Skip to main content
Back to sermons

Making Better Choices

A Better Filter for Decision-Making

Shane Willard · Activate Church Hamilton

Trade pursuits of temporary urges (the 'bowl') for intentional pursuit of your highest calling in God (the 'birthright')—the difference determines the entire narrative of your life.

Sign in to save Sign in to mark completedSign in to keep this private.
Church
Activate Church HamiltonPentecostalHamilton, New Zealand
Date
Read time
15 min
Word count
3,222 words
Language
English

Scriptures

CitedQuoted
Matthew 7:13–14Genesis 25Genesis 25Exodus 4:10Judges 6:14–15Jeremiah 1:4–7Matthew 23:37–39Hebrews 12:16–17Exodus 2:12

Tags

Categories

Decision-MakingPersonal GrowthBiblical Living

Bible characters

JacobAbrahamMosesGideonJeremiahDavidSolomonJesus

Key takeaways

  • Trade pursuits of temporary urges (the 'bowl') for intentional pursuit of your highest calling in God (the 'birthright')—the difference determines the entire narrative of your life.
  • Godlessness is not primarily about committing grave sins, but about treating your divine potential as less important than momentary desires.
  • Develop a better decision filter: ask 'Does this decision serve my birthright or my bowl?' rather than limiting yourself to right versus wrong.

Share this quote

In this sermon▾

Making Better Choices: A Better Filter for Decision-Making

The Problem with How We Make Decisions

The quality of our life will largely come down to the quality of the decisions we make. There's a subtle, non-evil but psychologically toxic way many of us operate: we refuse to own responsibility for our own desires by absolving it onto an outside sacred space—whether that's God or Satan.

Often when people say, "God told me," what they really mean is, "I've already decided what I'm going to do, and to avoid having a reasonable conversation about it, I'm just going to say God told me." When we do this, we absolve ourselves of responsibility for owning our desire. I would much more respect someone who says, "I have clarity and I want this," and then asks, "Is my desire surrendered to God?" That's a great question—but we have to own it first, or it leads us to a psychologically toxic place.

Similarly, we sometimes blame Satan for our choices. "Satan's attacking my finances." Maybe. But if you just bought something you can't afford with money you don't have to impress people you don't like—if you bought a $60,000 car on a $70,000 income—that is not Satan. That is you.

The Worst Filters for Decision-Making

The absolute worst filter for decision-making is psychopathy. The next worst is sociopathy. But the most common problem in a room like this is apathy—living unintentionally.

Jesus talked about this when he said, "Broad is the road that leads to destruction. Lots of people on it. Narrow is the way that leads to life. Only a few will find it." This isn't primarily a message about heaven and hell when you die. This is an ancient rabbinical message about the role of intention. Jesus's point is that very few people live with a clear enough "yes" that they know what to say "no" to.

Apathy will destroy you. You don't have to plan to fail; you just have to have no plan and failure will overtake you. You don't have to intend to be broke; you just have to have no financial plan and brokenness will get you. You don't have to intend to be unfit; you just have to have no fitness plan and unfit will overtake you. You don't have to intend to be a bad husband; you just have to have no intention to do what good husbands do and bad husband behaviors will overtake you.

The Trap of Only Considering Right and Wrong

The most common problem is that when we consider decisions, we only consider what's right and what's wrong. But that's a trap. Here's why:

First, if you make a hundred decisions in a week and 99 of them are awesome and one is bad, you're going to obsess about the one you missed. Second, there's a lot of things that aren't wrong—they're just dumb. Some things aren't sinful; they're just stupid. If we only consider right and wrong, we'll rationalize lots of things that aren't wrong but are frankly stupid.

The Story of Esau and Jacob: A Better Filter

I want to give you a picture of a way, way, way better filter for decision-making. This filter is so universal that it's found really early in the Bible story—in Genesis 25—in a story about two brothers having a conflict over a bowl of stew.

Two brothers named Jacob and Esau were in a dysfunctional family. Their father Isaac loved Esau; their mother Rebecca loved Jacob. One day Jacob was cooking stew when Esau came in from the open country famished. He said to Jacob, "Quick, let me have some of that red stew. I'm famished."

