Skip to main content
Back to sermons

Reawakening to What Our Souls Already Know

Fall Series 6 || Sacred Earth, Sacred Soul

Rev. Michael Lehman · First Congregational Church of Los Angeles

Every person bears the divine image and an inherent, God-given goodness that is deeper than any sin.

Sign in to save Sign in to mark completedSign in to keep this private.
Church
First Congregational Church of Los AngelesOtherLos Angeles, United States
Date
Read time
9 min
Word count
1,934 words
Language
English

Scriptures

No identified reference

No explicit scripture reference has been identified for this sermon.

Tags

Categories

Sermon SeriesTheologySocial Justice

Bible characters

JesusJohnPaul

Key takeaways

  • Every person bears the divine image and an inherent, God-given goodness that is deeper than any sin.
  • Forgetting our sacred worth leads to injustice, so we are called to honor and defend the dignity of every person.
  • Christ affirms what is deepest and truest in us rather than replacing it, and following him means being repeatedly awakened to this truth.

Share this quote

In this sermon▾

Awakening to What Our Souls Already Know

At the beginning of this sermon series lies an invitation: to awaken, or reawaken, to what our souls already know. To awaken to that which is deepest and truest about ourselves and our world. Have we experienced such moments of realization in our lives?

Last week, my oldest nephew turned eight. While FaceTiming with him, I remembered the first time I saw his face, mere days old. When my sister handed him to me, I was overwhelmed. Not just because I had become an uncle, or because my parents had become grandparents, or my sister a mother, but because I remembered what a fourth-century Celtic monk named Pelagius said: that when we look into the face of a newborn, we are looking into the face of God freshly born among us.

Original Goodness

Here, the Welsh teacher meant to suggest what is true of every person who ever was or will be: that what is deepest in and about us is sacred. Upon our faces shines the light of which our reading today speaks, and of which our choir just sang so marvelously. It is the light, our source, from which all life comes. Each of us is graced with the divine image. We bear an inherent dignity. What is truest in us is of God, not opposed to God.

This hallowed knowing formed the basis of the spiritual vision upon which Celtic Christian wisdom was fashioned, a vision called original goodness, or original blessing. It also got Pelagius deemed a heretic and excommunicated from the Church of Rome in the year 418.

When I first encountered them in divinity school in 2006, my goodness, I am getting old, Pelagius' story and work were presented under the heading the Pelagian heresy. An opposing view, by the North African bishop Augustine, had already gained significant ground in the Western church. His doctrine, eventually adopted as official by that church, would be called original sin. Augustine held that humanity had become permanently marred, that it no longer bore the image and likeness of God. He claimed our sinful nature was unavoidable, passed from parent to child in the womb.

Author and historian Mary Earle suggests that Augustine's despairing views were shaped by the mass suffering he had witnessed in Rome through successive invasions from northern Europe. So much so that he began to doubt the God-given goodness of the human community. Therefore, Augustine believed Jesus came to save us from our true nature, which was sinful. Pelagius, on the other hand, believed that Jesus came to reconnect us to our true nature, which was sacred.

Jesus, he said, revealed what is true of everyone, reminding us that we too are intersections of the divine and the human, meeting places of heaven and earth deep within. To awaken to this union is to experience recapitulation, the resounding of the deepest notes of our being. And these notes compose the famous overture to John's Gospel.

Through the Word, all things came into being.

The beloved disciple, or likely a student of the beloved disciple, wrote these words. Everything is essentially an utterance of the divine, a sacred sounding, each creature and life form a unique, unrepeatable expression of the One.

Christ as Affirmation

As early as the second century, Celtic communities in Gaul, modern-day France, had enthusiastically embraced this news of the Christ. When they heard John's soaring rhetoric about this Word made flesh, it was a striking confirmation of what their souls already sensed and believed about all life. Christ, to the Celts, was not a new word over and against what is deepest in this human mystery, but rather a profound affirmation of it.

We so easily fall asleep to this sacredness at the heart of all life that, in a way, to follow Jesus is to be repeatedly woken up and reminded of this truth. Jesus's entire life reveals how a life may be lived when we remember and insist upon the sacredness in ourselves and all people.

A few verses beyond today's reading, John will say of Jesus that from his life we have received grace upon grace upon grace. Pelagius said that this steady flow of grace acts as a gentle and sometimes rude alarm, reawakening us to each other's sacredness and then moving us to act accordingly, more lovingly and more compassionately in turn.

Soul Forgetfulness and the Call to Justice

When Pelagius arrived in Rome in the late fourth century, he witnessed the same political instability and resultant suffering that Augustine had. But Pelagius's response was to reaffirm human goodness and our capacity to love. His compelling call converted many. He encountered a church whose religion had officially become the religion of Rome some fifty years prior, and he found that the church now mirrored the excesses and abuses of the empire. In its acquiescence to imperial power, it had lost its vocation as the conscience of the state, neglecting the suffering of the vulnerable, the poor, and the outcast, whose numbers amid Rome's slow but sure collapse were increasing by the day.

Pelagius diagnosed the condition among many Jesus followers in Rome as soul forgetfulness: a denial of the sacredness in our lives, and of the goodness of our bodies and all bodies, which are worthy of great care. He said there are three types of people: those with enough, those with more than enough, and those with not enough. And the primary reason some do not have enough is that others have more than enough. Pelagius proclaimed that just as the Eucharist of this table, with its sacred elements of bread and cup, held enough for everyone, so too the natural world provided enough for everyone, its sacred gifts to be shared equally.

