not about freedom, but about meaning. Because our culture can offer us infinite, unlimited freedom, but yet little meaning.
What is the purpose of your life? What will it amount to? What will it accomplish in the end?
But Christianity—we all know this—offers us limited freedom, yet infinite meaning. You have been created by God. You have been created for God. Your life is more than your worst day; it's more than your best day. Your life is more than your accomplishments; it's more than your failures. You have been created by God in his image to one day rule over the cosmos.
I'm a big fan of C.S. Lewis. One of my favorite essays he wrote was in The Weight of Glory, where he talks about how, really, "you and I, we have never met a mere mortal." He talks about how culture and buildings and all these things are mortal, but actually human beings are eternal beings. Each one of us is headed towards one of two destinations: either something so horrible you only meet it in your worst nightmares—becoming more and more in the image of a beast rather than in the image of God—or a being so divine and beautiful that we would be tempted to worship.
We've never met a mere mortal.
The world around us is offering us unlimited freedom, pleasure, self-expression. But what about meaning? This meaning can only be found in the biblical narrative. We've been created, given identity and purpose to live out, and we're told that only through Jesus Christ can we discover the way to truly live in that meaning and that freedom.
A Surprising Return to Faith
I think it's important to note that we're in a significant moment right now. I'm noticing a fallout, a disillusionment with the culture's promise of freedom. It's not enough.
There are many stories, especially happening in Europe right now but also in waves in the US: people who grew up in the church, who bashed the church, who pronounced themselves atheists and renounced Christianity, are now changing their tune. They're talking about prayer. They're talking about divine presence and practicing it. There's a surprising rebirth of belief in God.
Rather than seeing what so many predicted—the death of Christianity and the triumph of secularism—we're seeing a flood of stories. Intellectuals, academics, cultural influencers are now returning to Christian roots, returning to the church. Why? Because they found that this secular identity narrative cannot deliver on its promises. Humans are meaning-seeking creatures.
For some, this has come about through profound suffering or personal crisis. For others, it's come through dissatisfaction and disillusionment. For Esther, it came in an unexpected moment. She wasn't looking for it; it found her out and exposed her need.
But it doesn't have to happen that way—so dramatically for us. I believe that God offers us so many opportunities to return to him, so many opportunities for repentance, to turn back to him. And this is one of those moments in the story of scripture to rejoin with the people of God, to take hold of their identity, belonging, and purpose.
So I wonder even just this morning with this conversation: What does that look like for you? Where are you on the scale of faithfulness? Are you Mother Teresa? Or are you Janis Joplin? The truth is, most of us—myself included—we're more like Princess Diana: divided in our loyalty. Generous and philanthropic, yet spending millions on ourselves and our outward appearance. Divided in our loyalty.
"Who Knows?"
Mordecai actually gives Esther a word of hope. His final word to her is: "Who knows but that you have come to your royal position for such a time as this?"
It's interesting—whenever we talk about Esther, we focus on "for such a time as this." But I think the key is actually the "Who knows?" That's the hinge. That's the invitation of the book of Esther.
Why? Because Mordecai is quoting Joel. The prophet says, "Return to the Lord your God." Why? Because he's gracious, compassionate, slow to anger, and abounding in love. He's quoting Exodus 34:6-7—the Bible's favorite verse to talk about the character of our God. He says, "He relents from sending calamity. Who knows? He may turn and leave behind a blessing."
I love that open-ended invitation. "Who knows?" We don't know what will happen next or what the total outcome of any situation will be. But here is what we know: We know the proven character of God. If we turn or return to the Lord, he is gracious, compassionate, slow to anger, abounding in love. In our God there is healing, there is life, there is hope, there is infinite meaning and purpose.
"Who knows?" Really, I think the invitation is ours. The choice is ours.
Esther's Three Days of Transformation
Esther tells them to reply to Mordecai: "Go, gather all the Jews to be found in Susa and hold a fast on my behalf. Do not eat or drink for 3 days, night or day. I and my young women will also fast as you do. Then I will go to the king, though it is against the law, and if I perish, I perish."
Mordecai then went away and did everything as Esther had ordered him.
I believe that Esther is giving us a biblical textbook example of what true faithfulness looks like. She recognizes the seriousness and inescapable nature of this threat that's coming. She enters a 3-day fast.
Now, 3 days is always significant in scripture. Why? On the third day. Right. Think about how many times in the biblical narrative, new life and hope spring up on the third day.
These 3 days of fasting, grieving, mourning, and weeping—asking all the people of God to join her—will produce in her a transformation of character. What we see here is actually a picture of death and resurrection. Death and new life.
She comes out of this with a bold and renewed identity with the people of God. She goes from blending in with the Persians, hiding her name and her true identity, to boldly and cunningly facing down the enemy to his face. She proclaims her name and place among the people of God and becomes an agent of God's salvation and redemption for his people.
Rather than using her position and place for herself, her comfort, her protection, her benefit, she uses it for the sake of her people. She uses what she has to play her part in God's redemption, putting her life on the line in order to save her people.
Sounds a lot like somebody else we know, doesn't it?
The Pattern of Death and Resurrection
We see a new birth, renewed spiritual life, and awakening. Scripture is consistent: It only comes about by a death. This is the consistent pattern for the people of God. Something must die in order for much fruit to come.
