Skip to main content
Back to sermons

What If (Part Two)

What If?

Alvin Love III · Nashville Life Church

Tithing is giving back to God through the local church where one is accountable and submitted, not merely generosity given to any cause.

Sign in to save Sign in to mark completedSign in to keep this private.
Church
Nashville Life ChurchOtherNashville, United States
Date
Read time
14 min
Word count
2,994 words
Language
English

Scriptures

CitedQuoted
Malachi 3:10Matthew 5:37Matthew 6:211 Chronicles 29:3

Tags

Categories

StewardshipTithingGenerosityChurch Membership

Bible characters

AbrahamJacobMosesDavid

Key takeaways

  • Tithing is giving back to God through the local church where one is accountable and submitted, not merely generosity given to any cause.
  • Tithing is a tenth returned to God that belongs to him already, while giving above the tithe is personal generosity.
  • Unity in the church is strengthened when members honestly say yes and actually do what they commit to.
  • Faithful, unified tithing is presented as the key to a corporate blessing so large the church cannot contain it.

Share this quote

In this sermon▾

Good morning, everybody. For the rest of November, we are dedicating our whole month to At the Movies. We are going to host four weeks of showing movies that many of us know, and I'm going to take the themes from those movies to share the gospel. I'm going to basically treat these movies like parables, showing a good movie to people who don't yet know Jesus, but tying it to the truth of Jesus Christ.

The key to enjoying November is to come in ready to have fun. If you're uptight, it's not going to work. There's going to be a bunch of popcorn, we're going to have Cokes in the sanctuary, and we're breaking the rules. Kids Life is going to have their own At the Movies, with Wreck-It Ralph and Nemo and characters walking around. For the month of November, this place is going to be a place of good times, and on top of that, people are going to be saved.

For those of you who were here last week, congratulations, you came back. For those of you here for the first time, I highly recommend checking out last week's message on our podcast or YouTube, because it served as a foundation for what we're talking about today. Some of this can be a sensitive topic, but it is a necessary one when it comes to our obedience to God and his plans for our lives.

The Promise to the Jews, Extended to Us

The series is called What If?, and it stems from a very exciting offer God gave to the Jews. Through Jesus Christ, the word says that those of us who are not Jews have been grafted into this amazing family and get to inherit God's promises as if we were Jews. Though this passage is in Malachi and was written to the Jews, I believe it applies to our church today, just as the Ten Commandments and the other great things we find in the Old Testament still apply to us.

Malachi 3:10 says:

"Bring all the tithes into the storehouse, that there may be food in My house, and try Me now in this," says the LORD of hosts, "if I will not open for you the windows of heaven and pour out for you such blessing that there will not be room enough to receive it."

Defining the Terms

There is a wide range of biblical knowledge in the room, which we love, and this church is just as much for newer believers and those who don't yet know Jesus as for anyone else. So let's make sure everyone is caught up.

A tithe simply means a tenth, a tenth of any increase God blesses you with, whether that be cattle or goats or chickens. In 2026, for most of us, that's our money: the income God blesses us with through our employment and work.

The storehouse God refers to is not some random barn on the side. It is God's house, the place where worship happens, where priests administer worship and sacraments, and where offerings go up to God. That is the storehouse where the community worships and brings its offerings.

The Practical and the Supernatural Outcomes

The passage describes two outcomes. The first is practical: more resources. The more ears of corn we bring in, the more corn we have to feed everybody. The more cows we have, the more beef we have for everyone. That's the math.

The second outcome is supernatural, and it is the one I'm most curious about. God says there will be a blessing on the unity of the community, producing an excessive, more-than-enough blessing on his people. The word you in Malachi is plural. This involves all of us. And the blessing is so heavy that there won't be room enough to receive it.

I consider myself a blessed man, and I think I'm speaking to a room of blessed people. But I can't remember a time I told God, "No, thanks, that's too much." So I believe there is still room, which means we are still seeing what it takes for this promise to manifest.

Tithing Before the Law

For those not familiar, tithing is a pre-Mosaic principle established by Abraham, where the first tenth of his increase went to God by way of the priest. Abraham gave it to God by way of the priest Melchizedek. Sometimes we ask, "God, you say this is for you, but why am I giving it to them?" You give it to God by way of the priest. Abraham's grandson Jacob later vowed that a tenth of everything God gave him would go to God, but he gave it through the house.

So tithing sets the precedent of a pattern: we give to God, and we give it to his house, where the priests are and where worship happens, where the storehouse is. Even in Malachi, God says, "Tithe by giving to My house." We don't throw a $30 bill into the sky and hope it works. We give it to the storehouse, God's house, if we want it to be what the tithe biblically is.

What If All the Tithe?

