Saltar al contenido principal

Esta página aún no se ha traducido por completo. Parte o la totalidad del texto siguiente se muestra en English, su idioma original.

Volver a los sermones

God's Hopeless Optimism

A sermon on the Book of Jonah

Rev. Rob Fuquay · St. Luke's United Methodist Church

God's love and mercy extend even to our enemies and those we despise; holding a line against injustice does not require abandoning compassion.

Predicador
Rev. Rob Fuquay
Iglesia
St. Luke's United Methodist ChurchMethodistIndianapolis, United States
Fecha
Tiempo de lectura
10 min
Número de palabras
2060 palabras
Idioma
inglés

Pasajes bíblicos

Sin referencia identificada

No se ha identificado ninguna referencia bíblica explícita para este sermón.

Etiquetas

Categorías

biblical storytellingenemy lovemoral frameworkresistance and gracepersonal transformation

Personajes bíblicos

JonahJesus

Ideas clave

  • God's love and mercy extend even to our enemies and those we despise; holding a line against injustice does not require abandoning compassion.

    Compartir esta idea clave

    Tarjeta de cita: God's love and mercy extend even to our enemies and those we despise; holding a line against injustice does not require abandoning compassion.
  • Personal encounters with those we have stereotyped or hated can transform our hearts and challenge us to see our enemies as complex human beings deserving of dignity.

    Compartir esta idea clave

    Tarjeta de cita: Personal encounters with those we have stereotyped or hated can transform our hearts and challenge us to see our enemies as complex human beings deserving of dignity.
  • A breakdown in shared moral frameworks has made us reduce people to political categories; recovering civility requires rebuilding our capacity for empathy and understanding across difference.

    Compartir esta idea clave

    Tarjeta de cita: A breakdown in shared moral frameworks has made us reduce people to political categories; recovering civility requires rebuilding our capacity for empathy and understanding across difference.
  • True Christian resistance, like the way of the cross, resists evil without losing love—it keeps caring even while standing firmly against injustice.

    Compartir esta idea clave

    Tarjeta de cita: True Christian resistance, like the way of the cross, resists evil without losing love—it keeps caring even while standing firmly against injustice.

Compartir esta cita

En este sermón▾

God's Hopeless Optimism: The Story of Jonah

Why Stories Matter

Bishop N.T. Wright reminds us that "Our task is to find ways of doing things differently, planting flags in a hostile soil, setting up signposts that say there's a different way to be human. Find ways, fresh ways, of telling the story of the return of the human race from its exile, and use stories as your explanation."

This is exactly what the ancient biblical writers did. They told stories about the human race returning from exile, using narratives to inspire people with a different and better way in the midst of the division and hurt that defines our world. Stories like Jonah—much like the ancient Sumerian Epic of Gilgamesh—challenge us to reconsider how we treat our enemies.

The Context: Jonah and the Assyrians

In the 8th century BC, the Assyrians conquered Israel as a ruthless people. They would harm and torture enemies as if it were sport. The king of the Assyrians, who lived in the capital city of Nineveh, wallpapered his palace with the skins of conquered enemies. The Jews lived in fear of this tyrant.

Then God does something unexpected: God sends Jonah, an Israelite, to preach to the Assyrians. Jonah doesn't want to go—not because of what the Assyrians might do to him, but because of what God might do to them. More accurately, Jonah fears what God might not do to them. Because Jonah doesn't want to go, he boards a ship to Tarsus, heading in the opposite direction of Nineveh.

Running from God

You can't get away from God. God sends a storm so violent it threatens to tear the ship apart. The sailors believe they won't survive, so Jonah convinces them that if they throw him overboard, they'll be spared. The sailors finally relent and toss Jonah into the sea. God then sends a great fish to swallow him, and Jonah survives in the belly of the fish for three days and three nights.

Some people get caught up in the details—could a whale really swallow a person?—and miss the point entirely. The question the story asks us is this: Have we ever despised somebody so much that we cannot imagine them getting anything better than they deserve? This story speaks to anyone who would rather have God punish their enemies than change their hearts.

