The Spirit of Our Politics
Can I Ask That?
Michael Wear · First Presbyterian Church of Spokane
The state of our politics reflects the state of our souls — if we were a different kind of people, our politics would be different.
- Preacher
- Michael Wear
- Church
- First Presbyterian Church of SpokanePresbyterianSpokane, United States
- Date
- Read time
- 16 min
- Word count
- 3,510 words
- Language
- English
Scriptures
Tags
Categories
Bible characters
Key takeaways
In this sermon▾
Introduction: A Phone Call That Changed Perspective
A few years ago, I received a call from a good friend who worked in politics. We probably don't vote the same way, but we work together on a range of issues — she does a lot of work on international human rights and religious freedom. Usually when she calls, it's because there's a human rights crisis somewhere and she wants help getting people together or writing a statement. But this time was different.
She said, "Michael, I know this is a little bit out of the blue, but I was hoping you might have some time to meet with my daughter. She's been deeply troubled by what's happening in our politics. I've tried to explain it, but my daughter doesn't quite see how the values I raised her with align with the political work I do."
My friend said her daughter was no longer attending church and was struggling in her faith. Then came the line that got me: "Michael, to be honest, I no longer care all that much about the future of my daughter's politics. I just want her to start going to church with her family again."
That was one of the most helpful things I've heard in quite some time. Here was someone who had invested their professional life in political advocacy, who was nonetheless willing to set aside their politics out of love for their daughter. As I've spoken with churches and colleges, I've come to expect there are people in our churches, our communities, maybe even our own families, who are waiting for someone to say the same kind of thing to them — waiting for someone to say that they value their walk with Jesus more than their political opinions.
So how many of us would say we'd prefer to lose in our political ambitions if it meant others might draw closer to Jesus? How many of us would say we'd prefer to sacrifice political advantage if it meant we might draw nearer to Jesus ourselves?
A Society Sick With a New Disease
In his essay Membership, C.S. Lewis writes:
"A sick society must think much about politics, as a sick man must think much about his digestion; to ignore the subject may be fatal cowardice for the one as for the other. But if either comes to regard it as the natural food of the mind — if either forgets that we think of such things only in order to be able to think of something else — then what was undertaken for the sake of health has become itself a new and deadly disease."
Our culture, and many people in our churches, are sick with that new and deadly disease. Politics is causing great spiritual harm in Americans' lives, and a big reason is that many Americans — including many Christians — are going to politics to get their spiritual needs met.
Political Sectarianism
In October 2020, fifteen scholars from a range of fields came together to issue a warning about a particular kind of polarization they termed political sectarianism: "the tendency to adopt a moralized identification with one political group and against another." It's upheld by three pillars:
- Othering — viewing opposing partisans as essentially different or alien, placing those who disagree with you outside the bounds of normal human community.
- Aversion — the tendency to dislike and distrust opposing partisans.
- Misplaced moralization — viewing opposing partisans as iniquitous rather than merely wrong-headed.
What does political life look like when it runs on the fuel of aversion, othering, and misplaced moralization? The scholars write: "Out-party hate has become more powerful than in-party love as a predictor of voting behavior." In other words, political hatred has become so profound that it outstrips many individuals' desire to actually help themselves, not to mention loftier motivations like pursuing the common good. Political sectarianism is a state in which we hate our opponents so much that we will do harm to ourselves and our interests before we concede anything to them.
The challenges in our politics are not merely systemic — they reflect how our political institutions process the habits of the heart held at the level of the individual. We are in a vicious feedback loop: a citizenry that makes itself available for political tactics that degrade people and degrade our politics, which leads to a normalization of those very tactics.
The State of Our Politics Is the State of Our Souls
My book, The Spirit of Our Politics, is grounded in the conviction that the kind of people we are has much to do with the kind of politics we have. Spiritual formation is central to civic renewal. We cannot separate our laws, our political leaders, our institutions, and our political culture from the kind of people we are.
