Esta página aún no se ha traducido por completo. Parte o la totalidad del texto siguiente se muestra en English, su idioma original.
Luke - The Cost of Discipleship - Sermon - RD McClenagan - 10/18/26
The Cost of Discipleship
RD McClenagan · Fellowship Church Of Knoxville
Following Jesus requires placing love and devotion to Him above every competing allegiance, because God is a jealous God who desires wholehearted devotion.
- Predicador
- RD McClenagan
- Iglesia
- Fellowship Church Of KnoxvilleEvangelicalKnoxville, United States
- Fecha
- Tiempo de lectura
- 26 min
- Número de palabras
- 5654 palabras
- Idioma
- inglés
Pasajes bíblicos
Etiquetas
Categorías
Personajes bíblicos
Ideas clave
En este sermón▾
An Opening Story: Bonhoeffer and Finkenwalde
Good morning, brothers and sisters. We began this morning in Luke 14:25–27, where a great crowd was following Jesus, and He turned to them and spoke words that are hard to hear: "If anyone comes to me and does not hate his father and mother, wife and children, brothers and sisters, yes, even his own life, he cannot be my disciple. And whoever does not bear his cross and come after me cannot be my disciple."
To help us feel the weight of that call, I want to take us back about ninety years, to Germany in 1935. Under Adolf Hitler's Nazi regime, the church was under enormous pressure. The Nazis wanted control of the church, and they allowed Christians to practice their faith only in ways that history describes as deeply restricted. Worship was no longer pure. Allegiance to Christ was no longer undivided, because for Hitler a certain kind of devotion was required.
The church in Nazi Germany gradually compromised, blending its loyalties between the state and the church. Dietrich Bonhoeffer, one of the most well-known pastors to see this clearly, recognized that these things could not be made identical. You cannot hold these two together. The compromise was enormous, and the message of Jesus and the kingdom of God that transcends this world was fading.
"If we want to have any influence on this rising storm, we must return to the basics and point people to the way of Jesus, the life of Jesus, and the truth of Jesus."
Returning to the Basics
So Bonhoeffer asked, what do we do? How do we face a state with the power and resources that Nazi Germany had? In 1935 he chose to return to the basics. He established a theological seminary, acquired a house in the German town of Finkenwalde, and began training pastors and laypeople alike in a deep, serious discipleship.
The training Bonhoeffer gave was, at its heart, simply what Jesus had laid down. This pattern of discipleship was essential to our identity, so that we could resist what was happening outside.
A Friend Asks Questions
As the story is told, a friend came to visit Bonhoeffer because he had heard about Finkenwalde and what was happening there. The friend thought, "This is radical. This is extreme. Is this necessary? Are you being too extreme? Too harsh? It isn't that bad."
We should remember that when you look back to 1935 and 1936, it did not seem so bad to many people. It seemed perfectly normal. It is like trying to tell a fish that this is not water. The fish does not know what water is. It is all it has ever known.
Bonhoeffer had, in a sense, a prophetic vision: "No, this is not normal. This is not acceptable." God gives such a vision to prophets so that they can see things and have the courage to act. So when his friend asked him to tell more about what he was doing, Bonhoeffer took him on a walk up a hill. From the top they looked over a vast field where thousands of German soldiers were training for what was coming.
Bonhoeffer said, pointing back toward the seminary: "This, what happens here, must be stronger than what happens in that field. The formation taking place in this theological school and in the church must be stronger than the cultural formation of Nazi Germany. It must be stronger. That is why we train people this way."
The Spiritual Battle Beneath the Political
Bonhoeffer would say that what was happening in Nazi Germany was not at its core a political battle but a spiritual one. The enemy disguises the battle as political, so we think it is about this or that, when in truth it is always about a spiritual reality. He had the clarity to say: "No, we are raising a generation of pastors and leaders committed to the way, the truth, and the life of Jesus, and we will not compromise."
And what did it cost him? It cost him his life. You can go and see the place. I have visited it twice. You can go to the area where the manor stood in Finkenwalde, Germany, which is now part of modern Poland, because Nazi Germany no longer exists. But the kingdom of God still remains.
