Skip to main content
Back to sermons

Thoughts that Stick

Johnny Baker · NewStory Church

Our hurts often produce 'hang-ups'—sticky, false beliefs about ourselves, God, and others that function like a faulty internal GPS.

Sign in to save Sign in to mark completedSign in to keep this private.
Preacher
Johnny Baker
Church
NewStory ChurchNon-DenominationalLos Angeles, United States
Date
Read time
19 min
Word count
4,137 words
Language
English

Scriptures

CitedQuoted
Romans 12:22 Corinthians 10:5Genesis 1:26John 3:16Philippians 1:6John 151 Thessalonians 5:11James 5:16

Tags

Categories

Mental and Emotional HealthRecovery MinistryDiscipleship

Bible characters

Jesus

Key takeaways

  • Our hurts often produce 'hang-ups'—sticky, false beliefs about ourselves, God, and others that function like a faulty internal GPS.
  • Scripture calls us to take every thought captive and test it against God's truth rather than letting unchecked thoughts shape our behavior (2 Corinthians 10:5, Romans 12:2).
  • Renewing our minds requires bringing our hang-ups honestly to God and trusting what He actually says about us.
  • Healing happens in vulnerable, trustworthy community—bringing others into our struggles so they can speak truth we can't always see ourselves.
  • Recognizing our hang-ups allows us to move from automatic reaction to intentional response, freeing us to live out of God's truth instead of old pain.

Share this quote

In this sermon▾

Introduction: The Thoughts We Carry

What I want to talk about today is the thoughts that we carry around with us. If you're like me, there is a constant stream of thoughts going on in your head all the time. And what I have found for myself, and for many of us, is that those thoughts are not always positive. They're not always thoughts that build ourselves up. They're not always thoughts that give us a right perspective of who we are and where we belong in the world.

I'm part of a ministry called Celebrate Recovery. My goal by the time we're done today is to have all of you decide that you need to check out Celebrate Recovery, because I want to help us understand that our thoughts are a part of us, but they don't have to stay the way they are. In fact, God talks about renewing our minds in Romans 12:2:

Do not conform to the pattern of this world, but be transformed by the renewing of your mind. Then you'll be able to test and approve what God's will is, his good, pleasing, and perfect will.

We all have these thoughts that we carry around with us that aren't true, that aren't helpful, and that don't give us a clear picture of who we are or the world in which we live. In Celebrate Recovery, we would call these hang-ups.

Sticky and Leaky: What Is a Hang-Up?

These hang-ups are two things: they're sticky and they're leaky. They become our constant companion. I heard somebody once say that nobody thinks about you as much as you think about you. For most of us, we're the star of the movie — we're the main character. So we think about ourselves a lot. But the problem is some of the things we think about ourselves just flat out aren't true. Because they're in our own minds, often in our own voices, they feel like we came up with them on our own, so they stay around and impact our lives in ways we don't even think about.

Celebrate Recovery is for anybody with hurts, hang-ups, and habits. The truth about our hang-ups is that it all starts with hurt. We go through painful experiences, and as a way to make sense of that experience, we begin to tell ourselves stories. These stories become hang-ups.

A good working definition for a hang-up is: any thought or belief system we have about ourselves, other people, God, or the world in which we live. The problem is these hang-ups aren't true. They feel true because we say them to ourselves a lot, or maybe other people have said them to us a lot, and it feels like truth — it might even feel comfortable — but the reality is it's not true. It's a faulty guide.

The Apple Maps Illustration

I love and use Apple Maps. When Maps first came out, I didn't trust it right away. I had to test it going somewhere I already knew how to get, like the grocery store. After years of using it, now when I need to go someplace I've never been, I put the address in and I hit go — I never stop and think, is it going to take me the right direction?

But imagine if, when I tested it on that mile-and-a-half trip to the grocery store, it had taken me three hours out of the way. I would stop trusting that app. Instead, if something seems off, I assume I put the address in wrong, not that the Maps app is working wrong. I trust the guide.