In Hebrew, this is actually a joke. Esau comes in and essentially says, "Ha-adam, ha-adam"—which roughly means, "How dumb, how dumb." The word "adam" sounds like "red." So Esau's literally shouting for the red stuff repeatedly. Jacob replied, "First, sell me your birthright." Esau said, "Well, look, I'm about to die. What good is the birthright to me?" This is the key question: "What good is the birthright to me?"

Jacob made Esau swear an oath, selling his birthright to Jacob. Then Jacob gave Esau some bread and lentil stew. He ate and drank, and he got up and left. Esau despised his birthright.

Understanding the Birthright

In Hebrew culture, the birthright was much more than just inheritance. It was a summary statement of everything you could be. It involved carrying your family name, standing up for everything your family stood for, keeping the deeds of who owns what land. The firstborn received a double portion—not to profit personally, but to cover all the extra responsibilities. If your brother died, you had to marry his wives to ensure they wouldn't go to prostitution. As the firstborn, you might end up responsible for dozens of women and children.

The double portion never made it to your pocket. So when the Bible says Esau "despised his birthright," it means he treated something sacred as if it were common. He only considered the holy possibilities of being given a life empowered by God's breath as not as important as a bowl of stew. That is profane.

The Central Point

Esau traded everything he could be for one momentary urge. And it wasn't wrong—it was just dumb.

Here's something confronting: When Hebrew writers read the word "iniquity" (Avon in Hebrew), they saw an eyeball, a hook, and fish multiplying. Whatever your eye hooks to multiplies. Whatever gets your attention gets bigger than it's supposed to be. We call this making a mountain out of a molehill. Have you ever had something or someone take too much attention in your brain? Have you ever had a $1,000 problem taking up $100,000 worth of headspace? That's iniquity.

One day you're going to be 90 years old—I hope—and you're going to look back at your life. It will be one of two narratives:

Narrative One: "I woke up every day pursuing the infinite possibilities I could be in God. Along the way, I made mistakes. Sometimes I made mistakes with zeros attached. But the posture of my heart was always pursuing my birthright."

Narrative Two: "My life was spent living from one urge to the next urge to the next urge to the next urge. I lived from one bowl to the next bowl to the next bowl. Thank goodness that God's faithfulness is never compromised by my lack of it, and he totally forgives my sins based on Christ's faithfulness alone. But actually, the quality of my life could have been a whole lot better."

People who pursue their birthright sometimes make more mistakes than people just living from urges—because people giving it a go are more likely to fail. But the posture of the heart is the thing that changes everything.

A Better Filter: Bowl or Birthright

For the rest of your life, here's what I'm asking you to consider: Instead of only considering what's right and wrong, start considering: Does this decision belong to the bowl or does this decision belong to the birthright? Is this a pursuit of an urge, or is this me infinitely pursuing everything I can be in God?

The Bible is best read with yourself as the villain, not the hero. If you read the Bible and always see yourself as the one who gets it, you'll miss the point. When we read Esau's story, we think, "What an idiot. He traded everything he could be for one meal. That makes no sense. Even if it's the best meal ever, four hours from now it's gone and you'll need another one." He traded something permanent for one meal.

But I think we might do it all the time. It's common to our lives. Can we just agree in solidarity that all of us have had moments where we traded something more important for something less important?

Throughout the Bible: Pursuing the Birthright Despite Mistakes

Here's what's so confronting: The people in Hebrews 11 would be disqualified from every Christian stage today and by YouTube "heresy hunters" and by our conscience. But Esau, whose worst mistake was trading his birthright for one meal, would probably be invited to give his testimony about how dumb that was.

Consider Moses. God had this huge birthright for him—to free a bunch of slaves. But Moses said, "Oh Lord, I've never been eloquent. I'm slow of speech and of tongue." He had this huge birthright, but he focused on what he didn't have.

Gideon was chosen to do something very similar, but he pushed back because of his family: "How can I save Israel? My clan is the weakest in Manasseh, and I'm the least in my family." His logic was essentially: "God, I'm the worst possible choice you could make."

Jeremiah thought he was too young. God said, "Before I formed you in the womb, I knew you. Before you were born, I set you apart. I appointed you as a prophet to the nations." But Jeremiah replied, "Ah, Sovereign Lord, I don't know how to speak. I'm only a child."