There is a stone with the name Finkenwalde on it, and a memorial garden you can walk through. It is small, not huge, just a simple country house. Each time I think about this story, I think about our reality today in Poland, and about how for many of us, especially in the West, the freedoms we enjoy, inherited from the past, make the world look different than it once did. Here we see Dietrich Bonhoeffer, who ultimately, as you know, died for his faith.
For me, the power of that place is that it is still relevant and central today: the idea that the way of Jesus and the call to truth is what sets it apart. Discipleship must be stronger than the pull and temptation of this world. We live in a time of enormous compromise about what it means to be Christian, about the church, and about the purity of the church, where everything gets mixed together.
God Is a Jealous God
Someone might say, "This is just water, this is normal." But when I think about it, I see that God has raised up more and more prophets to say that this is not normal. Biblical God is a jealous God. He is jealous for your love, jealous for your heart, jealous for his glory. He will not share his place with other gods. So to be followers means to be wholly devoted to him, because he is the only true God.
The vision Bonhoeffer saw, and that many saints have seen throughout history, is simply this: "Lord, we want your way, your heart, and your vision to be greater, more important, stronger, and more central than anything else, because nothing can compete with you, even though we know that many things do compete." That is the reality of life.
This is why our mission statement at Fellowship is bold and innovative: to be a church that creates and develops followers of Jesus. The whole thing comes down to this. You want to see renewal. You want to see the kingdom of God come. You want to see darkness pushed back by the light of Jesus. That light comes through people who say: Lord, your will, your way, not mine. These are the ones Jesus seeks. He seeks people committed to his way, his will, his heart, and his vision. These are the revolutionaries, the committed ones.
The Cost of Following Jesus
Many of us will likely not live the life Bonhoeffer lived. But we all have the same resources. Bonhoeffer was not Jesus. He was a human being, a man gripped by seeing what God had done through Jesus Christ, the costly grace of the gospel, so that he said, "How could I not give everything?" As Kate said at her baptism, "I owe my obedience to the one who gave everything for me."
This is the pattern. And so the teaching of Jesus we read today is among his most famous and most difficult sayings. But the call still stands today. Wholehearted devotion to Jesus is what the Father desires, and he will keep emphasizing this again and again to draw us back.
I promise we will go into this in more detail, but I will pause here for a moment. A great crowd was traveling with him. As Jesus neared the final stages of his earthly ministry, many crowds surrounded him because people were drawn to his teaching and his way. He performed miracles and fed people.
Let me say, there is nothing wrong with crowds. Crowds are not bad things. They are sometimes criticized in churches, but crowds can be helpful. We have a crowd here every Sunday, and I am grateful for it. Crowds can be useful. They can be wonderful places to learn. They can also be good places to hide. But with the teaching of Jesus, it often begins in the crowd, and then, of course, what he seeks is to go deeper and deeper.
So the crowds are with him and following him, and then he turns and speaks these piercing words to separate truth from falsehood. Luke tells us first: "Large crowds were traveling with him, and he turned to them and said, 'If anyone comes to me and does not hate his father and mother, wife and children, brothers and sisters, yes, even his own life, he cannot be my disciple. And whoever does not bear his cross and come after me cannot be my disciple.'"
These are probably not the words you would say if you really wanted to start a huge movement. If Jesus had undergone public relations training and said, "This is my message: come and die," they would probably have said, "Well, can we not say that? Can we say come and live?" And he would have said, "It is the same."
But as you know, when you read this, and if you have read the Bible before, you know that when people reach this part of the Gospels where Jesus speaks about carrying the cross, "eat my flesh and drink my blood," it sounds like madness. To borrow C.S. Lewis's idea, what does he ask? He does not only say follow my teaching, though he says that. He says, "If anyone comes to me and does not hate his father." In short, Jesus names every member of your family, and even yourself. So everything is included here.
