Esta página ainda não foi totalmente traduzida. Parte ou a totalidade do texto abaixo é apresentada em English, o idioma original.
What Matters Most | Josh Martin | October 4, 2026 | Vision Series
A Different Kind of Scoreboard
Josh Martin · Grace Church San Diego
The church's true measure of success is making disciples who make disciples, not attendance, giving, or decisions alone.
- Pregador
- Josh Martin
- Igreja
- Grace Church San DiegoOtherSan Diego, United States
- Data
- Tempo de leitura
- 15 min
- Número de palavras
- 3.162 palavras
- Idioma
- inglês
Passagens bíblicas
Etiquetas
Categorias
Personagens bíblicas
Ideias-chave
Neste sermão▾
A Different Kind of Scoreboard
Every October, we set aside our regular series to look again at God's vision for our church and our lives. It is easy to drift, to focus on good things instead of the best things, and to give our attention to things that are not worthy of it. So once a year we stop and ask: what is God's vision for the church, and what does it mean for my life?
Measuring the Right Things
In 2002, the Oakland Athletics had a budget of about $40 million, while other baseball teams spent hundreds of millions. The A's could not compete financially, so their manager began questioning the whole system. He asked how baseball decides what a valuable player looks like. For generations the answer was batting average, home runs, speed, appearance, and the instincts of experienced scouts.
He went back to the most basic question: what are we trying to achieve? The answer was runs, because runs equal wins. The metric above all others was on-base percentage. They built a team with their $40 million around people who could get on base, because if you can get on base, you can create runs, and if you create runs, you create wins.
This philosophy was disruptive and created real tension in the organization. Eventually the A's bought in, and the crescendo of the story is the A's winning 20 games in a row, an American League record. The A's realized they had confused what baseball traditionally valued with the things that actually produce winning baseball. Other teams eventually adopted the same approach, and what became known as Moneyball transformed the league because it was a better way.
The Church's Scoreboard
This illustration fits our vision series because the church is tempted to measure the wrong things. We put disproportionate value on things that don't put points on the board. What if we have gotten very good at counting the wrong things?
The typical church scoreboard looks like this: Sunday attendance, decisions for Christ, people serving, people giving. It becomes a funnel: come on Sunday, come to Christ, serve and give, and then we leave you alone. Those are good things, but the question is whether they contribute to a victory, whether they move us toward a better on-base percentage.
Over the next four weeks, we want to rediscover what Jesus calls a win, looking at the ministry of Jesus and the book of Acts to see where God tells us winning is.
Jesus Begins His Public Ministry
In Matthew 4, Jesus returns from forty days in the wilderness and speaks his first public words:
"Repent, for the kingdom of heaven has come near." As Jesus walked beside the Sea of Galilee, he saw two brothers, Simon called Peter and his brother Andrew, casting a net into the lake, for they were fishermen. "Come, follow me," Jesus said, "and I will send you out to fish for people." At once they left their nets and followed him.
Jesus is calling what in the ancient world would be an apprentice, a disciple. His message is: follow me, and in following me I will form you and then send you out toward others. A disciple is someone who follows Jesus, becomes like Jesus, and does what Jesus did. Jesus is forming a new people, and the twelve disciples represent the twelve tribes of Israel. This is the new mission.
A Crowd Is Not Enough
In Matthew 9, Jesus travels through towns and villages teaching, proclaiming the good news, and healing every disease and sickness. When he sees the crowds, he has compassion on them, "because they were harassed and helpless, like sheep without a shepherd." He turns to his disciples and says, "The harvest is plentiful, but the workers are few." Then he gives the twelve authority to drive out impure spirits and heal, and sends them out.
You would expect a large crowd to bring great joy to Jesus. But the text says his heart is filled not with joy but with compassion. A big crowd was not a win for him. For many of us, a big crowd feels like the proof of success. We might give Jesus a report: we run four services, our reviews are solid, the preschool is thriving, the counseling center is full, we've grown by a thousand people in four years. Jesus would be kind about it, but the question he cares about is a different metric.
It is easy to gather a crowd. Foolishness gathers crowds. Teaching with no biblical value gathers crowds. So Jesus is not impressed by the harvest alone. The harvest is not the problem; laborers are. His concern is raising workers, not gathering crowds.
Disciples Who Make Disciples
Jesus models ministry for his disciples, matures them, and then empowers them to go out and do it. His life goal is to raise up leaders who walk in the gospel he has accomplished for them. In John 17, before he leaves, Jesus prays: "As you have sent me into the world, so I have sent them into the world." In John 20, after the resurrection, he says the same thing: "As the Father has sent me, so I am sending you."
In Matthew 28, the resurrected Jesus says, "All authority in heaven and on earth has been given to me. Therefore, go and make disciples of all nations." Jesus has done his part: he reconciled us to God, lived a perfect life, died in our place, and rose from the dead. Now it is the disciples' turn to take this mission to the ends of the earth.