The problem is many of us have this internal thought life that works like a GPS, but it's faulty — because it all starts with how we've been hurt.

How Hurt Becomes a Hang-Up

All of us have been hurt by people around us, and we've all hurt people around us — often unintentionally, but sometimes intentionally. That hurt does something inside of us. The first thing it does is kick off an emotion. This emotion is God-given; God is an emotional God, and we're made in his image. At the same time, it's biological — we can't do anything about it.

Some science says that if you go through an experience and an emotion is triggered, if you just sit with it for about 90 seconds, that chemical reaction in your brain will fade. But how many of us actually do that?

A Story from the Freeway

It happened to me on the way to church this morning. I drive a 2013 Honda Fit — not a great car. My kids call other Honda Fits they see "members of FIT army." I got passed by a big F350 pickup truck, and as he passed me, he revved his engine at me. I started to get angry and began telling myself a story about what his life is like, how sad he must be that he has to show off to a guy in a Honda Fit. By about five miles down the road he was gone, and I was still arguing with someone I'd never met. My anger flared, and then I needed to make sense of that anger, so I told myself a story.

The same thing happens in our lives. Something happens to us, and we tell ourselves a story. Somebody says something that hurts your feelings. You say, "That really hurt my feelings," and they say, "You're just so sensitive." Hear that enough times, and pretty soon the story becomes, "I'm overly sensitive." So when my feelings get hurt, it's not that person who hurt my feelings — it's something wrong with me. And that becomes a hang-up.

The Child and the Out-of-Control Parent

Researchers have found that if a child is raised in a home with an out-of-control parent — someone who gets angry and flies off the handle — it's actually safer for that child to believe it's something they've done wrong than to believe their parent is simply out of control. That makes sense: a kid depends on their parents, and if they think their parent is undependable, that's a lot scarier than thinking, "There's something wrong with me that makes mom or dad fly off the handle." But that belief can become a lifelong hang-up.

Leaning In or Stuffing It Down

So we get hurt, an emotion is charged up in us, we tell ourselves stories, and then usually there are one of two responses.

  1. We lean into the feeling. You feel anger, and you say, "It's go time," put on the heaviest music, and decide everyone's going to feel your anger. Or you feel sad, so you listen to the saddest song you can find, watch The Notebook for the hundredth time, and think about every sad thing that's ever happened to you. When we lean into an emotion like this, it's usually a sign that emotion was safe for us to express in our family of origin.

  2. We stuff it, deny it, push it away. You get angry and say, "No, I'm not angry," and push it down. "Men don't cry," so you push sadness down too. When we do this, it's usually a sign that emotion was unsafe or unacceptable for us growing up.

All of this serves to form in us these thought systems, these belief systems, these sticky hang-ups that we can't shake. They become part of who we are. We carry them around and start saying things like:

  • "I'm always going to be ______."
  • "Everyone around me is looking to take advantage of me, so I have to have my guard up at all times."
  • "If I'm going to be safe, I have to be in control — of myself, other people, the world around me."

These hang-ups become part of our inner monologue. We think them over and over again, and it affects not just what we think but how we behave. We're no longer operating on the truth of who God says we are — we're operating on this faulty guidance system, and we begin behaving in ways we wouldn't if we had a different thought system.

Hang-Ups Operate Under the Surface

Often these thoughts go unchecked in our lives. We leave them alone, run as if they're true, and most of the time we're not even aware of them. If I asked you right now what thought or belief system you have that's untrue, you'd probably think, "None — everything I think is true," because that's how we operate. Even if the thing you thought about yourself was negative, challenging it wouldn't feel good. If you told me, "I always mess up," and I said, "I bet there are times you do a great job," you'd say, "Nope, not me." It would feel bad to hear otherwise because that system has become so ingrained we don't even see it anymore.