Our politics is doing great harm materially and spiritually, and if that is to change, we must recognize the ways in which our politics is ours. If we were a different kind of people, our politics would be different.
You are not one person in politics and another person in your personal life — you're just you. Thoughts, feelings, and actions characteristic of a person in politics are not quarantined off from the rest of the person. If you are the kind of person who lies during political arguments to get your way, you are that kind of person. If you are the kind of person who wishes ill on those you disagree with politically, you are that kind of person. So — what kind of person are you? This is the question not just for politics but for life with Jesus.
Dallas Willard defined joy as "a pervasive and constant sense of well-being." How many of us would describe our current political climate that way? How many of us would describe our own approach to politics that way? Might it be a problem that so many of us don't see politics as a place for joy?
Simon the Magician: Power Without Transformation
In Acts 8, Philip was preaching the gospel in Samaria. He performed great signs — driving out impure spirits, healing the paralyzed and lame. But Philip came to a people already enamored with a man who performed signs of a different kind and from a different source.
"There was a man named Simon who had previously practiced magic in the city and amazed the people of Samaria, saying that he himself was somebody great... But when they believed Philip as he preached good news about the kingdom of God and the name of Jesus Christ, they were baptized, both men and women. Even Simon himself believed, and after being baptized he continued with Philip, and seeing signs and great miracles performed, he was amazed."
When the apostles in Jerusalem heard Samaria had received the word of God, they sent Peter and John, who prayed for them to receive the Holy Spirit. When Simon saw the Spirit given through the laying on of hands, he offered them money, saying, "Give me this power also."
"But Peter said to him, 'May your silver perish with you, because you thought you could obtain the gift of God with money! You have neither part nor lot in this matter, for your heart is not right before God. Repent therefore of this wickedness of yours, and pray to the Lord that, if possible, the intent of your heart may be forgiven you. For I see that you are in the gall of bitterness and in the bond of iniquity.' And Simon answered, 'Pray for me to the Lord, that nothing of what you have said may come upon me.'"
Simon wanted the power of the kingdom of God without becoming the kind of person fit for the kingdom. He was willing to use the language of faith, but not because he had a vision for a life of faith — he saw what Philip could do and wanted to do the same. Naturally, out of his very nature as a magician, he sought to acquire this ability through transaction, not personal transformation. Simon was not interested in the substance of the deed, but in its utility — what it could do for him.
Peter told Simon to repent — not for what he did, but for "this wickedness of yours." Simon was so inattentive to his own heart, so unable to hear Peter's rebuke, that his response made little sense: he prayed that nothing Peter said would come upon him, when Peter's rebuke was about the very nature of Simon's heart. Simon remained under the delusion that what he could or could not do was somehow removed from the kind of person he was.
The Ethiopian Eunuch: Substance Over Utility
Immediately following the story of Simon — which I don't think is a mistake — Philip encounters an Ethiopian eunuch, a man of significant status in charge of the treasury of the queen, essentially a civic role. The eunuch is also seeking knowledge of the things of God, but his story is quite different from Simon's.
"The Spirit told Philip, 'Go to that chariot and stay near it.' Then Philip ran up to the chariot and heard the man reading Isaiah the prophet, and asked, 'Do you understand what you are reading?' And he said, 'How can I, unless someone explains it to me?' And he invited Philip to come up and sit with him."
The eunuch asked Philip who the prophet was talking about — himself or someone else — and from that very question, Philip preached the gospel to him.
"As they were going along the road they came to some water, and the eunuch said, 'See, here is water! What prevents me from being baptized?' And he commanded the chariot to stop, and they both went down into the water, Philip and the eunuch, and he baptized him. And when they came up out of the water, the Spirit of the Lord carried Philip away... and the eunuch saw him no more, and went on his way rejoicing."
The eunuch learned the substance of what he desired, pursued it through means intrinsic to the desire itself, caught a vision of the gospel, set an intention to give his life to it, and immediately took up the means to do so. Scripture tells us he was filled with joy. This is a very different portrait of engagement with the kingdom of God than what we saw with Simon.
