Jesus Crucified: An Eyewitness Account
Good Friday
Church in Toronto
John's eyewitness account presents Jesus' crucifixion without dwelling on physical agony, instead emphasizing the accomplished purpose and meaning of his death.
- Church
- Church in TorontoOtherToronto, Canada
- Date
- Read time
- 17 min
- Word count
- 3,806 words
- Language
- English
Scriptures
Tags
Categories
Bible characters
Key takeaways
In this sermon▾
Introduction: An Eyewitness Account
The whole thought of our Good Friday service is Jesus crucified: an eyewitness account. Think about what it means to be an eyewitness to something — someone who has firsthand knowledge of what they have heard, what they have seen, and what they have experienced.
From John chapter 19 and 20 we read:
When Jesus saw his mother and the disciple he loved standing there, he said to his mother, "Woman, here is your son." Then he said to the disciple, "Here is your mother." And from that hour the disciple took her into his home.
One of the soldiers pierced his side with a spear, and at once blood and water came out. He who saw this has testified so that you also may believe. His testimony is true, and he knows he is telling the truth.
This is the disciple who testifies to these things and who wrote them down, and we know that his testimony is true.
The Beloved disciple we've been looking at over the last number of months is John, the author of this gospel. He was there at the cross — an eyewitness. He is seeing things, hearing things, experiencing things, seeing what Jesus is also experiencing. Other disciples were not there — no Peter, no James, none of the others. The story we are reading here originated from John's eyewitness account because of what he saw, what he heard, and what he experienced. So the question is: what did John want us to see from his unique perspective as an eyewitness?
John Gives Us an Elevated Picture of Jesus' Crucifixion
What's striking about the account John gives us is there's no agony, no gruesome details about what Jesus went through on the cross. You may find that in other gospels, but that is not the perspective John is giving us here. John does say that Jesus was flogged, but he uses one simple word for it and carries on. He does say Jesus was crucified, but again it's just one simple word, and he carries on. Why is John downplaying the agony and the suffering that we know Jesus went through?
This is quite a contrast to what we've seen over the last couple of decades — some of you may remember Mel Gibson's The Passion of the Christ, a gruesome, blow-by-blow, detailed account of what Jesus suffered on the cross. But here's what's striking: not one of the New Testament gospel writers ever goes into that kind of detail about what Jesus went through on the cross. The goal of the gospel accounts of Jesus' crucifixion isn't to make you and me feel pity or sympathy for Jesus.
Leon Morris has this to say, and I think it's helpful:
"John describes the horror — yes, the horror — that was crucifixion in a single word: 'They crucified him,' as in the case of the scourging or the flogging in 19:1 he simply mentions the fact and passes on. Popular piety, both Protestant and Catholic, has often emphasized the suffering of Jesus. It has dwelt on the anguish the Savior suffered. None of the gospels does this. The evangelists — that is, the gospel writers — record the fact and let it go at that. The death of Jesus for sinners was their concern, not what he went through. They make no attempt to play on the heartstrings of their readers."
So we see what has been accomplished for us through what he went through — not a dwelling on the suffering itself.
Jesus Did Not Feel Abandoned by God on the Cross
Another elevated perspective John gives us is that Jesus' crucifixion also means he did not feel abandoned by God on the cross. This might surprise you. If you know Matthew, Mark, and Luke, you know that one of the things Jesus said on the cross is, "My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?" That statement is not in the Gospel of John at all — again, because the perspective is quite different. It's not about suffering; it's not about being abandoned.
Gail O'Day's comment on this is helpful:
"The key to the dignity and serenity that surrounds Jesus' death in John are the words 'It is finished.' Jesus dies with a public proclamation of the completion of his mission on his lips... The words he speaks on the cross in Mark 15:34, 'My God, my God, why have you forsaken me,' are a theological impossibility for the Johannine Jesus."
The Jesus that John is presenting could never have said those kinds of words, because God and Jesus are united in work and in love, and that unity is strengthened — not broken — at Jesus' death. Jesus' death fills him neither with despair nor a sense of abandonment by God, because he knows that he has lived fully the life and mission God gave him to live. So there are no gruesome details, no agony on display, and no sense that Jesus is feeling abandoned by the Father.