In a letter to a student named Celantia, Pelagius wrote:

A society can only live if people love and serve one another. That person is a Christian who is merciful to all, who is not motivated by injustice, who cannot endure the oppression of the poor before their very eyes, who comes to the aid and helps the needy, who mourns with those who mourn, who feels the suffering of others as if it were their own, who is moved to tears by the tears of others, whose doors are closed to none, whose table is familiar to all the poor, whose food is offered to all, whose goodness is known to all, and at whose hands no one suffers injustice.

Pelagius was especially aggrieved to see the subordination of the feminine within imperial Christianity. He was derided for teaching women. Jerome, a famous church leader of the time, said that Pelagius had gone mad from eating too much Scottish porridge. Yet Pelagius was simply doing in Rome what was the norm in the Celtic Christian world: celebrating the sacredness and equality of women as students and teachers alike in the study of Scripture and wisdom. Pelagius was, I think, hilariously charged with disturbing the peace, which really meant disturbing the status quo: Rome's and the church's entrenching of hierarchy and patriarchy, and its consolidation of great resources and power.

Why Original Sin Won Out

It is not hard to imagine why original sin won out over original goodness. If we are inherently sinful and in need of saving, and only the church can mediate that salvation, then we will always be dependent upon it. But if we are blessed at birth with an irrevocable goodness, and the Christ in our community exists to help people know that and remember it until the sacred in them remembers again, that would feel threatening to a church concerned primarily with its own perpetuation and power.

It is a simple but radical vision that Pelagius and others offer. When I first encountered it, it made my heart feel free. I remember saying to myself, I knew it. The same feeling happened again this week as I revisited this material in John Philip Newell's book Sacred Earth, Sacred Soul, upon which this entire series and this sermon is based. Perhaps you feel the same hearing it for the first time, especially if you grew up in a shame-based religious culture. Or maybe you feel it hearing it again for the twentieth time in your life: your soul's awakening, reawakening to what you knew all along. And we need to wake up, recover, and insist upon it more than ever.

Living in a Time of Soul Forgetfulness

In this time of soul forgetfulness, we are living daily with the consequences of what happens when we forget, obscure, or outright deny the God-given goodness within us and others. An immigrant shot in his car while his five-year-old daughter begs her father not to die. Nolan Wells, another Black son, and the latest Mississippi murder cover-up. The hanging deaths of Black people across the South, repeatedly and immediately ruled suicide. A Palestinian child killed by a drone while running to assist an injured paramedic. Masses of starving people shot at while just trying to get a meal. Women repeatedly blamed and disbelieved when assaulted and victimized. Muslims and Jews and those of other faiths scapegoated with alarming frequency. The Pentagon announcing the live stream of an execution while offering Jesus as justification, Jesus who was himself killed in a public, state-sponsored execution.

Our souls stir with sadness and rage because our souls know, in each of these cases, that something sacred is at stake. The sacred in others is denied. This is how mistreatment is justified, continued, and normalized. At its root is a pernicious worldview that some are expendable while others are not. Some are worthy of life and others are not. Translated theologically: only we are blessed, only we are truly loved by God, and others who do not believe as we do are not, and are quite literally damned.

But when everyone is sacred, fundamentally and irrevocably, the very substance of divinity in the depths of our souls, that changes things, doesn't it? Shouldn't it? Will our insistence on the goodness of humanity, when it is so easy in these days to deny and despair of it, keep our hope alive and our love aflame, and lead us to refuse its erasure in anyone?

A Face That Shines

Today, my nephew wears the cutest glasses. He is still losing his baby teeth and fighting stubborn cowlicks in his hair. He is unbelievably smart and perceptive, and he brings an undeniable joy into the room. Across his face flashes the truth of what I hold most dear, and why I long to cherish and fight for the sacredness of our entire human family. His face reminds me to hold everyone in that same precious light, even when the divine light in them or in me is obscured, unwilling or unable to shine.

After his excommunication and exile, Pelagius returned to Wales and then went on to Ireland, where the tentacles of church allied with empire had not yet reached. To ensure that his writings would circulate, he wrote under various pseudonyms, including his favorite, Augustine. Bans never work against truth, against what our souls already know. Truth will always rise again. So be encouraged in these days, and please let your light shine. For from you endures the light which the deepest night, the deepest shadows, have never overtaken.

So, sacred souls, awaken to the dignity of your being. Awaken to it in every living soul. Honor it. Defend it in heart and mind, in word and deed, in every child. In every child.

Transcript prepared with AI from the original recording and may differ from the spoken words. Check the recording before quoting. Report a correction

Share

Cite this sermon

For lessons, articles and study notes. It credits the preacher and the church and links the original recording.

Rev. Michael Lehman, “Reawakening to What Our Souls Already Know”, First Congregational Church of Los Angeles, Sunday, 11 October 2026. Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DcEX2waf1fE&t=3672s Transcript: https://sermonregistry.com/en/sermons/reawakening-to-what-our-souls-already-know-rev-michael-lehman-2026-10-11?utm_source=citation#sermon-transcript

Guided discovery

Find a sermon for where you are.