In that moment he defines what winning is. Disciples who make disciples. That is Jesus' on-base percentage, his Moneyball. He is so committed to this vision that he promises, "I am with you always, to the very end of the age," and the Holy Spirit will empower them to make it happen.
The Mission Before the Church
In Acts 1:8, Jesus says, "You will receive power when the Holy Spirit comes on you, and you will be my witnesses in Jerusalem, Judea, Samaria, and to the ends of the earth." To have the Holy Spirit is to be empowered to witness. The gospel goes forward and it works. People respond. Those converts become disciples, disciples form communities, communities raise up leaders, and those leaders are sent to start the process over again. The mission comes before the church. The mission is pre-church.
Peter takes this up in Acts 2, preaching the first gospel sermon, and the Holy Spirit falls. About three thousand people follow Christ and are baptized. Jesus is gone, yet his ministry continues. The new believers devote themselves to the apostles' teaching, to fellowship, to the breaking of bread, and to prayer. Everyone is filled with awe at the wonders and signs performed by the apostles, the ones who had been with Jesus and were now doing what he did.
The community was so compelling that "the Lord added to their number daily those who were being saved." People were rescued by Christ into a community, and that community drew in new believers. For three or four years the church in Jerusalem flourished, so much so that in Acts 6 they appointed deacons to organize the growing church. But the mission was always to take it to the ends of the earth, and for those years they remained in Jerusalem.
Scattered, and Then Exploding
The story turns in Acts 7 when Stephen, a young deacon, is killed for his faith, the first martyr. Acts 8:1 says that a great persecution broke out against the church in Jerusalem, and everyone except the apostles was scattered throughout Judea and Samaria. It looks like the end. The greatest power in the ancient world has allowed persecution against this small group, and it appears Christianity will be taken out.
But it is not the end of Christianity. It is its explosion. Every persecuted Christian who was scattered carried the gospel and the ability to share it and make disciples. Any one of them could be dropped anywhere and reproduce everything. That is why it is painted on the wall in our lobby: any one of those disciples could be dropped anywhere and reproduce everything.
Acts 11 shows new communities of disciples and new churches springing up. This was not the apostles or the leaders; these were regular Christians taking the gospel with them everywhere. Some of the scattered believers went to Antioch and began speaking to the Greeks also, and "the Lord's hand was with them, and a great number of people believed and turned to the Lord." From that moment the church's center shifts from Jerusalem to Antioch, and nobody knows exactly who started the church there. Regular Christians started it.
The Church That Sends
In Acts 13, the church in Antioch, with its prophets and teachers, is worshiping and fasting when the Holy Spirit says, "Set apart for me Barnabas and Saul for the work to which I have called them." After they fast and pray, the church places its hands on them and sends them off. This is the moment in church history where everything changes. The church in Antioch begins to live out the command of Acts 1: the church that was reached becomes a church that sends.
The pattern is a cycle. The church is sent on mission. The gospel goes forward and works. People respond. Disciples are made, communities form, and churches raise up leaders who are sent out again. It is an ongoing, ever-present cycle, again and again.
Why is Acts 13 a moment that will never be experienced again in the same way? In Acts 8, the church was sent by persecution. Scattered by force, they took the gospel with them. But by Acts 13, the church no longer needs persecution to be sent. The church is now sending on its own, by the Spirit's direction, with prayer, fasting, and the laying on of hands.
Before there is a church, there is a mission. Jesus told his followers in Acts 1 that they would be his witnesses, and God's mission for the church is that the gospel would go forward. When the gospel goes forward, it works. People respond in faith. When people respond, disciples are made. Those disciples form communities we call churches, and those churches raise up leaders to send people out with the gospel again.
This is an ongoing, ever-present cycle: sent, works, disciples, churches, leaders, sent again. It repeats again and again.
Why Acts 13 Is Different
Why is Acts 13 a moment in church history that will never be experienced again in the same way? In Acts 8, the church was sent by persecution. It was scattered by force, and the gospel traveled with those who fled. But in Acts 13, the church no longer needs persecution to send anyone. They worship, they fast, they listen to the Holy Spirit, and they willingly send out Barnabas and Saul.
By Acts 13, the church had learned to participate intentionally in the movement Jesus announced in Acts 1.
"Set apart for me Barnabas and Saul for the work to which I have called them." — Acts 13:2
Fascinatingly, the first person commissioned by the church in Acts 13 is the same man who oversaw the killing of Stephen in Acts 7. Saul, the one who led the persecution that scattered the church, is now sent out as a missionary by the very church he once persecuted. It is a scandal of the gospel, and it is the movement.
The Vision
Here is the goal. It is a Spirit-led willingness to multiply churches and disciples, to multiply disciples within churches. We would embrace this cycle voluntarily. We would not need persecution, pressure, trouble, or metrics to drive us.
How are we doing at this at Grace Church San Diego? Honestly, sermons like this one rarely draw much response, and that is understandable. The American evangelical culture has seldom asked this of people. It has asked us to enjoy worship songs and feel something, to buy books and listen to preachers who make us feel better about our lives, our stuff, and ourselves. We have been fed that vision in many forms, and we consume it because it surrounds us.