The Magic Eye Poster

Some of you might remember Magic Eye posters from the '90s and 2000s — kiosks in the mall with posters that just looked like static. If you relaxed your eyes just right and looked at a certain point, that static image would suddenly become a pirate ship or a heart. And once you saw that image, you could never unsee it. The next time you saw that poster, even in a totally different mall, you'd immediately see the pirate ship — you could no longer see the static.

Our hang-ups are the same way. We operate with them under the surface all the time, ignoring them because they feel true. And we've done a great job collecting evidence for them over the years — we look for things that back up what we think and believe, often at a subconscious level.

  • If we think everyone's going to take advantage of us, every time that happens, it goes in the column of "I'm right."
  • If we think we're too sensitive, every time our feelings get hurt, it goes in the column of "I'm right."

The People-Pleasing Hang-Up

Maybe, like me, you carry around the hang-up that you're responsible for the emotional well-being of everyone around you. If someone is sad, angry, or upset, you feel it's your job to fix that feeling. So as people-pleasers, we go into hypervigilance trying to make everything just right. Maybe you know someone who, when they get angry, starts cleaning — and you hop up and start cleaning too. Or they get sad, and you think, "What do I do to make you feel better?" The feeling becomes: I'm responsible for your emotions. 

This can seem good — "I'm going to soothe the people around me, I'm going to take care of people." But the problem is we're not actually serving them; we're serving ourselves, because there's something going crazy inside of us when someone close to us is upset. How many of you know that when you ask somebody how they're doing and they say "fine," it sets off an alarm system in your head? Because "fine" can mean "fine," or it can mean "fine, but you're really in trouble."

We can go through life with this operating system that says: I'm responsible for everyone's emotions. If I'm well-behaved, everyone's happy; if I'm poorly behaved, everyone's upset. So now I'm no longer thinking about my own needs — I'm thinking about everyone else instead, operating out of a hang-up.

Exchanging Our Hang-Ups for God's Truth

These hang-ups are sticky, but once we see them, we can begin to address them. Although they can become invisible and something we operate out of without realizing it, God wants us to see the truth. He doesn't want us operating out of the lies we've been told or the lies we tell ourselves — he wants us to operate out of his truth.

So rather than just saying, "You've all got faulty operating systems, have a good week," I want to help us see a couple of ways we can begin to exchange our hang-ups for God's truth.

1. Bring It to God

The first step is that we have to bring our hang-ups to God. To do that, we first have to admit that they're lies. We have to start testing and checking our thoughts and asking: is that true, or is that a lie?

2 Corinthians 10:5 says:

We demolish arguments and every pretension that sets itself up against the knowledge of God, and we take captive every thought to make it obedient to Christ.

I've heard that verse a lot, read it a lot, even taught on it a lot. But as I was preparing this message, something stuck out to me that never had before: it doesn't say every bad thought. It doesn't say every lustful thought. It doesn't say every thought about a certain topic. It says we take captive every thought.

If you could see or hear what's happening in my brain, there are thoughts coming a mile a minute, and I don't take those thoughts captive. They just go through my head. The more often I've heard a thought, or thought a thought, the easier it is for me to believe it's true. The same is true for you.

This verse tells us that we take captive every thought and bring it to God. We say:

  • "God, am I really responsible for everybody's emotions, or is everybody responsible for their own?"
  • "God, is it really up to me to be in control at all times?"
  • "God, is it really my job to perform?"
  • "God, is everybody out there really a villain and I'm a victim?"

We take those thoughts captive and bring them to him so he can begin to show us his truth. This is what Romans 12:2 means:

Do not conform any longer to the pattern of this world, but be transformed by the renewing of your mind. Then you will be able to test and approve what God's will is, his good, pleasing, and perfect will.

What can that mean more than that we exchange our hang-ups for his truth? He is renewing our mind. So instead of thinking things like:

  • "I'm responsible for the feelings and emotions of those around me."
  • "People can't be trusted. No one's willing to help me. If I want to get something done, I have to do it myself."
  • "I'm fundamentally unlovable. I'm too much for people."
  • "At my core, there's something wrong with me."
  • "My feelings are too much for people."