Two Important Points
Now there are two important points to notice. First, the call to discipleship that Jesus gives here, which he gave in his ministry and which he gives here more broadly, is a call for everyone. It is for all. There is no group of people Jesus selects while others are left out, though it may seem that way. There is no hierarchy in the kingdom of God. Theologically, you may be at a different stage of maturity in your walk with Christ than someone else, but everyone is on the field. Everyone is in. Each person has a role, a position, a place. But everyone is on the field.
God, of course, does not need your gifts, but he desires that you be a blessing to others through them. He wants you there. So remember this: the call is for everyone. He turned to the great crowd and said, "If anyone comes to me..."
Do you know what the word "anyone" means? Even here in Greek it means anyone. It means everyone. Everyone has the capacity to follow this. Whoever does not bear his cross cannot follow me and be called my disciple.
Now, the use of the word "hate" is harsh language, so just to clarify, Jesus is making a comparison here. We know from his teaching that even for our enemies, Jesus calls us to love them, and he also calls us to love ourselves, as we love our neighbor. You cannot love your neighbor if you do not love yourself. So what Jesus is saying is not an absolute hatred and fierce anger toward your parents. That does not fit with the teaching of the Bible or with how you should view yourself. What he is describing is a deep level of comparison and priority. To the degree that you love me by comparison, you hate your family and yourself. This is critically important.
It is not as though you can love me and love your family at the same time. Rather, it is like saying: no, by comparison, if you want to be my disciple, if you want to carry your cross, your love for me must exceed your love for your family and for yourself. If it does not, you cannot be my disciple. You must bear your cross yourself.
Ordering Our Loves
Wow. Even here we see the recurring thread you will see in the letters of Jesus and Paul across the Old and New Testaments: God is a jealous God, and the priority he wants for your life is that he be first, central, and alone. Everything else has its place and its importance. You are to honor and love your parents, and love your children. You are to love yourself, but not more than you love Christ. Not more than you love the Lord. He is above all.
When that order is disrupted, things begin to go wrong. Sin is missing the mark, and, as Augustine said, sin at its root is disordered love. Loving things first when they should be loved second. So if your loves are disordered, following Jesus always means reordering them rightly: Lord, you are first. Lord, you are central. Everything else is lower than that, and I can love those other things in a healthier and more complete way because I love you first and foremost.
Augustine, in his Confessions, an incredible book, speaks to the idea that the key to life change, the key to real transformation, is not mere willpower. It is not simply trying harder or attempting to act. It is in fact a change of heart, because what you love determines the kind of life you live. If you order what you love rightly, much grows from there.
So sin is not simply a failure to hit the target or just doing bad things. Certainly those are true. But sin is in fact loving anything or anyone more than God. This is the first commandment: you shall have no other gods before me. You shall not have another god, because God is a jealous God. So the right ordering matters enormously. And we often get the order wrong. And when we do, everything collapses sideways.
C.S. Lewis says: "Put first things first and you get the second thing thrown in; put second things first and you lose both the first and the second." We do not even get the sensual enjoyment of food in its fullest when we are greedy. In other words, you cannot enjoy food if it has become an idol. If you crave food, if food is your source of satisfaction in life, what happens? It is never enough. Gluttony is a sin, and I think it is the sin of our culture. Right? It is never enough, because whatever you make the ultimate end that it is not will collapse. It is a disordered love. It is out of control.
So you have to choose what you will serve. For example, in modern American culture, if your children are the center of your home life, if they are everything to you, you will feel the pressure, the burden, and the expectations that you place on them to fulfill your own goals. Loving them that way will ultimately crush them. Why? Because children are wonderful. I love all three of my children. If I make my love for them greater than my love for God, if I make everything about them ultimately the most important thing, they will become gods to me and I will crush them. Because I would then have to, as a god, justify myself by how successful they are at such and such. Does that make sense? Yes. I mean, hypothetically, of course. This is directed at you, not at me. So take it as you will.