Jesus, by contrast, says the thing he cares about most is this. Yet many systems have measured success by how many people can fit in a room and how big the building can become. We have measured the church by its seating capacity instead of its sending capacity.
Three Environments
At Grace Church San Diego, we have three environments, and most churches have only two.
- Sunday gathering: This is where we are now, for the Word of God and worship. We hear the Word preached and we worship together.
- House church: This is a geographical home where we try to live out Acts 2. We are family on mission, living together, eating together daily, walking through life together, making friends, and enjoying one another.
- Huddle: This is where disciples are made. A house church leader gathers three or four people at a separate time. Together they repent of their sins, grow to become like Jesus, and are trained to do what Jesus did.
Most churches say, "Go to church and go to small group." We say, "Go to church, go to small group, and go to huddle." Think of it like the big group, Jesus and the Twelve, and then Jesus and the three.
Where We Are Now
On an average Sunday, about 1,200 people attend, not counting children. About 1,023 are involved in house church, so we are doing well at getting people into house church. Five hundred thirty people have said they are members, committed to the church, giving, and sacrificing. Four hundred ten people are in huddle, and 110 of them are leading huddles. We are doing a good job moving people through a process.
But the middle number is the one Jesus most wants to talk to us about. That is the number of laborers, the people who can make disciples and raise up others to make disciples.
What We Celebrate
As a church we celebrate three things:
- Baptism: When a new person becomes a Christian and is baptized, we celebrate with clapping, crying, and joy.
- First-time guests: When someone first comes to house church, bringing a casserole, chips, or something to share, that is a moment of welcome and connection. We love tracking first-time guests.
- Multiplication: When a huddle multiplies within a house church, that is a major celebration. When one of the people in a huddle goes into the house church, gathers a few more people, and begins discipling them, that is a sign of life.
Our vision is that every member of our church would be in a huddle, being discipled, and eventually able to lead a huddle as a disciple maker. That is the endgame. We want you to be discipled, which means walking with Jesus and becoming like him. Then we want you to do what Jesus did, which is go and make disciples.
Our Strained System
If we are honest, our system is stressed right now. Our house church model grew from 1 to 36 in four years. It is chaos, and there is not much room to walk when people arrive with casseroles. Our system is strained, but that does not change the vision of making more laborers and more disciple makers.
God's Vision for Your Life
God's vision for your life is not only to save money, see the world, get married, have children, or pursue whatever else you hope for. Consider this: What if God is asking you to become so much like Jesus that you have within you the ability to lead someone else to Christ? And not only to lead them to Christ, but to open the Word of God with them and open your life to them, so that they too become like Christ and, by God's grace, turn around and lead someone else to Christ.
Imagine one Sunday, a baptism Sunday, when you walk into church and into that tub comes your spiritual grandchild, someone you led to Christ, who walked with you, matured in Christ, and then led someone else to Christ. You watch them get into the water and you weep, because for a moment you realize your life has had eternal impact, and that you are doing the work of making disciples of all nations.
When I speak about this, I do not want you to feel pressure, shame, or sorrow. I want you to ask yourself what a Spirit-led willingness looks like. After one service, a woman came to me with her husband and said they might host a house church. Whatever the Spirit is leading you to do next, what is your next step? Maybe you need to get baptized. Maybe you need to bring a casserole to house church. Maybe you need to join a huddle. Whatever it is, lay before the Lord a willingness that says, "God, lead me to my next step."
Standing on Those Who Went Before
You and I are here today because others lived into this vision. We have the gospel because the original eleven disciples, after Judas was lost, did what they were told. The early church did what they were told, and when everyone was scattered, they did what they were told. Our own church was started in 1912 by people from Arizona who came to San Diego to bring the gospel. We have the gospel because of those who planted this church and remained faithful. Now it is our turn to make disciples and to be reminded of this vision.
The Right Metric
This matters for our church. If attendance becomes the definition of success, we will learn to increase attendance and pander to it. If giving becomes success, we will make giving the center of everything we do. If decisions become success, we will make every week an altar call to make people cry and bow their heads. But Jesus did not ask us to increase any of those metrics. He asked us to increase one: making disciples. Disciples who make disciples.
It is like Moneyball: on-base percentage is what creates runs and wins. If we make disciples, we will plant churches and send missionaries. But we have to increase that middle number. Ask God what your next step is and how you can move forward in making disciples.
Prayer
We prayed together, thanking God for his Word, for friends who gathered despite the heat, and for the gospel as the good news that Christ has done everything necessary for our salvation. We asked God to show us our next step, to increase the number of disciple makers in our church, and to help us grow for his glory.
Transcrição preparada com IA a partir da gravação original; pode diferir das palavras proferidas. Confirme na gravação antes de citar. Comunicar uma correção
Citar este sermão
Para lições, artigos e notas de estudo. Credita o pregador e a igreja e liga à gravação original.





