Lament
The Life of David
Craig Pagens · Tenth Church
Lament gives us room to hold complex and contradictory emotions together, rather than building walls that isolate us.
- Preacher
- Craig Pagens
- Church
- Tenth ChurchOtherVancouver, Canada
- Date
- Read time
- 17 min
- Word count
- 3,617 words
- Language
- English
Scriptures
Tags
Categories
Bible characters
Key takeaways
In this sermon▾
Opening: A Moment That Changed Everything
In the summer of 2009, I returned from Denmark, where I had been studying on an exchange program. My parents were supposed to meet me at the airport, but when I arrived only my father was there. It seemed strange, but he explained that my mother would stay home and I would see her when we got back. Because time was short, we would not leave right away and would instead stay at the airport hotel.
In the morning, after showering and getting ready, my father surprised me a little. He said, "Can you sit down?" I sat on the bed, and he said, "Craig, your mother and I are seeking a divorce." I felt that it was one of those dividing moments after which life would never be the same.
Feeling the Loss
I remember feeling shock, surprise, anger, and resentment. As the days and weeks passed, the sense of loss became more real to me. Because of my anger and resentment toward my parents, my heart began to harden. I built a wall, an emotional wall around myself. At the time, I thought it would protect me from more pain. But all it did was leave me feeling alienated and alone. I was no longer able to acknowledge my feelings or share the depth of what I felt with others, and I could not heal or grow through the grief and loss.
Can you feel a moment of loss that seemed like a dividing line in your life? Whether you are looking at a loss of a friend, a relationship, a dream, or a hope, you may have felt that something would never be the same again. During this message, I want to invite you to be aware of where that loss is and how you have felt. As we look at David's loss and his own lament, I invite us to bring our own losses into that moment as well.
David's Story: A Mirror, Not Just a Model
We continue today our sermon series on the life of David. We look at David not necessarily as a model to imitate, but as a mirror. As we look at David's life, we can see ourselves: how we can become more human, and how we can follow God faithfully and honestly in a hard and complicated world.
I invite you to enter David's story at one of those dividing moments, a moment after which David's life would never be the same. Let me set the scene before I read the text. David had been running from Saul, the king of Israel, for more than ten years. He lived in caves and slept on rocks. Then someone approached him and told him that he had been in the same battle as Saul and Jonathan. In that battle, both Saul, his enemy, and Jonathan, his dearest friend, were killed. In the midst of this emotional reality, we are told that David wrote a song called a "lament."
I want to invite you to follow along in 2 Samuel, chapter 1, beginning at verse 17. You can open your Bible, whether a paper copy or on your phone, or you can follow on the screen behind me.
"David chanted this lament over Saul and his son Jonathan. He also ordered that the men of Judah be taught this song of the bow; it is written in the Book of Jashar. 'Your glory, O Israel, lies slain on your heights! How the mighty have fallen! Tell it not in Gath, proclaim it not in the streets of Ashkelon, lest the daughters of the Philistines rejoice, lest the daughters of the uncircumcised exult. You mountains of Gilboa, let there be no dew or rain on you, nor fields of offerings. For there the shield of the mighty was defiled, the shield of Saul, anointed with oil no more. From the blood of the slain, from the fat of the mighty, the bow of Jonathan did not turn back, and the sword of Saul did not return empty. Saul and Jonathan, beloved and lovely, in life and in death they were not divided. They were swifter than eagles, they were stronger than lions. You daughters of Israel, weep over Saul, who clothed you luxuriously in scarlet, who put ornaments of gold on your apparel. How the mighty have fallen in the midst of the battle! Jonathan lies slain on your heights. I am distressed for you, my brother Jonathan; very pleasant have you been to me; your love to me was wonderful, surpassing the love of women. How the mighty have fallen, and the weapons of war perished!'"
Let us pray together.
Lord Jesus, thank you that in our Bible there is a song like this. A song of lament. Thank you that, with David, we can come with our whole selves and our complicated emotions, including our grief, to face this world. Thank you that you do not only want to hear our laments, but you invite us to lament. As we enter David's lament, Lord, I pray that you would hear our lament as well, and help us heal and expand our horizons through it. Amen.