The Folly of Systems Without Formation
Our society, our politics, and many of our churches are hampered by a technological conceit — the idea that we can attain the kind of society we seek without becoming a different kind of people. Real, lasting societal change is not possible without coming to terms with the nature of the problem.
C.S. Lewis writes:
"A Christian society is not going to arrive until most of us really want it, and we are not going to want it until we become fully Christian. I may repeat 'Do as you would be done by' till I am blue in the face, but I cannot really carry it out till I love my neighbor as myself; and I cannot learn to love my neighbor as myself until I learn to love God; and I cannot learn to love God except by learning to obey Him. And so, as I warned you, we are driven on to something more inward — driven on from social matters to religious matters."
T.S. Eliot described the folly of the current human endeavor as "seeking to find a system so perfect that people will no longer have to be good." I think this describes so much of what happens in our political life today.
Dallas Willard wrote that spiritual formation, without regard to any specifically religious context, is "the process by which the human spirit or will is given a definite form or character." This happens to everyone — we each become a certain kind of person in the depths of our being. Your spirit has a character; it's being shaped and directed every day. Spiritual formation isn't something you can turn off when dealing with money, relationships, or politics and turn back on in moments of convenience. Understanding this matters not just for ourselves but as we think of others in public life — they too are being shaped, and in some measure our actions are influencing their formation.
A Politics of Brokenhearted People
It takes great vision to look at our politics and see what Parker Palmer saw: "a politics of brokenhearted people." I think that's exactly right.
C.S. Lewis, in his sermon The Weight of Glory, said something similar:
"It is a serious thing to live in a society of possible gods and goddesses, to remember that the dullest and most uninteresting person you talk to may one day be a creature which, if you saw it now, you would be strongly tempted to worship, or else a horror and a corruption such as you now meet, if at all, only in a nightmare. All day long we are in some degree helping each other to one or other of these destinations. It is with the awe and the circumspection proper to them that we should conduct all our dealings with one another, all friendships, all loves, all play, all politics."
Why Christians Engage Politics
As Christians, we care about politics because we care about our neighbors and our communities — political decisions impact our neighbors' well-being. With representative government, you do not choose to have political influence; you already have it. Sitting out of politics does not absolve you of blame for the state of our politics; it's simply your choice about how to steward the responsibility you've been given.
Politics is one of the essential forms in which we can love our neighbor — and to love our neighbor is to will their good. This is what drives Christians to politics: not to seek affirmation or a primary source of identity, but to affirm human dignity and advance justice. Our spiritual and emotional needs are met elsewhere.
As followers of Jesus, we seek to place that which is within the range of our effective will under the will of God. God's kingdom is the range of His effective will — where what He says is done, is done. But each of us has our own small kingdom, the range of our effective will, and we want to place what we have say over under the jurisdiction of love.
We will approach politics best when we do not think of politics first.
A Different Kind of Church
What if our churches made a commitment that politics, like every area of life, is a place to live out our faith? What if we made a commitment that our political opinions run secondary to our commitments to one another? What if, instead of being a source of frustration, division, and conflict, politics became a forum where we actively sought to follow Paul's call in Colossians 3 — to rid ourselves of anger, rage, malice, and slander, and instead clothe ourselves with compassion, kindness, humility, gentleness, and patience?
"Put to death therefore what is earthly in you... anger, wrath, malice, slander... and above all these put on love." (Colossians 3)
Our politics tells us that rage and malice are necessary and effective, but we have knowledge that suggests otherwise — we can live it out, we can prove it with our lives. What if, in the midst of a frantic public square, our churches and families were embassies of joy — a pervasive and constant sense of well-being? We have all that we need for this in Jesus.
Benjamin Mays said in 1951: "It isn't more light we need, it isn't more truth, and it isn't more scientific data. It's more Christ, more courage, more spiritual insight to act on the light that we have."
