Skip to main content
Back to sermons

Legalism: The Dangers of Rules Without Heart

Mark - Part 6

Jordan · Life Church

Legalism focuses on outward behavior and rule-keeping, while God desires to transform our hearts.

Sign in to save Sign in to mark completedSign in to keep this private.
Preacher
Jordan
Church
Life ChurchPentecostalEdmonton, Canada
Date
Read time
12 min
Word count
2,678 words
Language
English

Scriptures

CitedQuoted
Mark 2:23–28Mark 2:23–28

Tags

Categories

Sermon SeriesGospel of MarkLegalismSabbath

Bible characters

JesusDavidPaul

Key takeaways

Share this quote

In this sermon▾

Introduction: The Trap of Legalism

Good morning, everyone. I'm not a pastor here at Life Church; I'm a member. But I used to be a pastor, and I want to share a little about where I came from. I went to Bible college and became a Christian there, because I grew up believing that you had to get all your ducks in a row before you could come to God. You had to be polished. And I thought you had to come to a Sunday night service, wait for the altar call, and walk forward before you could become a Christian.

Where that came from was a very legalistic upbringing. Legalism is the belief that by keeping rules, laws, regulations, and religious practices, we establish righteousness and holiness, rather than relying on God's grace through faith and being transformed by the Holy Spirit working in us. Put simply, it is about acting and looking Christian, acting and looking religious. As long as we focus on the outside, we can measure whether someone looks Christian or not.

Growing Up Under the Rules of the Lord's Day

Let me give you a few examples so you understand how I was raised. On Sundays, we called it the Lord's Day, and that meant I was not allowed to go outside. Every time I asked why, the answer was simply, "Because it is. Because that's why." That never answered my question.

Our house had a front door you couldn't see through, a screen door, and a second glass door that we were not allowed to open on the Lord's Day. So I would sit in the living room in my church clothes, and when I heard my friends at the door asking if I could come play street hockey, I had to say no. My friends who weren't raised in church were confused, and they would just turn away. I would stand there at seven, eight, nine years old with my hand on the glass, feeling the breeze through the screen, enjoying the Lord's Day from the other side.

The strange thing is that these rules were not consistent between families. My cousin Clint was allowed outside on the Lord's Day, but he couldn't ride his bike or run. He would try to walk fast enough to keep up with his friends, and the moment he began to shuffle into a run, Uncle Gene would call out, "Quick, give that up. It's the Lord's Day. Don't you be running on the Lord's Day."

We had no idea what these rules meant or why they made us look holy or made us think we were Christian. But this is what legalism looks like. Legalism never gives us the why. It prioritizes outward conformity over inward transformation. That is the mistake: we emphasize the outside and never look at what is happening on the inside.

Why This Matters at Life Church

This is an important conversation for us here, because we seek to develop resilient followers of Christ. That means cultivating genuine spiritual maturity, and we cannot allow legalism to creep into our culture. True spiritual growth is the transformation of our hearts, which affects how we think, live, and obey God.

Let me be clear: legalism is the enemy here, not behavior. Our behavior matters, and how we conduct ourselves matters. But legalism treats behavior as the goal. It uses behavior as the measuring stick to decide whether someone looks Christian or holy. That is my problem. I am not convinced God is interested in merely making people look and act Christian. I believe God wants to transform our hearts to become more like his, because when the heart changes, behavior changes. This is part of spiritual maturity, which we call sanctification: a journey.

I care about this deeply because I don't want to disciple our people, or new people who come through our doors, into thinking they must show up with their lives all polished, waiting for me or Jeremy or someone to give an altar call before they surrender to Jesus. Legalism robs people of the joy of the Lord. It excludes people and pushes them out. Our goal is not a list of do's and don'ts. We want to equip all of you to walk with God day by day, to be attentive to the Holy Spirit working within you, who reminds you of God's truth and can convict you when you are out of line, not to push you away, but to draw you back in.

The Holy Spirit is not out there trying to catch you breaking rules. He is shaping your desires and your motives to produce godly character and authentic spiritual maturity. Legalism is just trying to look holy, which isn't holiness at all.

Mark 2:23-28: Legalism Meets Jesus

This morning we are going to look at how legalism creeps in and distorts our understanding of God's commands and his intentions. We will walk through Mark 2:23-28, a conflict that happens when legalism and Jesus come face to face. I am reading from the ESV. Before we dive in, the primary teaching this morning is not on the Sabbath. I am teaching on the dangers of legalism. The Sabbath is simply the context in which we see legalism distorting God's purposes.