Jesus Lifted Up and Exalted
One last point: John's elevated perspective of Jesus being crucified also means that John saw him in a different way than others saw him. For John, he saw Jesus on the cross lifted up — exalted, enthroned on the cross. A painting by Salvador Dalí captures this perspective: this is not the cross on the earth as we normally see it. There's no crown of thorns, no nails holding Jesus on that cross — no nails in his hands, no nails in his feet. Why? Because the perspective John is giving us is that Jesus is elevated, lifted up — so that he can save people from their sins.
The Second Reading and the Theme of Unity
From John 19:23-30:
When the soldiers crucified Jesus, they took his clothes and divided them into four parts, a part for each soldier. They took the tunic, which was seamless, woven in one piece from the top. So they said to one another, "Let's not tear it, but cast lots for it to see who gets it." This happened that the scriptures might be fulfilled that says, "They divided my clothes among themselves, and they cast lots for my clothing." This is what the soldiers did. Standing by the cross of Jesus were his mother, his mother's sister, Mary the wife of Clopas, and Mary Magdalene. When Jesus saw his mother and the disciple he loved standing there, he said to his mother, "Woman, here is your son." Then he said to the disciple, "Here is your mother." And from that hour the disciple took her into his home. After this, when Jesus knew everything was now finished, that the scriptures might be fulfilled, he said, "I am thirsty." A jar full of sour wine was sitting there, so they fixed a sponge full of sour wine on hyssop and held it up to his mouth. When Jesus had received the sour wine he said, "It is finished." Then, bowing his head, he gave up his spirit.
We're at the middle section of John's account. John was the last gospel written, quite a few decades after the event, so John had a lot of time to consider: what is the effect? Yes, Jesus died on the cross — this is how it happened — but what is the impact? What has it done for us? We're getting a retrospective view. John is not writing an account as it happens; he's writing it after the fact, looking back at the result, the fruit of Jesus' death on the cross and how it impacts us. There are three things to draw out here.
1. Jesus' Clothing and the Garment Woven from Above
John recounts what happened to Jesus' clothing. The other gospels mention it also — they say the soldiers divided his clothing and cast lots, taking about six or twelve words in Greek. John expands that; he takes 67 words to describe it in more detail. So we have to ask what John wants us to get from this.
Jesus was wearing two kinds of garments: an outer garment and an inner garment. The outer garment they tore and divided into four parts, one for each of the four soldiers. The inner garment, as we read, was a tunic — seamless, woven in one piece from the top. Only John tells us that detail; he wants us to get that it's significant.
They divided my clothes, and cast lots for my clothing.
Yes, they fulfilled scripture, and the soldiers did it in fulfillment, but John wants us to get something more. The tunic — the inner garment of Jesus — was in one piece, woven from the top: from the neck down, woven as one piece all the way, no seams, no stitching, all the way down to the bottom. It was a unity.
John has an emphasis in his gospel on unity, on oneness: the people of God are one flock with one Shepherd; they are one vine, branches in the one vine; they are one people of God, one family. The phrase "the garment was woven from the top" can also be rendered "from above."
John 19:23... could be translated "his tunic was entirely woven from above."
This word, anōthen — "from above" — comes up several times in John's gospel. Jesus tells Pilate a few chapters back, "You would have no authority over me unless it was given to you from above" — meaning given to you by God. Jesus, in chapter 3, tells Nicodemus, "You must be born again" — the same word in Greek, so you could say "you must be born from above, from God."
So, apply the same idea here: yes, Jesus physically had one inner garment that was woven from the top, one piece. But if we take this as a metaphor for the unity of the church, it is something from above, from God. The unity of the church is not something humanly produced — not humanly negotiated, arranged, or coordinated. It is something from God, from above.
Alan Culpepper writes:
"The tunic was woven from the top, or from above. Through the whole garment, this suggests that the seamless tunic was related to John's repeated emphasis on the unity of the church. Metaphorically, of course, Jesus prays in John 17 that they all may be one. Metaphorically, John ties the death of Christ to the theme of unity. The unity of the church is grounded in God's design. What God weaves, God weaves whole, from above."
Brothers and sisters, don't just look at the outward things. The church is one in God's sight. That oneness is not outward — it's spiritual, it's inward, just like the garment. The inner garment, not the outer garment, was the unity. So the unity of the church is inward; it is from God. We are not trying to stitch up, patch up things to make a unity — no, the unity of the church is there already.
2. The Women at the Cross
John draws our attention to the women at the cross, and he names them. Picture an artist's rendition of Jesus' view from the cross: Jesus is lifted up, looking down — crowds around, and notice this group: there are three women in the center, and one woman close to the foot of the cross — that's four women — and one man in white: the Beloved disciple, whom we know as John.