The Complexity of David's Grief
Can you imagine what David feels? On one hand, his enemy, whom he hated and who relentlessly hunted him, is dead. The one because of whom he slept in caves and used rocks as pillows, who kept him away from his wife, friends, and city. He is dead. But Jonathan, his close friend, has died too. In the midst of that, David stands up and offers a lament. And not just a private lament, but a public one, so much so that he, as the future king of Israel, asks that others learn this lament with him.
Can you imagine a politician or public figure today who stands in the middle of a national tragedy, and instead of giving a prepared speech, stands before others on national television, weeps, and sings a song of lament? I think if we are honest, even thinking about it might make us a little uncomfortable. Or perhaps if we saw someone like that, we might say, "That is completely unprofessional. It is not befitting the dignity of his office as a public figure."
Our society struggles with the vocabulary of lament. Eugene Peterson, who wrote The Message translation of the Bible and was a professor at Regent College on the UBC campus, says this about the state of lament today. He says: "In our culture there is no lament because truth is not taken seriously. Love is not taken seriously. And human life does not matter as life."
And we see this, don't we? We open the news, we see death and war, but no grief and no lament. When we read newspapers, we see sorrow and anger written on their pages, but there are no songs of lament. And when we open social media, we see anger, we see distraction, but very little lament at best. Lament is not part of our spoken or visual vocabulary as a culture. And we avoid it.
In contrast, the biblical world is full of lament. Did you know that 70% of the Psalms are songs of lament? And there is an entire book in the Bible literally called "Lamentations." It means the book of lament. Throughout both our Old and New Testaments, we see lament on many pages. This makes us wonder why. Why do we find it difficult to lament as a culture? And what does that say about us?
So today, I want to invite us to be challenged by the words of Scripture, and to allow ourselves to feel uncomfortable, even in our places of grief. I want to invite us to walk alongside King David in his lament. I want to invite us to ask how lament changes us. What does lament do? We will look at how lament can help us heal and expand the horizons of our souls. Let us reflect on this together.
Lament Helps Us Heal
Let's begin with how lament can help us heal. Surprisingly, David begins by lamenting Saul. In verse 24: "Daughters of Israel, weep over Saul, who clothed you luxuriously in scarlet, who put ornaments of gold on your apparel. How the mighty have fallen in the midst of the battle!"
David loved Saul. He was his king. He looked at Saul with appreciation. Saul had spared David even in moments when he could have ended his life while he was a fugitive. Yet Saul was also a person who hated and hunted David. That is why David was in exile, running in the wilderness, far from family and friends, sleeping on rocks. Can you imagine the complexity of emotion, even contradictory emotion, that David feels about the loss of Saul?
But lament leaves room for grief. Lament leaves room even for complete and contradictory feelings to exist side by side at the same time. It gives them space, because if we are honest, life is complicated. In our lament, we come to bring our complicated feelings and our complicated lives, and we hold them together.
Perhaps some of you can recognize situations in your life where grief felt complicated. Perhaps loss through the death of a father who was absent or abusive. The loss of a long-term friendship that at times seemed unhealthy. The loss of a dream job that did not meet your hopes or expectations. Or the accumulated losses that come from fighting cancer, even as you look at the papers confirming remission. Through his lament, David makes space for complex emotion. He refuses to let stereotyped answers or dualistic thinking take control. He refuses to say, or allow himself to say to others, "Well, at least you still have..." or "All things work together for good, right?" No. Instead, David holds in his lament the complexity of loss, refusing stereotyped answers, and also refusing to protect himself from pain as I did with my parents. Instead of building an emotional wall, David expresses the complexities of the feelings he has, allows others in, invites them, and asks them to lament with him.