Verse 23: Gleaning, Not Working

One Sabbath, Jesus was going through the grain fields. As they made their way, his disciples began to pluck heads of grain.

What is the Sabbath? Briefly, it is a day set apart to not work, to rest and focus on worshipping God. It is observed on the seventh day and is found in the Ten Commandments, which instruct us to remember the Sabbath by keeping it holy. It is a day to rest, to be rejuvenated, to go outside and play if that fulfills you.

This verse does not say the disciples were eating, but the parallel accounts in Matthew and Luke say they were hungry and eating the grain, and later in this passage Jesus references a story of eating. So they were out for a stroll on the Sabbath, walking, talking, and having a snack. They were not harvesting, not getting ahead, and not stealing from the farmer. This was what was known as gleaning. Farmers would leave extra crops in their fields for the marginalized: the poor, widows, and foreigners. God established this rule to provide for those people, and I think that is a sweet thing. Jesus and his disciples were not in the wrong.

But one of the problems with legalism is that it makes people see what they choose to see and what they want to see.

Verse 24: The Pharisees' Accusation

And the Pharisees were saying to Jesus, "Look, why are they doing what is not lawful on the Sabbath?"

The Pharisees were saying, "Why are your guys working on the Lord's Day?" They thought they were seeing work, because pulling grain can technically be interpreted as work, even though all they were doing was eating.

What one person considers work can be a hobby and rejuvenating for someone else. I know a man who loves working on his truck, doing oil changes and filters. I tried doing my own oil changes once, and it was dreadful. Because of this gray area, the Jewish scribes of the time meticulously defined work, creating 39 categories with a multitude of rules underneath each one. Let's call a spade a spade: they made up a bunch of rules around a rule, and turned a gift from God, a day of rest, into a burden. People had to tiptoe around, walk on eggshells, and make sure the people judging them were not pointing fingers or deciding they were no longer Christian because they did not abide by the rules.

And it got more absurd. Many theologians suggest a second issue: how far Jesus and his disciples walked. There was a concept called the Sabbath day's journey, which meant you could walk a maximum of 2,000 steps on the Sabbath. You could walk 1,999 steps, but don't you dare take the 2,000th, because that is sin. You can go outside and walk fast, but don't run. This is how silly legalism can become.

Legalism can make you an expert in the rules, but remain a stranger to the heart of God.

Legalism causes you to get so caught up in rules and people's behavior that you lose sight of God's purposes and miss the whole point: that it is about spiritual maturity, that people are on their own journeys, and that they may not be where you are. Look at this picture. The Pharisees stand face to face with the Son of God. They have every rule memorized, yet they cannot see the Son of God standing in front of them. That is what rules can do. This is a mirror for us. When we allow legalism to creep into our lives, we can see the rules and see when people are out of line, but we cannot see Jesus face to face. Our priorities change, and the emphasis blinds us.

Verses 25-26: David and the Bread of the Presence

So Jesus said to them, "Have you never read what David did when he was in need and was hungry? He entered the house of God in the time of Abiathar the high priest and ate the bread of the Presence, which it is not lawful for any but the priests to eat, and also gave it to those who were with him?"

Jesus challenges the Pharisees with a passage they have clearly overlooked. I taught on this story back in August. David was on the run from Saul and came to the Tabernacle, where he encountered Ahimelech, the father of Abiathar and the high priest. There was holy bread there, the bread of the Presence, which was made fresh every week, and the old bread was for the priests to eat. This was law, and it protected the bread.

Yet Ahimelech saw that there was a human need first, and that the need was more important than religious tradition and rules. Do you really think it is an accident that this was the only bread in the story? David says, "Give me something to eat," and the priest says the only bread available is the bread of the Presence. In a town of at least a hundred people, that is not a coincidence. God is teaching us something in this moment.

Ahimelech, the high priest who upheld these laws, understood but did not forget that the law was meant to help people. The Pharisees saw it backwards. They became legalistic in their theology and elevated rules over human need. They would rather keep the bread and let the man starve. That is backwards, and that is the heart of legalism. It distorts our understanding of God's purposes. We prioritize rules over heart transformation, performance over grace, and tradition over God's intentions. We cannot elevate rules above our love for human beings made in the image of God, the very people Jesus laid down his life for. Jesus references this story because legalism produces rule-following without understanding God's heart. He points the Pharisees back to seeing God's commands through the lens of his character and purposes.