At the cross, John tells us there were four women, and he describes them:
- Jesus' mother, whom we know as Mary.
- Mary's own sister — Jesus' aunt.
- Another Mary — Mary the wife of Clopas. (Mary was a popular name.) Scholars feel this is connected to the end of Luke's gospel, where on the road to Emmaus two people are mentioned, one anonymous and the other named Clopas. The name was very rare, so scholars think this is the same couple — one mentioned in relation to the crucifixion, the other in relation to the resurrection.
- Mary Magdalene — Mary from the fishing town of Magdala. Not a surname, like "Jesus of Nazareth" — she is Mary from Magdala, distinguished because there were so many Marys.
John describes a little dialogue at the cross. He was there; he saw it, he heard it — he could tell you who said what, when. At some point during the crucifixion, Jesus looked at his mother and said, "Woman, look, your son" — meaning the Beloved disciple. Then he looked at John and said, "Look, your mother." This was not mother and son by nature — Jesus pronounced that day a new relationship, not by natural birth but based on the cross, the death of Jesus Christ.
What is Jesus forming? Jesus' death produced new family relationships — a new family.
The Central Point: A New Family Formed at the Cross
What's the central issue of the cross? You can arrange the elements of this passage into a so-called chiasm — seven sections — and the central point is this: the matter of Jesus' mother and the Beloved disciple. That is the key point of Jesus' death in John: Jesus' death on the cross produces a new family.
Jesus came — yes, many did not receive him, but those who did receive him, who believed, became children of God; that's from the prologue of John's gospel. Here, Jesus is pronouncing this as something accomplished, based on his crucifixion. There's a new family, and it includes John, it includes Mary the mother of Jesus, it includes the other Marys.
From that day, John took Mary into his home, since she was older — he took care of her. They could have had a little home meeting — would you like to go, if you were in that area? You could talk to John, talk to Mary, talk to Mary Magdalene if she was visiting. This is what the new family produced out of Jesus' death.
Lindars comments:
"This scene on the cross seems to introduce a new family that comes through birth from above, not natural relationship. It is reinforced when the risen Jesus calls his disciples 'my brothers' and refers to God as 'my father and your father.'"
You may say, well, that's a stretch — taking a short sentence here, a short sentence there, making a big deal out of it. No, I'm not — Jesus made a big deal out of it. He spoke it from the cross. A new family was formed out of Jesus' death.
A couple of days later, Jesus tells Mary Magdalene, "Go to my brothers and tell them, 'I ascend to my Father and your Father, my God and your God.'" Mary Magdalene did not go to his natural brothers — James, Joseph, and the others. She went to the disciples. Where did she learn to call them that? At the very least, she learned it here, at the cross — there is a new relationship, a new family formed out of the death of Christ.
In John's gospel, the church was born — produced out of the death of Jesus. A lot of times we think Pentecost started the church, but in John, the church starts with the death of Christ — it starts at the cross of Christ. This is where it began. This is where John, and those in John's church, felt they began. This is also where this church began — this church began in the death of Christ, at the cross of Christ.
So that is the major accomplishment of Jesus' death: to produce the church as a new family of God. After this, Jesus can declare, "It is finished." It's done. God's work is complete.
Look at the person on your left and the person on your right — this is your family, and this is what has been accomplished at the cross.
Jesus Pierced: Blood and Water
"Since it was the preparation day, the Jews did not want the bodies to remain on the cross on the Sabbath, for that Sabbath was a special day. They requested that Pilate have the men's legs broken and that their bodies be taken away. So the soldiers came and broke the legs of the first man and of the other man who had been crucified with him. When they came to Jesus, they did not break his legs since they saw he was already dead, but one of the soldiers pierced his side with a spear, and at once blood and water came out. He who saw this has testified so that you also may believe; his testimony is true, and he knows he is telling the truth. For these things happened so that the scripture would be fulfilled: not one of his bones will be broken. Also, another scripture says, they will look on the one they pierced." (John 19:31-37, paraphrased)
This is the last section of the eyewitness account of John. Even though we have already covered the part where Jesus says, "It is finished," John wants us to see there is more. This section about Jesus being pierced is unique to the Gospel of John — the other gospels do not include it.
The Roman soldier pierces Jesus' side just to make sure he is really dead — Jesus is already dead at this point. John records that blood and water came out. Why does John add this detail? It must be because he wants us to see something more than simply that Jesus died. There must be some symbolism in this matter of blood and water, though John does not explain it directly — we have to work it out.