What's this about? How many bowls can we come up with that aren't wrong but cost us something bigger? Sometimes we trade our birthright for a bowl of "I don't have the skill." Sometimes for a bowl of "I don't have the heritage." Sometimes for a bowl of "I'm just not ready." But often—and this applies to every single one of us—we're just not willing.

Consider Israel. They were chosen by God to be a blessing to all nations. Instead of maintaining justice and righteousness, they chose to make slaves build the temple to honor God. They failed to see the irony that a country born from freed slaves would force slaves to build a temple to honor the God who freed them.

Jesus called them out on this: "Oh Jerusalem, Jerusalem, you who kill the prophets and stone those sent to you. How often I have longed to gather your children together as a hen gathers her chicks under her wings. But you were not willing. Now your house is left to you desolate." Israel had this huge birthright to bless the whole world, but they just weren't willing.

A Confronting Word from Hebrews

Here's what's really confronting. Someone wrote Hebrews 12, and it says:

See to it that no one is sexually immoral or is godless like Esau.

The writer of Hebrews had access to the entire Old Testament—to Ahab, Jezebel, Ammon who introduced child sacrifice, Manasseh who invited his opponents to worship foreign gods in the Jewish temple. But he doesn't say, "See to it that no one is godless like Ahab." He says, "See to it that no one is godless like Esau."

Why? Because all the people in Hebrews 11 made way more mistakes than Esau:

  • Abraham gave his wife to Pharaoh's harem and profited from Egyptian affluence while she suffered.
  • Moses was a premeditated murderer. "I looked this way and that, and seeing no one, I killed the man and hid him in the sand."
  • Samson lost a bet and killed 30 people.
  • Jephthah killed his own daughter for a rash vow.
  • David had eight named wives, several unnamed wives, and an innumerable amount of concubines.
  • Solomon had a thousand women.

Who made worse mistakes—David or Esau? David by far. By infinite.

Yet the writer of Hebrews calls them heroes and calls Esau godless. Why? Because the people in Hebrews 11 woke up every day intentionally pursuing everything they could be in God. Along the way, they made mistakes with zeros attached. But this guy—Esau—he thought everything he could be was not as important as one bowl of a meal. That is godlessness. The writer of Hebrews is saying: "See to it that no one sees their entire life as less important than their next urge."

The text is confronting because it says Esau "for a single meal sold his inheritance rights as the oldest son." The tone is like: What an idiot? But beyond idiot—that's godlessness. He wanted to inherit the blessing afterward and was rejected. He could bring about no change in mind, though he sought the blessing with tears. This isn't about God forgiving Esau. He regretted his decision the next time he got hungry and asked his father to reverse it. Sometimes God forgives us, but we still have to wear the consequences of the bowl.

The Reality: Everything is Just Beans

Do we despise our birthright? Do we live as though there's no higher purpose, which profanes our destiny? The problem is this simply leads us from living from one urge to the next to the next to the next.

Here's what's so important and hard to see in the text: the thing that seemed so great—the haadam, haadam—when Esau got it, it was just a bowl of beans. That's all it was. Jacob gave him lentils. What are lentils? Small, tasteless beans. In other words:

Esau traded everything he could be for one bowl of beans. We would never do that, would we?

But think about it:

Food: You know you're overweight and in danger of diabetes and heart disease. Your doctor begs you: "Please stop." But you open the fridge and there it is—Grandma's cake calling to you. You know if you eat one bite, you'll eat the whole cake. And you know before the sweetness is off your mouth and the whole thing's heading to your butt, you'll think, "Boy, I thought I would die without that." That totally overpromised and underdelivered. It's just beans.

Alcohol: You know you're the kind of person who can't have one beer. If you have one, you'll have 20. And you know it. Why would you have a whole case at one time? You open the fridge and there it is—haadam, haadam—I'll die without the next beer. You give in. You drink 15. You lose permanent things: your wife's respect, your children's honor, your family's dignity, financial peace. You wake up with the worst headache, thinking, "I thought I would die without that." But boy, was that beans. That overpromised and underdelivered.