Verses 27-28: The Son of Man Is Lord of the Sabbath

And he said to them, "The Sabbath was made for man, not man for the Sabbath. So the Son of Man is lord even of the Sabbath."

This is the mic-drop moment in the passage. Up to this point, the Pharisees are looking at Jesus as if to say, "Who do you think you are? By what authority are you talking?" Remember that Mark is considered the first Gospel written. There was a roughly 400-year silence from Malachi, the last book of the Old Testament, until now. Here, at the very beginning of Mark, we finally hear the Son of Man prophesied by Daniel in chapter seven: one like the Son of Man, who will receive dominion and glory over all nations and peoples. Jesus knows what he is saying, and so did the Pharisees.

Jesus is in effect saying, "Let me put it this way: the Son of Man is Lord of the Sabbath." He created the Sabbath and knows why it was made. He is not offering another interpretation. He is calling the shots. Jesus addresses legalism here and teaches that the Sabbath was created to refresh people, not to enslave them with legalistic restrictions. The Pharisees were so caught up in rules that they were missing the point that the Sabbath was designed as a blessing for us.

The Sabbath was intended to be a gift, not another tool or metric for legalism. It is for your enjoyment: a day to fill your tank, to put the phone away for a while, to enjoy relationships, and to focus on worshipping God. From that comes spiritual, emotional, and physical refreshment, which sustains you and gives you what you need to face tomorrow. When the Sabbath is seen through the lens of legalism, it is like believing man was made for the Sabbath. Legalism will rob you of God's gift and of what it was intended for. In the case of the Sabbath, we rob ourselves of true rest, the joy, freedom, and grace of knowing God more deeply and intimately. You will miss all of that because you are worried about how you look and whether you have checked all the boxes.

Applying the Heart of the Passage

Legalism is rarely about green fields today, but the underlying heart, the drive to follow rules to earn approval, still takes root in our lives. Legalism prioritizes behavior modification over spiritual maturity. Again, the issue is not behavior. The issue is when we make rules that protect a behavioral image into the end goal. Legalism makes us experts in rules but strangers to the heart of God.

God wants our hearts transformed as his Holy Spirit forms our desires and motives. He is not simply interested in making us appear holy. He wants us to become more holy and more like his Son, Jesus. So we must be very cautious when we elevate our personal convictions, our political preferences, or our cultural traditions, and treat them as the same standard as God's commands. There are personal convictions, and there is liberty in that. Something may be sin for one person and not for another, and we must not forget that. Let us be people rooted in Scripture, continually transformed by the Holy Spirit, and marked by grace, love, and mercy. The goal is not simply to look Christian. The goal is that we grow in spiritual maturity as we become more like Christ.

A Word of Invitation

This topic can be heavy and wordy, and I understand if you are wondering what I am talking about. But if you take one thing from this morning, know that you can come to Jesus as you are right now, with no strings attached. You do not have to have your life together or be polished. He meets you where you are.

If there are rules you were raised with that are holding you back, come talk to one of the pastors, to me, or to an elder, and we will help you determine whether those rules are biblically rooted or not. I do not want Satan holding you captive through man-made rules and legalism. Our heart, and the heart of Jeremy and the staff, is that you would come to know Jesus, and that we would walk alongside you, help you hear the Holy Spirit at work in your life, defend you when people come at you, and hold you accountable. And if you have been a Christian for a long time, take this moment to reflect: are these rules and regulations, and the way I measure people, my rules, or are they biblically based? That is my takeaway for you today.

Transcript prepared with AI from the original recording and may differ from the spoken words. Check the recording before quoting. Report a correction

Share

Cite this sermon

For lessons, articles and study notes. It credits the preacher and the church and links the original recording.

Jordan, “Legalism: The Dangers of Rules Without Heart”, Life Church, Sunday, 18 October 2026. Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q70X227KSSs Transcript: https://sermonregistry.com/en/sermons/legalism-the-dangers-of-rules-without-heart-jordan-2026-10-18?utm_source=citation#sermon-transcript

Guided discovery

Find a sermon for where you are.