This is the great teaching Martin Luther offers in some of his writings on idolatry, which has been repeated again and again: that in the Old Testament, idols were carved statues, but at their heart there was something that lured people away from fundamental worship of God. That cannot be allowed to happen. So we live in a moment where you can feel, well, I love my children. I love my spouse. Well, I love my sports teams. And I love them all. It is wonderful. But if that is everything, at some point it will break you, because anything you live for that is more than Christ will ultimately disappoint you. And perhaps far more than that, it will shatter and break you. This is what often happens, right?
So what Jesus is saying here is that I must be your first love. In Lewis's terms, the first thing at the center and foundation of your life is in fact a life for God. Discipleship is built on love for God, love for Christ, and love for the Holy Spirit. That must be the central core and not divided.
Counting the Cost
But here is what I probably know about most of the listeners today. I think most of you will call yourself Christian. You call yourselves disciples. And here is the truth about how our week looks in most weeks: our discipleship to Jesus is not as pure or wholehearted as we would like it to be. It is divided among many competing things. Right? Yes. When we review our past week, do we say that Jesus was everywhere, as he always is, on the throne of my life? No. Well, that is great news. We can all raise our hands. Right? What often happens on a Sunday morning is simply a beautiful reminder that Christ is everything, Christ is enough, the Holy Spirit dwells in us, and you have all the hope in the world. There are some things to repent of and change, which differ from week to week.
But what often happens is this. Jesus uses here the picture of a half-built tower, where you start something and cannot finish because you did not count the cost. In Luke 14:28, going back to Luke: "For which of you, desiring to build a tower, does not first sit down and count the cost, whether he has enough to complete it?" Think about any home improvement project. You have to count the cost first, whether you have enough to complete it. Otherwise, Jesus says, "When he has laid a foundation and is not able to finish, all who see it begin to mock him, saying, 'This man began to build and was not able to finish.'"
But it is as though we all know this. Jesus says, "Folks, many people who start a journey with me are not genuine converts, and they have no idea what they have actually signed up for. It is just a fire insurance policy, right? It is insurance against the fire. I mean, that is the only point of following Jesus." When things go badly, or you are in the valley of despair, or the life you thought Jesus owed you is not the life you are actually living, what happens? You walk away. And Jesus telling you to really count the cost does not help you there.
From this, Bonhoeffer drew the title of his book The Cost of Discipleship. To have a real sense of what discipleship will be. So here it is. Is there a cost to full discipleship to Jesus? Certainly. But there is a greater cost to divided discipleship, or to not being a disciple at all. There is a cost for that too. Everything has a cost. No one in the world receives no discipleship or formation from someone or something. As on planet Earth, there is no neutral ground. No one is exempt from the powers of this world. Everyone moves toward or away from the life of Christ depending on the condition of their heart. Whether you are in Christ, whether you are walking with him, or whether you are not.
This simply means returning to the truth of the Lord: no division in my heart, no drifting away from you, but wholehearted devotion to you with the strength of my spirit. This is the kind of thing that takes shape in ordinary, daily faithfulness, not in dramatic gestures alone.
A Lesson from 2 Kings: Mixed Loyalties
There is a remarkable pair of chapters in 2 Kings, chapters 17 and 18, which I read during my fall break as a light read. If you do not remember 2 Kings, here is a quick summary. Israel was divided between north and south. As you can see, there is a lack of ability to fully devote oneself to God because of division within the kingdom. Why? Because of sin and idolatry. The northern kingdom of Israel was conquered many times because of the sin of idolatry, pursuing other gods.
