Skip to main content
Back to sermons

Holy Eucharist, Harvest Thanksgiving

Harvest Thanksgiving

All Saints Cathedral

Thanksgiving is not about comparison or guilt, but about gratitude for what we have now.

Sign in to save Sign in to mark completedSign in to keep this private.
Church
All Saints CathedralAnglicanHalifax, Canada
Date
Read time
7 min
Word count
1,545 words
Language
English

Scriptures

CitedQuoted
Matthew 6

Tags

Categories

ThanksgivingHarvest

Bible characters

Jesus

Key takeaways

Share this quote

In this sermon▾

Thanksgiving Beyond Comparison

Good morning, and welcome to Thanksgiving weekend at the Cathedral Church of All Saints. Thanksgiving is our theme today, and the displays around us and the cool temperatures inside the cathedral both point to the season. In our Canadian context, we are called to remember the amazing and varied gifts of harvest, the bounty that this land and sea provides, and the people whose hands have joined in the creative process to bring it to fruition.

The Thin Edge Between Blessing and Calamity

Even a quick glance at the world reminds us of the thin edge between blessing and calamity. It may be forces of nature, like the recent back-to-back hurricanes Helen and Milton, or the more sinister, human-induced tragedies like the deepening crisis in the Middle East or the seemingly endless conflict in Ukraine. We know the balance can quickly tip from thankfulness to despair, and it can happen in our individual lives as well. We are all vulnerable.

The stories of those on the precarious boundary of being unhoused, or unable to adequately feed themselves and their families, are ones we are all too familiar with. But Thanksgiving is not about viewing life by comparison, either, or being prompted by guilt or fear. We may well say to ourselves, "I'm so thankful I'm not like those poor souls in Florida," or "there but for the grace of God go I." While this is perhaps a heartfelt and honest response, it is not really what Thanksgiving is about.

The Roots of Thanksgiving

Thanksgiving weekend in Canada is typically more secular than religious, and here it is tied to the time of harvest and gathering to give thanks for the bounty of the earth. Growing up in the United States, this holiday fell in late November, always on a Thursday, and late November is long past harvest time. That date is rooted in remembering a day when the first European settlers in America, in the 1600s, gave thanks for surviving their first year in a strange and sometimes harsh environment, one that had claimed the lives of half of their number. They were simply thankful to be alive, and grateful for the hospitality shown to them by the native inhabitants who helped them adapt as they prepared to face another harsh New England winter.

Even in these secular celebrations, we are being asked to step out of ourselves long enough to recognize that there is more to life than just us. Contemporary theologian Walter Brueggemann writes that we have become obsessed with consumption and accumulation. The gospel that spews nonstop from our televisions, computers, and other media is that happiness is about having more. Our need to accumulate, he suggests, is rooted in our survival instinct, a drive to store up enough food to get through the winter. But today, our accumulating has nothing to do with survival. Instead, it comes from our anxiety, our worry that others may get more than us, that there isn't enough to go around.

How often have we heard of some kind of crisis looming on the horizon, and the first reaction is to go to Costco and stock up on toilet paper? At a fundamental level, our need to accumulate is rooted in a fear that if we don't grab our share, we will be left out. We simply do not trust that God's providence will be sufficient to give us what we need.

Do Not Worry

Today we hear a teaching of Jesus that confronts this reality head-on:

"Therefore I tell you, do not worry about your life, what you will eat or what you will drink, or about your body, what you will wear. Is not life more than food, and the body more than clothing?" (Matthew 6)

What is it we are really hungry for, and what do we fear we are missing?

Looking at the Prairies

About ten years ago, my son and I flew to Vancouver. For him, it was the start of a new chapter in his life's journey as he began postsecondary education. For my wife Francis and me, it was also a new chapter, as we adjusted to life back here with one less child, and to the physical and emotional distance between Halifax and Vancouver. We were winging our way west, further west than I had ever adventured before. Detroit had been my western boundary to that point.