This is one of the greatest things I was missing in the midst of my loss and grief. In my anger, my bitterness, and my resentment, I had built a wall, thinking it would protect me. But instead, all it did was isolate me, leaving me alone, unable to express my feelings or even acknowledge and recognize them, and therefore unable to recover from them. I remember the first time I shared with a trusted friend the experience of hearing that news from my father. As I shared it, I felt as though a dam inside me began to crumble and collapse, and a flood of tears began to pour out. And as those tears came out, I did not feel any less myself. In fact, I felt I was returning to being more myself than I had been in a long time. That wall did not only hide my feelings from me, it hid me from myself and from my ability to heal and grow through that sense of loss. Lament makes room to hold even contradictory and complex feelings together, so that we can move through them and recover.
Lament Expands Our Horizons
But David does not lament only Saul. We then see that he laments his dearest friend, Jonathan. He says: "How the mighty have fallen in the midst of the battle. Jonathan lies slain on your heights. I am distressed for you, my brother Jonathan. You were very dear to me. Your love for me was wonderful, surpassing the love of women." This is David's closest friend. They literally fought side by side in the war. This was someone who physically guarded his back in battle. Jonathan also sacrificed much for David. He was willing to give up the crown so that David would become the next king. Jonathan was Saul's son, and by right, he should have been the next king. But he knew that Samuel had declared David the coming king, and he was willing to lay down his sword and his crown for David to take up in the future.
Eugene Peterson, whom I mentioned earlier, the author of The Message, rendered this part I just read in this way: "My dear brother, Jonathan, my heart is broken over your death. Your friendship was a wonderful miracle, a love beyond anything I had known or ever hoped to know." I remember reading those words, that phrasing, and it feels as though David was looking back at his past with both the joy of the heart and the ache of the heart together. Like a sunset, the most beautiful sunset you can remember. Knowing that the sunset has long passed, yet you keep the beauty of that moment in your heart. Can you call to mind a sunset moment in your life? A moment from your past that you hold with great joy in your heart, and perhaps also with some pain.
For me, one of those sunset moments that I can now only hold with the joy of my heart is the memory of meeting my wife for the first time. I met her at a tenth-grade retreat. I and a friend arrived at the retreat a little late, got out of the car, and walked toward the fire. And as we walked toward the fire, my eyes fell on the most beautiful woman I had ever seen in my life. She is not here now, so I am not trying to earn any extra points. The firelight was dancing around her, and my heart began to beat very fast. I thought to myself, I have to talk to her. So, with excessive confidence, I approached her and we started chatting. We talked for what seemed like more than an hour. It was the best conversation I had ever had up to that point. Do you know what? At the end of that hour, she was not interested in me at all. Not at all. It took a full year for me to get a date with her. But I look back on that moment with the joy of my heart, because it was my first memory of talking with her and seeing her in the firelight. It is like a photograph that lives in my memory. But one day, Sabine or I will look back on that memory as a sunset. We will hold it with great joy and great pain in the heart. The joy of the heart and the ache of the heart. Because we will remember the fun and the beauty of that moment and that conversation together, and what God was preparing for us a year after that. But our hearts will also be full of pain because one of us has gone. Can you feel the sunset memory? We were designed to hold these complex and intertwined feelings together.
The opposite of lament is numbness. If lament allows us to keep our hearts and our lives soft, then the absence of lament makes us hard and turns us into plastic people. Plastic people like mannequins in a store window. From a distance you see everything looking tidy and good, and perhaps stylish too. But the closer you come, especially when you look inside, something seems not right. Lament helps us avoid turning into hard, plastic people. It keeps our hearts soft and allows us to become more human.
In my old age, or as I advance in years, I hope my faith and my life will reflect the reality I have lived deeply. I want to look in my eighties or nineties like my grandmother looked. She passed away several years ago. To be clear, I do not want to look exactly like my grandmother. That would be, well, perhaps not that hairstyle. But my grandmother lost a lot. She wept deeply. She laughed honestly. And I hope that my face in old age reflects the depth of my losses, instead of a Botox smile that hides everything. That I have gained every wrinkle, every smile line, every tear and every laugh. I think if I am in my eighties or nineties and my face looks a little like that, and I have half her sense of elegance, then I will be heading in the right direction. Lament gives us room to expand and keeps our hearts soft.