The Miracle of Three Days

Three days and three nights—does that remind you of another Bible story? When the Bible speaks of someone in a dark, enclosed place for three days, something miraculous is about to happen. In the belly of the fish, Jonah prays. At the end of his prayer, he essentially says to God: I do believe your way is best. God causes the fish to vomit Jonah up on the beach.

God gives people second chances. The word of the Lord came to Jonah a second time.

Preaching Doom with a Smile

Jonah goes to Nineveh and begins to walk through the great city, preaching a simple sermon: "IN 40 DAYS, GOD IS GOING TO DESTROY THE CITY OF NINEVEH."

One wonders about people who preach doom and gloom while smiling as they do it. But something surprising happens. The people listen. They put on sackcloth and ashes—the sign of repentance. They're changing. Word reaches the king, and he repents and changes too. Imagine that: a king who listens to his people. Something crazy is going on in Nineveh.

The Heart of the Matter: God's Hopeless Optimism

But Jonah either doesn't believe the people can really change, or he doesn't believe God will really forgive. He climbs a hill where he can see the whole city and waits for the destruction that never comes. Now Jonah is angry. He says to God:

"This is exactly why I did not want to come here. Because God, you are hopeless. YOU CANNOT help yourself from showing mercy to people."

For Jonah, God is hopeless because God won't slam the door on people even when they deserve it. God leaves the door cracked open. God is hopeless when it comes to hoping people will change, to wanting to show mercy and grace. When we put limits on love, it doesn't ever lead to a better place.

The Modern Crisis: How America Got Mean

In 2023, David Brooks wrote an article titled "How America Got Mean." He argues that our modern division and mean-spiritedness derives from a breakdown of an enduring moral framework—one that teaches us how to show respect, model civility, and be empathetic toward other people. Without that framework, we don't try to understand others. Our default becomes judging, based on a simple criterion: who is right and who is wrong?

This is why we've become so hyper-politicized. Politics appears to give people a sense of righteousness. A person's moral structure is based not on their conduct, but on their location on the political spectrum. You don't have to be good—you just have to be liberal or conservative.

Consider the story from the book I Think You're Wrong, But I'm Listening: An elected official, a Democrat, posted on Facebook that she had voted for a well-known Republican in an election. The reaction from her fellow Democrats was swift and ugly. They called for her removal from office. She was no longer a neighbor, a friend, or even a complex person. She was wrong. And that was that.

The Danger of Reduction

What's dangerous about this pattern is that it creates a reduction in our lives. We start to reduce our connections to those we agree with, those who share our sense of who is right and who is wrong.

But the real danger is what this pattern forms in us unconsciously. It creates an instinctive reaction: every time we encounter difference with a person, we find ourselves reflexively wanting to withdraw, to step away, to separate. And the truth is, we're going to have differences with anybody because we're different people. But when you get into this pattern of reduction, what really happens is our own hearts get reduced. Our own willingness to understand other people gets reduced. Our compassion gets reduced.

This is what was happening with Jonah.

God's Teaching Through a Plant

God has a little fun with Jonah. Sitting on the hilltop overlooking the city, Jonah expects destruction. God causes a plant to grow and give him shade—because if you're going to be angry and in a stew, you might as well be comfortable. Then God sends a worm to eat the plant. It dies. Now Jonah's head is baking in the sun, and he just wants to die. He's mad at the world, mad at God, just mad altogether.

God speaks a closing commentary:

"How is it that you can change your feelings from pleasure to anger overnight about a mere shade tree that you did nothing to get? You neither planted nor watered it. It grew up one night, it died the next. So, why can't I likewise change what I feel about Nineveh from anger to pleasure? This big city of more than 120,000 childlike people who don't know yet right from wrong, to say nothing of all the innocent animals."

In other words: Jonah, you care more about a plant than you do people. You care more about your own comfort than you do the needs of an entire population and race of people.

Jonah is learning what God desires for us: to hold a line, but not to let go of compassion.

The Author's Own Journey

Bible scholar Peter Enns makes a compelling argument about who wrote Jonah. He believes the author was a captive Israelite who went to Nineveh—someone who arrived in as much anger as Jonah carried. Someone who could not stand these people. But living with them for a while, he began to see them differently.