Jesus, the master, the way, the truth, and the life, says it many times. In Mark 8:
"Whoever wants to save their life will lose it. But whoever loses their life for me and for the gospel will save it. What good is it for someone to gain the whole world yet forfeit their soul?"
And John's version in John 12:
"Unless a kernel of wheat falls to the ground and dies, it remains only a single seed. But if it dies, it produces many seeds, a great harvest. Anyone who loves their life will lose it. While anyone who hates their life in this world will keep it for eternal life. Whoever serves me must follow me."
It is through the death of Jesus Messiah that the way is opened up for salvation, for life, for redemption for many. But what we often fail to remember is this: The way of Jesus doesn't mean, as people used to say, "Jesus died so you don't have to."
No. Dietrich Bonhoeffer puts it more accurately: "When Christ calls a person, he bids them come and die." This is the consistent message of the New Testament. When we turn our lives over to Jesus Christ, this is what God begins to do in us: to redeem us, to bring us back to our true identity and our created purpose, to use our lives for a greater meaning and purpose beyond ourselves, to bring about and be a partner in his beautiful work of redemption and salvation in the world.
His faithfulness can make us faithful. But it requires a kind of death. One that is truly necessary so that we might live.
The Gospel Thread in Esther
One of the main messages of Esther is that personal renewal, finding our true identity and meaning, comes only through a death to self. We see this in Esther's fasting, mourning, putting on sackcloth, putting her life on the line—a kind of death to self. And with that, you can begin to see the gospel and redemptive thread of this story.
Esther, the royal queen of the known world, lays aside her royal garments and takes upon herself the garments of brokenness, weeping, and mourning. She enters the pain of her people, afflicting her body. Then three days later, she courageously walks into her own potential death as her people's representative. She outwits the serpent-like character, Haman, and saves her people from annihilation, bringing them salvation and blessing.
But listen: Our way back to God, to renewal and to an identity in him, to our created purpose and meaning, is through the Son, Jesus Christ. He himself took on the affliction and cause of his people. He went through suffering and death. Three days he was laid in the tomb without water or food. Yes, for others there was weeping and mourning. But at the end of three days he rose to new life, a new creation. He outwitted the serpent, triumphed over him through death, and is now exalted to the right hand of God, securing blessing and hope for his people now and in the age to come.
Here's the thing I want to close with: This is the pattern. This is the pattern that God is working in you. This is the pattern that God is working in me. A continually handing over of ourselves to God into this process. And what feels like a death, the end for us, actually works to bring an expansion in our capacity to understand God's redemptive ways. An expansion to understand God's new life that he has birthed in us and God's new life that he is birthing in the world.
This is the model for our lives: dying to self that we might live for him.
Faithfulness Looks Like Jesus
I asked earlier: "Where are you on the faithfulness to God scale?" But the real question is this: Are you measuring yourself by the standards we've created, the labels we wear, the benchmarks we set as Christians?
For me, in the last probably 10 years of my life, I've had such a deep conviction: Faithfulness looks like the life of Jesus. And the life of Jesus, though blessed and good and true, is a life of suffering. He's a man of sorrow. He's a man acquainted with grief. He's not a man of comfort. He's not a man of luxury. He's not a story of worldly prosperity.
But guys, these are the waters that we are constantly swimming in. These are the success stories that we are constantly being told. And yet the gospel is radically subversive. It says almost the exact opposite.
The only way to have a life of meaning is to hand it over. To actually give yourself to the brokenness of the world. To give yourself to sorrow. To give yourself to identify with the weak, with the mourning, with the suffering. To follow in the way of Jesus. That is the mark of faithfulness for the people of God.
As I was thinking about this, I asked: "Okay, Lord, I might have a standard by which I think I'm doing okay right now in my life. But what am I comparing that to?" And scripture would say that always needs to be according to the way of Jesus.
This isn't about beating ourselves up or feeling bad. It's an invitation. It's interesting that Jesus's words at the beginning of the gospel are: "Repent, for the kingdom of God is here." It doesn't sound like the way we think of repent. It would sound more like: "Children, turn around, you're going the wrong way."
So I wonder this morning, as we think about faithfulness, as we think about this story, as we think about these opportunities to turn to and return to the Lord: How might the spirit of God be saying to each of us, "Children, you're going the wrong way." This thing that you're after, this life of success that you are so hard at work, your identity and reputation that you spend so much time on—you're going the wrong way. You won't find the deep meaning, solid identity that you're looking for in that way.
Turn around and follow me. Turn around and be my disciple. Measure your success not by the world and its ever-fickle standards. Measure yourself by the faithfulness of Jesus. Follow him.
The Invitation
That's my word. That's my invitation for us this morning: In what ways might the spirit of God be inviting us deeper into this cruciform, my life for your life, others-oriented way of Jesus, today? Maybe in our relationships, our marriage, our family, our work environment, in this community.
My prayer is that the spirit of God will give clear conviction and direction to our lives.
Transcript prepared with AI from the original recording and may differ from the spoken words. Check the recording before quoting. Report a correction
Cite this sermon
For lessons, articles and study notes. It credits the preacher and the church and links the original recording.