The Meaning of the Blood
The original readers of this gospel would have known the background of the Old Testament, which indicates that blood had to be shed for the forgiveness of sins. Jesus gave himself as a sacrifice — he died, and as he died, he shed his blood, laying down his life for us.
The book of Hebrews gives us three indications of what the blood signifies:
- Redemption — Hebrews 9:12 says, "By his own blood he obtained an eternal redemption."
- Cleansing — the same chapter says the blood of Christ cleanses our conscience.
- Forgiveness — Hebrews 9:22 says, "Without the shedding of blood there is no forgiveness."
So the blood symbolizes redemption, cleansing, and forgiveness.
The Meaning of the Water
What about the water? In this gospel, water is mentioned a number of times, so it should be understood according to John's own writings. When Jesus was speaking to the Samaritan woman at the well, he said:
"Whoever drinks from the water that I will give him will never get thirsty again. In fact, the water I will give him will become a well of water springing up in him for eternal life."
So water in this gospel points toward life — even eternal life. Later, at a big festival, Jesus stood up and shouted to all the people:
"The one who believes in me, as the scripture has said, will have streams of living water flow from deep within him."
Again, water speaks of life — streams of living water flowing out. Jesus himself said, "I came so that you may have life, and have it abundantly." So Jesus going to the cross, and this matter of blood and water coming out, symbolizes redemption, but it also signifies life being poured out for us.
Jesus' Royal Burial
The last thing John records is Jesus' burial. Jesus' burial was not a typical burial of a common person who was crucified — in fact, the majority of people crucified never even had a burial. But Jesus had a burial, and his burial was like the burial of a king. It was a royal burial, for a number of reasons.
First, we read that Joseph of Arimathea came to Pilate asking for Jesus' body. Whenever the gospel writers mention names, they assumed readers would know who these people were. The Gospel of Matthew is the only gospel that tells us Joseph was a rich man — Matthew cared about money, so he noted it. But we can also tell Joseph was rich because: he had a brand-new tomb carved out of the rock, which was not something poor people could do. The stone covering it was rolled, not a simple plug — rolling stones were also a sign of wealth. It was a new tomb, an expensive tomb, where no one had yet been buried.
In addition, Nicodemus came bringing seventy-five pounds of spices — he must have had help to carry that much. Jesus' body was wrapped in all this linen. All of these things point to how kings were buried: lots of spices, a brand-new expensive tomb. It even mentions that this tomb was in a garden — again, a sign of how royalty was buried.
So Jesus had a royal burial, a kingly burial. Earlier we saw that Jesus, on the cross, had a sign over his head: "The King of the Jews." Yes, he was the king, and he was buried as the king.
There is an indication from the Old Testament, Isaiah 53, that says:
"He was assigned a grave with the wicked, but he was with a rich man at his death, because he had done no violence and had not spoken deceitfully."
He should have been assigned to go where all the wicked people go, but instead he was buried with — or by — a rich man. So not only was Jesus' death foretold in the Bible, even his burial was foretold. This was all according to God's plan.
Conclusion: Victory, Life, and Honor
As was said at the start, the Gospel of John does not dwell so much on the suffering of Jesus. Why? Because John wants us to see that Jesus' death was a victory, not a defeat. That is why Jesus would say when he died, "It is finished" — I accomplished it, everything has been done according to God's plan.
So in John's gospel, Christ's death on the cross is:
- A victory
- A way of giving life — Jesus' death brought life to us
- An occasion where he is honored as a king in his burial
A Moment of Response
We've had a lot of response tonight in song, but it's good for us to have a response in prayer too. Wherever you are, consider: is there something that has stood out to you tonight?
- Is it the fact that Jesus was elevated and has drawn people to himself for salvation?
- Is it the clothing — the seamless garment, which speaks of unity?
- Is it Jesus' words to his mother, where a new family is formed?
- Is it the piercing that took place, where we are redeemed, forgiven, cleansed, and life eternal is made available to us?
- Or finally, is it that kingly burial?
Take a moment where you are, close your eyes, have a moment with your God, and thank him for what he's brought to your attention tonight.
Transcript prepared with AI from the original recording and may differ from the spoken words. Check the recording before quoting. Report a correction
Cite this sermon
For lessons, articles and study notes. It credits the preacher and the church and links the original recording.