He realized: "Wait a minute, they're just families worried about their children. They're just people trying to make ends meet. They're people I see have goodness in their hearts by the way they treat each other. They're people like me who get afraid of things and act out of their fears."

This changed the author's heart. Out of that comes the story. As Peter Enns wrote:

"Our author poses not a God of uncompromising harsh judgment. Rather, in his fictional story, he's posing a question. What if God is not our private deity who aims to wipe out our enemies? What if our God Yahweh has room in his heart for everyone, even the people we hate the most?"

Resistance Without Losing Compassion

I don't know how I feel about that, especially right now. Just a few days ago, I stood on the beaches of Normandy. On June 6, 1944, over 4,400 allied soldiers were gunned down resisting a tyrant. Over the three months of the Normandy campaign, 73,000 allied soldiers were killed, not to mention all the many who were injured. Hitler was not defeated because soldiers laid down their weapons and handed roses to their enemy. Hitler was defeated because people resisted. Resistance is needed when there are threats to human flourishing.

But I also stood at a different place in Normandy: Bocage, where there is a memorial to our former senior pastor, Carver McGriff. Part of Carver's ashes are buried beneath that memorial.

At Bocage, Carver was injured in battle. His life was saved because of soldiers in his unit he did not like—Mexican-American soldiers. He was prejudiced toward them. Yet lying on the field of battle with bullets whizzing, he felt arms pick him up and say, "We're going to get you out of here." The Mexican-American soldiers saved Carver's life. He realized in that moment: I can never look down on anybody again.

Then he was taken to a medic station—a German medic station. Carver was the only Allied soldier in the room. All the other wounded soldiers were German. His doctor was a German doctor. Lying on the gurney, Carver looked over at a young boy next to him, about Carver's age, and they locked eyes for a moment. The boy smiled at him.

That did something to Carver. He said, "Just a few moments ago, I was trying to kill him, and he was trying to kill me, and now we look at each other as if to say, 'In different circumstances, we'd probably be friends. We'd probably be taking care of our families, going to work, meeting up afterward, watching sports together.'" It messed with Carver's entire worldview of who this enemy is and how they all must be evil. German soldiers, German doctors, others in his unit—they showed him kindness.

In Carver's own words from his book about Normandy:

"Despite the unthinkable horrors perpetrated by the Germans against the innocents, I have to believe there was still decency to be found among the Nazis. I have to believe that God was urgently seeking entrance into German hearts and was having some success. From German blood came Hitler and Göring and all the criminals of the Nazis. But too far from that same blood, but not far from that same blood, came Niemoller and Bonhoeffer and Tillich. Christian theologians. For me, it's a mystery still concealed in God's great plan for human destiny. I cannot explain the Holocaust nor any evil which prompted it in a loving creation. I can, however, perceive the evidence of God's love moving within that destiny. That I can choose to trust."

Carver was believing a different story.

The Birth of St. Luke's Vision

What happened in Carver's heart moved him in a way that, 40 years after that event, he stood before this congregation and said: We are going to be an open community. The story of St. Luke's was born in Normandy. It was born in the midst of a very bad tyrant hurting and harming people, and people standing up in resistance.

It is not an easy balance to resist and not lose compassion. But that's the way of God. That is the way of the cross. The cross is a symbol of resistance—but not a resistance that hurts people. It is a resistance that keeps loving and keeps caring.

Bishop N.T. Wright said, "Our task is to tell better stories of human history being redeemed, coming back from its exile."

What's your story?

Transcripción preparada con IA a partir de la grabación original; puede diferir de las palabras pronunciadas. Consulte la grabación antes de citar. Comunicar una corrección

Compartir

Citar este sermón

Para lecciones, artículos y notas de estudio. Reconoce al predicador y a la iglesia y enlaza la grabación original.

Rev. Rob Fuquay, «God's Hopeless Optimism», St. Luke's United Methodist Church, lunes, 19 de octubre de 2026. Grabación: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e7XAe1T8GcE&t=22s Transcripción: https://sermonregistry.com/es/sermons/god-s-hopeless-optimism-rev-rob-fuquay-2026-10-19?utm_source=citation#sermon-transcript

Descubrimiento guiado

Encuentra un sermón para el momento en que estás.