...instead of feeling and thinking those things, we can bring them to God and test them against his word. When we do, we often see the exact opposite of what we think and carry around with us.

  • Maybe you say, "There's something fundamentally wrong with me," and God says, "I made you in my image" (Genesis 1:26).
  • Maybe you say, "I'm unlovable," and God says, "I love you so much I sent Jesus for you" (John 3:16).
  • Or you say, "I'll never get it together," and God says, "I'm not done working on you yet" (Philippians 1:6).

We take them to God over and over again and ask, "God, is that what you say about me?" And we capture it and test it. When we read the word, we can see that he's talking to us directly. When we pray, the Spirit will tell us the truth.

So many of us find it easier to see God speaking truth about others than about ourselves. Sometimes I'll read the Bible and say, "God, you love people so much," and he'll say, "No, Johnny, I love you. Look at how much I sacrificed — Jesus went to the cross for all of us." "No, Johnny, I did that for you." If we can begin to internalize that God is not just saying these things about humanity in general, but about us specifically, it can begin to change our thoughts.

So the first thing is we have to bring it to God: "God, this is what I feel is true about me — what do you say about me?" And then we have to trust what he says about us.

2. Bring Others Along With You

One great way to continue to collect evidence is to bring other people along with you. Now, this takes vulnerability, because it's not fun to share your hang-ups with each other.

In fact, I would say this needs to be with somebody you really trust. This would be a terrible first date icebreaker: "So tell me, what are all your hang-ups? What are all the things you think about yourself, God, or other people that aren't true?" That would not go well. But to do this with safe people is liberating. That's why therapy or counseling, support groups, small groups, or Celebrate Recovery can be so powerful — because we bring other people around us, and when we say things like, "I'm fundamentally unlovable," they can say, "That's not true. I love you, man." "Man, I'm just such a screw-up." "Man, I saw you do a great job the other day. You're doing great."

Sometimes that's going to feel great, and sometimes it's going to feel terrible, because when people tell us the opposite of our hang-up, it can feel like they're giving us a false compliment. So many of us, myself included, are so bad at taking compliments. If somebody starts to say something nice about you, it's like, "Oh gosh, where do I put my hands?" I just want to walk away. The same thing can happen when somebody speaks against our hang-ups — it can feel the same way.

But it's so important to bring people along with you because they can see things from outside of your perspective. They can see truth about you that maybe you can't see about yourself. Look for someone you trust — someone who you know has your best interest at heart. The person who hurt you is probably not likely to be the person to help you heal from this wound.

For me, more often than not, it's my wife. If you knew my wife, you'd know two things about her: one, she always tells the truth, and two, sometimes you wish she wouldn't. There are times you're like, "Just make me feel good." But the truth is that having other people who can speak truth in your life — you can begin to trust them, as well as trusting what God is saying about you.

Catching the Thought Before It Runs Rampant

The thought, unchecked, has run rampant. The way this works is it freezes you, and then you begin to live out of it. What I want for you is to be able to catch those hang-ups as they happen, and in the moment go, "Wait a second — is that true?" And if not, I can do something different.

Left unchecked, we're stuck in reaction. Something happens, we react to it. When we begin to test our thoughts, gather evidence against them, go to Jesus with them, go to other people with them — now, when that thought comes up, instead of feeling like I have to just react, I can act. I can stop and say, "Oh, I'm lying to myself. Oh, that's that old tape that keeps playing in my mind. That's that old thought that feels so comfortable" — because most of these were formed as a coping mechanism for us.

Now, when I talk about the fact that this came from hurt, this is in no way to blame someone else for our thoughts or our actions. It's in no way so I can say, "It's your fault that I'm so messed up." I have no interest in that. What I want to be able to do is explain, at least to myself, why I do the things I do, so that I can stop doing the things I no longer want to do.