The scripture says "bring all the tithe," so my question is this: what if all the tithe is the key to a miracle none of us have seen firsthand? Including me.

I don't believe none of us have seen this miracle because God has stopped offering it, or because the promise expired. I believe it is because none of us have been part of a church community where everyone tithed. We have been in communities where some tithed. If you have been part of a church where everyone did, find me after church, because I want to take notes. I'm convinced it hasn't been done much, if ever. That doesn't mean it isn't something God is still inviting us to.

What if the abundant corporate blessing God promises, a blessing so large we lack room to receive it, depends on the unified participation of our church? I say corporate because everyone is in this. The blessing is not just for an individual. It is for the collective, a mass blessing.

What We Believe as a House

If you call Nashville Life your home, this should not be controversial or surprising, because we cover it before anyone joins. At Next Steps, we make clear how this house believes: we believe in tithing, and we expect members to be faithful in it. If you say this is where you are accountable, this is what we expect.

That said, it is not an enforced requirement. If it were, some of us wouldn't be here. There is space for people not to do this. But many of us have taken that liberty.

We recently did a study. We compared our total giving to the average household income in the zip codes our givers come from. It is a rough estimate, but we have reason to believe it is somewhat accurate. The comparison showed that our giving is about 30% of our tithe potential.

I'm not interested in comparing ourselves to other churches. I want to compare ourselves to what God is inviting us to and the vision I believe he is casting. As blessed as this church is (people are getting saved, healed, experiencing joy and growth), we are currently working at roughly 30% of what we could be. And that 30% is only among those who give. It does not include those who have never given financially. So if we counted everyone who comes to Nashville Life, the number would be far lower.

This means a large percentage of our church, even after hearing this is our standard for membership, have not adopted it personally, yet they continue forward in membership, and some even in leadership.

Tithe Versus Generosity

Some of us give far more than ten percent away and call anything we give the tithe, including charity and nonprofit giving. I want to be clear about what we believe here. Some people consider whatever they give away to be their tithe, rather than tithing being exclusive to God's house. I'm not here to say what is right and wrong in every case. My point is that these differences in belief and practice are compromising the unity of the church.

As far as this house is concerned, here is the standard, for anyone who forgot from Next Steps and for visitors scoping out where to go:

All tithe to God is through your local church, wherever you are submitted and accountable.

I have to be specific with that wording. There was a time when we could say "wherever you are fed," but in 2026, between YouTube and podcasts, everybody is feeding everybody. So it's wherever you are accountable, wherever you are submitted, where the people who know you are. For those of you watching online, I'm glad you're being fed, but if we are not your local church, don't tithe to us. Tithe to your local church. You are more than welcome to give above your tithe to bless us, but if this is not the body you are submitted to, the tithe is not for us.

I might have just lost a lot of money right there, but I believe in the principle more than I believe in money.

The tithe is not my generosity. Tithing is simply giving back to God what already belongs to him. If I gave you a cookie and you gave me back a piece of it, you wouldn't be considered generous. It was mine to begin with. So let's say my tithe is ten dollars. Once I give ten dollars and one cent, I believe that one cent is my first step into generosity.

Everything above the tithe is generosity, and it is your personal choice, given to whomever and wherever you're inspired: to the poor, to the under-resourced, to missionaries, to nonprofits, to education, to your alma mater, to helping a sibling with a mortgage, to picking up the lunch tab for a friend. That is generosity, loving people through giving. It can be spiritual, or simply being kind. Jesus says when you are kind to the least of these, you are being kind to him. Scripture says the more you sow, the more you reap, and I believe that holds in this life and the next. I am definitely pro-generosity. But the tithe and generosity are two separate buckets. With the second, you go and be led and have fun, because I've found that being generous is fun.

Yes Means Yes

This is how unity is compromised: when someone hears that this is the standard of the house, comes, and agrees to it by saying yes, but doesn't actually do it. Unity is not compromised by an honest yes or an honest no. Saying yes and doing yes is good. Saying no and doing no is good, because you're clear. Saying yes and doing no weakens unity. Saying no and doing yes is also not good.

Jesus puts it simply in Matthew 5:37: let your yes be yes, and your no, no. He goes on to say that whatever is more than these comes from the evil one. As a pastor, part of my job is making sure we are not opening unnecessary doors for the evil one. Imagine filling a bucket with water to take home to your family, only for the enemy to keep punching holes in it, so that by the time you get home, a large portion is gone. I'm trying to plug those holes so we can retain the full glory of what God intends for our church. I believe this is an area where the evil one is poking holes, and there is a leak, perhaps a large one.