A future of division does not need to be our future, but we must contend for something different. We must contend for hope. We must contend for love. This is our inheritance — this treasure in jars of clay. Our politics tells us it is ultimate, but the psalmist says we can be people who have no fear of bad news, whose Lord leads them beside still waters.
Closing
I want to be like the man Jesus talked about who found a treasure hidden in a field and sold everything he had to buy that field. What do you want? What are you here for? I don't want to be like Simon — I want to be like the Ethiopian. I don't want magic; I want baptism. I don't want the trappings of God; I want God Himself, and I want Him everywhere.
I want to put on the things of Christ. I want to be so full of love for God that I'm free to love my neighbor — to will their good. This is what we need. It's what our politics needs. May God be faithful to help us want what He wants, as He has promised and is faithful to do.
Questions & Response
On what "politics" really means: Politics is about the act of governance — the decisions, systems, and structures we've created to help us decide how to live together. Voting is the baseline democratic act, but it is probably the least personally expressive political action you could take. Your vote is contingent, mediated — an act of discernment, not a dogmatic or algorithmic process. We should think of voting as a stewardship of the limited influence we have toward the love of our neighbor, as best as we can discern it.
On politics meeting spiritual needs: People determine their political participation based on how much emotional satisfaction they get from it. Political scientist Eitan Hersh coined the term "political hobbyist" — someone who spends hours consuming news, arguing online, or watching cable news, mistaking this for actual politics, when in reality "online politics is all about provocation and signaling outrage, but changing people's minds... requires empathy and face-to-face engagement." Politicians increasingly believe they benefit from feeding outrage to their base — and in treating politics like a hobby, citizens have demanded politicians act that way.
On "political therapeutic deism": This is a way of marshalling religious language and symbols as secondary support for one's political views — going to God not for God Himself, but to marshal support for political views. Its beliefs often include: God is on my political party's side; my political views are a leading indicator that I'm a true Christian; my actions in politics are justified by God's general approval; I don't understand how other Christians could vote for my candidate's opponent; and it's obvious to me which issues matter most to God.
Perhaps the greatest contribution Christianity has to make to our politics right now is not telling our politics what it is or must be, but reminding our politics what it is not — that politics is not ultimate, it's penultimate. It's not the realm of the dogmatic but the realm of the prudential, what Tim Keller would call practical wisdom.
On disagreement within the church: We shouldn't assume ultimate principles automatically translate into one particular political outcome or policy. The moment we step into politics, we can no longer aspire to be stenographers of God's will — at best we can hope to be translators of God's will, and imperfect ones at that. C.S. Lewis, in Meditations on the Third Commandment, warns that the primary temptation when combining faith and politics is to proclaim "God hath said" when He hasn't spoken — to use God's name in vain. One practical shift: instead of saying "I am a Christian, therefore I support candidate A," say "I'm motivated by my Christian faith to support candidate A." That shift helps make clear we're in the translator's seat, imperfectly translating enduring truths into the realm of politics.
On families and friends who disagree politically: The aim for Christian families should not be political uniformity but spiritual integrity. Most of the time, your moral obligation in these conversations is not to correct someone's bad political opinions. Ask questions rather than offering retorts — people often lead with talking points, but if you stick with them, you'll get to what's actually driving their heart on an issue, and you can relate to them personally. If we're not willing to stick with people beyond the political performance, we'll never see eye to eye, because we're dealing with how they think politics has to be talked about, not with who they actually are.
On hope: It's not safe for Christians to engage in politics with their feet planted in politics — but there are tremendous possibilities when Christians engage with their feet planted in the gospel. I've met countless civic leaders and Christian college students with a profound heart for justice who believe politics can be a place of service. We need eyes to see — it takes courage to name the darkness, but it takes even more courage to say, "I think God is moving here." I'm hopeful for a church that pursues spiritual integrity over political uniformity.
Transcript prepared with AI from the original recording and may differ from the spoken words. Check the recording before quoting. Report a correction
Cite this sermon
For lessons, articles and study notes. It credits the preacher and the church and links the original recording.