I looked down from our vantage point of some 40,000 feet on a beautiful sunny September day, and below me I marveled at the vast, seemingly endless prairies stretching out to the horizon. Even at our air speed of some 400 miles an hour, the landscape seemed unvaried by time. It is perhaps cliché, but it did seem like a giant quilt spread out before me: squares and rectangles of brown, yellow, and green, pieced together and occasionally bisected by a lone road, straight as a ruler, connecting two unknown, distant points. For those of you who may remember the TV show Corner Gas, in its opening theme there was a line that read, "If your dog ran away, it would take three days." I could appreciate that now. The view was both inspiring and haunting: how vast and varied a country this is. Arriving some hours later in Vancouver and seeing my first view of that city, with the snowcapped mountains rising to the north, underscored the diversity and beauty from coast to coast.

On our second day in the city, we visited the Vancouver Art Gallery, where one of the featured artists was a photojournalist by the name of Robert Adams. Adams had spent much of his life photographing the Midwest plains. His black-and-white images captured for me that sense of the vast, mysterious emptiness I had seen the day before from 40,000 feet up. But I was struck by a quote from Adams printed on stark white walls between two of his framed pictures. Here is what his quote said:

"We tend to define the prairies by what is absent: checking maps to find how far we have to drive before we get to something: mountains in the west or cities in the east. What, after all, are we to make of wheat fields, one-room towns, and endless sky? We tend to define the prairies by what is absent."

At first glance, his photos seemed somber and bleak. Yet his eye and his lens found the hidden beauty, the unique wonder, and the mystery in the vast landscape. It is not about what is absent, but discerning what is right before us.

Seeing What Is Ours Now

It struck me that this is a reminder for all of us as we enter this season of Thanksgiving, as we approach winter: to look with fresh vision, not on what we are losing or have lost, or what we are missing, or longingly what we wish we possessed, but on what is ours now, in this moment. We often tend to do that, don't we? We continually strive for more, for bigger, for better, for what lies just beyond our grasp. And in that striving, we become blind to the present. If we fail to achieve what we believe we truly need, what will really make life better for us, what will at last perhaps make us happy, then we are overcome with a sense of failure and loss when those things are not realized.

Jesus says, "Look at the birds of the air; they neither sow nor reap nor gather into barns, yet your heavenly Father feeds them. Are you not of more value than they?"

Thanksgiving as Interdependence

Thanksgiving is not a time to proclaim our independence or our self-sufficiency. It is a time to recognize the virtue of interdependence: the recognition that our achievements are not fully our own, but emerge out of a network of relationships that sustain and shape us, giving us the materials from which we create our experiences, moment by moment, and weave the story of our lives.

Thanksgiving as a spiritual practice reminds us that all our gifts are communal as well as individual. Our creativity and freedom, our ability to choose the good and the noble, have their origins in forces bigger than us: in God, in this good earth, and in the persons who have guided, protected, inspired, and nurtured us on our life's journey.

The Reverend Bill Elliff writes that every human being has one foundational choice every single day, and this choice determines everything. This singular decision makes the difference whether we will be joyful or upset, peaceful or discontent, usable or useless, wise or foolish, intimate or distant from God. And here is the choice: will I choose right now, this day, to praise God with humble gratitude, or not?

I once had a poster of a valley with rolling fields, flowers, and trees, a mountain in the background, and in the foreground a still pond. On the bottom of the poster were these words by Thomas Blake:

"Every morning lean your arms a while upon the window sill of heaven and gaze upon the Lord. Then with this vision in your heart, turn strong to meet your day."

Thanks be to God. Amen.

Transcript prepared with AI from the original recording and may differ from the spoken words. Check the recording before quoting. Report a correction

Share

Cite this sermon

For lessons, articles and study notes. It credits the preacher and the church and links the original recording.

“Holy Eucharist, Harvest Thanksgiving”, All Saints Cathedral, Sunday, 13 October 2024. Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bUnspzvgnm4&t=1174s Transcript: https://sermonregistry.com/en/sermons/holy-eucharist-harvest-thanksgiving-2024-10-13?utm_source=citation#sermon-transcript

Guided discovery

Find a sermon for where you are.