Gerald Sittser, a former professor at Whitworth University in Spokane, Washington. In 1991, he was returning from a family trip, and on the way back, a drunk driver crossed the center line and collided with their minivan. In one moment, he lost three generations of women in his life. His mother, his wife, and his youngest daughter. He and three of his children survived. Gerald explains that in the days and months that followed, it was like living in darkness. Sometimes he simply wanted to escape. But his desire to strongly support his children in their time of loss is what literally kept him alive. He said that one night he had a dream. In the dream, he was running west, trying to catch up with the setting sun, but darkness overtook him. When he woke up after some time, he shared the dream with his sister Diane, who said: "The fastest way to catch the sun is not to run west, but to turn around and head east. In the darkness of grief, seek the light." He realized in that moment that he had a choice. That in his grief, he did not actually have to run away and hide. He could enter the darkness of his grief, facing it directly, with Christ, seeking the light even in his suffering. In his book called Grace Disguised, Gerald says this: the soul is elastic like a balloon. It can grow through suffering. Look, these difficult emotions stretch us, don't they? And that stretching is painful and hard. Sorrow. Depression. Anger. Grief. While that stretching is painful, those difficult emotions also create more space for the positive emotions we long for in our lives, such as joy, hope, love, and strength. Our suffering provides room for stretching. Not only can we hold more of those difficult emotions, but also the emotions we long for.
We often think of ourselves during suffering as a fixed entity, like a vase, which if broken we simply need to gather the pieces and put ourselves back together as in the story of Humpty Dumpty. However, we are elastic. We are meant to grow even through our suffering. To grow to hold more grief, but also more joy. To hold more tears, but also more laughter. This is what Gerald Sittser explains about what happened after his loss. There is no other way to do it. He says that in the years before that loss, he felt more sorrow and grief than he had ever known in his life. But he also knew more joy, laughter, and hope as well. Our suffering gives us an opportunity to expand our horizons in ways nothing else can do.
In Psalm 4, the psalmist, speaking of a distress and suffering that is not specified, says this. This is the King James version: "Thou hast enlarged me when I was in distress; have mercy upon me, and hear my prayer." Sorrow and joy are not stages we pass through. They are realities we can hold together as we walk with Christ even in the darkest valleys of our lives. We do not simply move past loss and suffering. They become part of ourselves that continually expand. They become places where we can confess to God and pray that the same Holy Spirit who raised Jesus from the dead will not only be with us, but will create new life even in the most dead, dark, and difficult places we experience.
Closing Prayer and Reflection
At the beginning of the message, I asked you to think of a memory. It may be a memory you carry now or one you faced in the past. One of those moments that comes before suffering and after it. I want to ask you to hold on to it now. Close your eyes. And simply acknowledge it. So, with your mind, name that memory, that space. Again, whether it is from the past or something very difficult you are carrying at the moment. I want to read to you Psalm 23. A psalm that reminds us that Christ is with us. He walks with us in the depths of our valleys. And he longs to bless us. And to anoint our heads with oil as well. So let this be our closing prayer together from Psalm 23.
"The Lord is my shepherd, I shall not want. He makes me lie down in green pastures. He leads me beside still waters. He restores my soul. He leads me in paths of righteousness for his name's sake. Even though I walk through the valley of the shadow of death, I will fear no evil, for you are with me; your rod and your staff, they comfort me. You prepare a table before me in the presence of my enemies. You anoint my head with oil; my cup overflows. Surely goodness and mercy shall follow me all the days of my life, and I shall dwell in the house of the Lord forever. Yes, O God. And I shall dwell in the house of the Lord forever. Amen."
Transcript prepared with AI from the original recording and may differ from the spoken words. Check the recording before quoting. Report a correction
Cite this sermon
For lessons, articles and study notes. It credits the preacher and the church and links the original recording.