The Status Quo Is the Enemy

Where we sit with participation and tithing is probably fairly standard, perhaps even on the higher end, for the United States. But sometimes the greatest threat to God's promises is the status quo. Often the greatest enemy to God's promises for your life is not the devil, but what everybody else is doing.

Moses sent twelve spies to scope out the land God had promised, a land already occupied by other tribes. When they came back, ten of the twelve said it was impossible, a suicide mission. Two said they believed God and could take it. In that situation, the status quo was unbelief: the belief that God is not real, that he doesn't mean what he says, and that he lacks the ability to protect us. And that status quo was so hostile that the ten tried to have the two who believed God killed. Moses had to intervene to stop the status quo from killing the two who trusted God.

The Heart Behind Giving

We have seen God do remarkable things in our church, and I believe this is the area where the enemy has been trying to poke holes, and there may be a large leak. Giving is not just a financial matter; it is a matter of the heart.

"For where your treasure is, there your heart will be also." — Matthew 6:21

David understood this. In 1 Chronicles 29:3 he says, "Moreover, because I have set my affection on the house of my God, I have given to the house of my God over and above all that I have prepared for the holy house, my own special treasure of gold and silver." David's heart was set on God, and so his treasure followed his heart into the house of God.

Following the Few, Not the Status Quo

We have already seen that the status quo can be a serious threat to God's promises. The average Christian in our country today does not pray in tongues regularly, does not serve faithfully in their church, does not tithe, has not led someone to Jesus, does not fast for spiritual reasons, and is not intentionally making disciples. Many do not know their Bible, and few are willing to lose their sins, money, relationships, or dreams for their faith.

I am not saying this to depress us. I am saying it so we realize that the status quo is not worth trying to keep up with. The status quo can give you company and numbers. You will not be lonely, but you may not be faithful, on fire, or obedient. If you find your safety in numbers, the status quo may be for you. But if you are following Jesus and obeying his word, you may not have the comfort of numbers, and you will have the comfort of your Father in heaven and of the Holy Spirit.

The Narrow Way

Jesus said that the way is hard and few find it, while the majority is headed toward destruction. What if we chose to be among the few who do not simply hear the word, but actually do what it says? What if God is still looking for people who will believe him enough to act on what he says?

The One Place God Says "Test Me"

Scripture tells us not to test the Lord our God. The one exception is tithing. Malachi 3:10 is the one place in Scripture where God says, in effect, "I dare you to do this." What if he is still looking for people who will take him at his word and are bold enough to actually test him?

The Fruit of Generosity

I praise God for the generosity of our church. We have seen more generosity than in the past fifteen years. In 2025 alone, Nashville Life gave nearly half a million dollars to missions, both local and national. Our total budget was once not even a quarter of that amount. We have also been able to double what we give in benevolence this year to those with needs inside the church, and we are preparing a grocery giveaway on November 14 that will feed many families.

Beyond the numbers are the testimonies of salvations, healings, and Holy Spirit baptisms. I heard that three people were baptized in the Holy Spirit at a small group a couple of weeks ago. God is doing things among us. Despite some rocky roads this year, we are still a joyful church, and we are still a diverse church. God has protected that diversity.

Imagining What Could Be

As blessed as we are, all of this glory is coming from about 30% of what we could be. If 30% looks like this, imagine what could happen at 45%, 57%, or 63%. When you think about it in these terms, it makes sense that when God says all of it comes in, there will be more blessing than we have room to receive.

Tithing Is Not the Key to God's Love

Tithing is not the key to God's love, and it is not the key to his mercy. Your sins are forgiven through Christ. Tithing is the key to a specific miracle: a corporate outpouring of blessing on the whole body, so heavy that the group cannot contain it all.

Setting the Heart Toward God

This month is primarily about the heart. The vehicle may be money, but the core is our hearts. In 1 Chronicles 29, after the people had given willingly, "the people rejoiced, for they had offered willingly with a loyal heart to the Lord." David prayed that God would keep this heart forever in the thoughts of his people and fix their hearts toward him.

When people's hearts are set toward God, they allow their income and increase to be set on him as well. We should ask God to show us what it looks like to give him our hearts in tangible, practical ways, and to save us from a generation that says it loves God but does not do what he says.

Transcript prepared with AI from the original recording and may differ from the spoken words. Check the recording before quoting. Report a correction

Share

Cite this sermon

For lessons, articles and study notes. It credits the preacher and the church and links the original recording.

Alvin Love III, “What If (Part Two)”, Nashville Life Church, Monday, 12 October 2026. Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=15z8YsN4GHY&t=86s Transcript: https://sermonregistry.com/en/sermons/what-if-part-two-alvin-love-iii-2026-10-12?utm_source=citation#sermon-transcript

Guided discovery

Find a sermon for where you are.