Addiction: If you've ever had someone you love dealing with addiction, it's "I'll die without the next hit. I'll die without the next hit." And then it never delivers. "Oh, I've cost myself lots of money, lots of pride, lots of dignity. I thought I would die without it, but that was just beans."

Fashion: You go to the mall. The mall is just store after store after store of haadam. Here's the messaging: they put shirts on models, and the intimation is "If you just had this shirt, you would look like that." No, you would not. But you think, "I'll die without that shirt." You give in and cost yourself something that could really make a lot of money in the long run, like investing in an S&P 500 index fund. You buy a shirt. A month later, you haven't even taken the tag off. You're like, "I thought I would die without that." That was just beans.

Cars: Men struggle with this worse than women. It's called car fever—the irrational need to drive something new while telling yourself it's something more reliable. The internet is going haadam, haadam, haadam, haadam. Then you go to the car lot. The car salesmen are going haadam, haadam, ha-adam, ha-adam. They put the first payment off 45 days. So by the time the newness wears off, you look in your garage: "Oh my goodness, I just bought something I can't afford with money I don't have to impress people I don't like. I bought something that's going to lose 53% of its value in three and a half years. I'm paying 8% interest for the right to do that. I'm going to be broke for years because of this." You thought you'd die without it. Boy, that was just beans.

Gossip: You've ever thought you'd die if you didn't share some gossip about somebody? "I just can't wait to share this. I've got to get it out." And then you share it and you can't take it back and you destroy someone's life for years. You're like, "That did not feel as good as I thought. I thought I'd die without that." But that was just beans.

The Choice Before Us

Anytime we trade our birthright for a bowl—something that's not wrong, but it's just a temporary urge—it's just beans.

Jesus has a lot to say about this:

Then he said to them all, "If anyone would come after me, he must deny himself and take up his cross daily and follow me."

You can read that sentence without the word "daily" in it and it makes total sense. But that's not how Jesus looked at things. If you failed miserably today, get up tomorrow, re-surrender to God, and start again. His faithfulness was never compromised by your lack of it. If you did magnificently today, get up tomorrow, re-surrender, and start again. In that sense, we're all in the same exact boat.

But Jesus is making a point about something else: Good decisions don't act like savings accounts. You don't make 20 years of good decisions and then get 20 years of terrible decisions before getting back to zero.

If you have the best marriage in the room, that good marriage is one really bad decision away from not being so good. If you have the best business in the room, 30 years of good decisions can be undone with one urge. Twenty years of great things can be undone with one knee-jerk sort of thing. It's not wrong—it's just "Man, I thought that would deliver something," and now you've got a mouth full of beans.

The Final Question

So I'm urging you, my brothers and sisters: Wake up every day intentionally pursuing everything you can be in God. If you're doing that, be okay with the mistakes along the way. God's faithfulness will make a way. But what we don't want is for our life to be one summation of one bowl to the next to the next to the next to the next to the next.

Is the story of our life going to be a pursuit of the birthright, or a summation of living from one urge to the next? That's our choice.

Prayer

Lord Jesus, let no one ever reject you because of the way I'm presenting you. Would you empower us to have the grace to know the difference between birthright and bowl? Give us the courage to choose the birthright and the grace to smash the bowl—that our urges are not worth it.

Right now, underneath your breath, name your bowl. What's his name? What's her name? What's the car's name? What's the shirt's name? What's the thing? And you know that if you give into this, it's going to be a mouthful of beans. Lord, would you rescue us all from that? Empower us to make great decisions. May the summation of your life never ever be one urge to the next, one bowl to the next. May it be an intentional pursuit of the birthright. And may each and every one of you get the taste of beans out your mouth.

Transcript prepared with AI from the original recording and may differ from the spoken words. Check the recording before quoting. Report a correction

Share

Cite this sermon

For lessons, articles and study notes. It credits the preacher and the church and links the original recording.

Shane Willard, “Making Better Choices”, Activate Church Hamilton, Tuesday, 18 August 2026. Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-_cjgN92XYc&t=494s Transcript: https://sermonregistry.com/en/sermons/making-better-choices-shane-willard-2026-08-18?utm_source=citation#sermon-transcript

Guided discovery

Find a sermon for where you are.