So often all we do is look at the thing we don't want to do and say, "I just got to stop." But if we don't understand why we do it in the first place, we're either destined to fail, or we're going to start something else that we don't want to do either. And yes, I'm talking about the big things — addictions, those kinds of things. But I'm also talking about:

  • Building walls between me and other people in relationships, not letting people see the real me
  • Telling half-truths so that people are happy with me
  • Controlling people, trying to get them to live the way I want them to live

All of those behaviors leak out of our hurts and our hang-ups. So what we want to do is capture them when we have them, bring them to Jesus, and invite other people in with us so that they can tell us the truth as well. Then we can do something different.

Everyone Is Carrying Pain

One of the things I want to share with you is the idea that everyone you know has been hurt in some way. Everyone in this room, everyone you'll see as you leave, everyone you'll interact with today is carrying pain. Some of it you'll know about, some of it you'll never know. That pain has caused them to believe things about themselves, God, other people, the world in which they live. And those hang-ups have caused them to act in a certain way.  

I don't tell you that so you'd let people off the hook, or so you'd judge them really harshly. I say that just so you'd know two things: one, you're not alone — there's nothing wrong with you; and two, this is part of the human condition. When you catch it, you can see it, and then you can choose to act differently.

Hearing Jesus Speak Directly to You

I mentioned going to scripture and reading God's word. What I'm trying to do is act as though, especially when I read the words of Jesus, that he's speaking directly to me.

What I would encourage you to do right now, if you're comfortable, is close your eyes. I want to read to you a section of scripture where Jesus is talking to his disciples. It's right before he goes to the cross, found in John 15. As I read this, imagine that this is not just in the Bible, but that this is Jesus speaking directly to you. Try to tune out anybody else in the room and just imagine this is Jesus speaking to you. Here's what he's saying:

As the Father has loved me, so have I loved you. Now remain in my love. If you keep my commands, you will remain in my love, just as I have kept my Father's commands and remain in his love. I have told you this so that my joy may be in you and that your joy may be complete. My command is this: love each other as I have loved you. Greater love has no one than this: to lay down one's life for one's friends. You are my friends if you do what I command. I no longer call you servants, because a servant does not know his master's business. Instead, I have called you friends, for everything I learned from my Father I have made known to you. You did not choose me, but I chose you and appointed you so that you might go and bear fruit — fruit that will last — so that whatever you ask in my name, the Father will give you. This is my command: love each other.

I want you to catch a few things he says there. First, he says he loves you — he says that over and over and over again. He says he chooses you. He appointed you. He gives you his joy. I love that he calls us friend. He says over and over that you are loved.

I hope that you'll take this piece of evidence and go through scripture and find more pieces of evidence. Bring others along with you.

Therefore encourage one another and build each other up, just as in fact you are doing. (1 Thessalonians 5:11)

We're not supposed to go through this alone. There's power in community.

Therefore confess your sins to each other and pray for each other so that you may be healed. The prayer of a righteous person is powerful and effective. (James 5:16)

Conclusion

Here's what I want for you — it's what I want for me. I want to be able to see my hang-ups clearly so that I can take them to Jesus, and he can renew my mind. Because renewing my mind will lead to a transformed life — one where I'm no longer at the mercy of my thought life, but I'm free in his truth.

Transcript prepared with AI from the original recording and may differ from the spoken words. Check the recording before quoting. Report a correction

Share

Cite this sermon

For lessons, articles and study notes. It credits the preacher and the church and links the original recording.

Johnny Baker, “Thoughts that Stick”, NewStory Church, Sunday, 13 September 2026. Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EdoreerM_DM&t=32s Transcript: https://sermonregistry.com/en/sermons/thoughts-that-stick-johnny-baker-2026-09-13?utm_source=citation#sermon-transcript

Guided discovery

Find a sermon for where you are.