In 2 Kings 17, the king of Assyria gathers all the people of northern Israel with him. Then he decides: "I will resettle Israel with people from every walk of life." Do not ask. He simply decided it was a good idea. He took all these people and placed them in Israel. Right? But here is the thing. None of them followed God. None of them knew Yahweh. So things went very badly for them, because their faith was all built on idolatry. But they lived there, did they not? In the promised land. And here is what 2 Kings 17:25 says. This is a striking verse. At the beginning of their settling there, all these foreign nations were in Israel. They did not fear the Lord. Of course not. And God did something about it. Oh my. So in verse 25, the Lord sent lions among them, and some of them were killed. Oh. Well. So what did the king of Assyria decide to do? He received reports that lions were killing the people living in the land. He said, "Let us send a priest to teach the people who Yahweh is so that the people will stop dying from the lions." An attack. And that is what happened. He sent one of the priests and began teaching the people the law, hoping this would stop the lion attacks. For a short time it worked. But what we see is that they added the worship, following, and fear of God to everything they were already doing. Nothing changed. Why? Because their desire to fear the Lord was built on real fear of the lion, not on love for Yahweh. That is a different thing. You cannot simply add Jesus to everything in your life, right? Discipleship works by subtraction. It works by removing things, not by adding things to them. As if you have multiple choices, like a buffet. That is not the way. It is a way of eating sometimes. But it is not the way of discipleship, my friends. It is not the way of discipleship. It is actually, Lord, help me clear things out for you.
And what happens here in this moving story at the end of chapter 17 is this: these are all the other nations living in Israel. And they also feared the Lord. So you think, "Well, that is good. Look at them." "And they appointed from among themselves all kinds of people as priests of the high places. Oh, that is probably not good. Who was sacrificing to them in the high places? Those are not good places." They feared the Lord. Understand this. But they also served their own gods in the manner of the nations from which they had been carried away. Why? Because their former way of life was stronger than their present way of life. So these nations feared the Lord and also served their carved images. Their children did the same, and their children's children as their fathers did, and so they do to this day. Look, you cannot have a mixed loyalty. You cannot simply add the things of Jesus to your life and think this is fine. Not just for you, but for your children, for discipleship across generations.
So the chapter that comes right after this is a striking contrast, a man with a pure heart. One of the few bright spots in a world full of events. The dark Old Testament where disobedience abounds. This is chapter 18, the chapter immediately following chapter 17. In the third year of Hoshea son of Elah, king of Israel. That is the northern kingdom. Hezekiah son of Ahaz, king of Judah, the southern kingdom. Now we move to the southern kingdom. He began to reign. What happened to him? Verse 2. He was 25 years old when he began to reign, and he reigned 29 years in Jerusalem. His mother's name was Abi, daughter of Zechariah. And he did what was right in the eyes of the Lord, according to all that his father David had done. Now, here is a little bit of information. Take it if you like. It is an add-on today. It is free. Right, King David was not technically his biological father. So what did he do? He took someone he knew was a man after God's own heart and essentially made him his example and his father's example. Because I want to walk in his way. My own lineage and the lineage of my generation is not good. So I will look for someone who has a true vision of God's life. This is my father. I want to walk in his way. And so King David became like his father. Adopted, so to speak, generations later. Look, you never know how your faith may influence generations to come. And we can all acknowledge that King David was a contradictory figure. Yet he had a persistent desire to follow God's way. That is shown here with Hezekiah. So in verse 4, what did Hezekiah do? Practically. He removed the high places, broke the pillars, and cut down the Asherah, the wooden pole associated with the worship of a fertility god. And he broke in pieces the bronze serpent that Moses had made, because until those days the people of Israel had been burning incense to it.
Making Room for Jesus
This is the picture of undivided discipleship: clearing out the high places, breaking the idols, cutting down what competes for the place that belongs to God alone. It is not dramatic in the way we might expect. Hezekiah did not win a battle by a flashy display. He simply did what was right in the eyes of the Lord and removed what had taken God's place. And that is where we will pick up the next part of this message, as we see what Jesus requires of anyone who would be his disciple.
Serving God Wholeheartedly
Let's start with Hezekiah. When he became king of Judah, the Scripture says he did what was right in the eyes of the Lord, just as his father David had done. Now, David wasn't Hezekiah's biological father in the technical sense. But he took as his model a man he knew had a heart for God. Hezekiah wanted to walk in that same path, and in that sense David became like a father to him, generations later.
Look, you never know how your faith may influence generations to come. And we can all acknowledge that King David was a contradictory figure. Yet he had a persistent desire to follow God's way, and that is shown here in Hezekiah.
"He removed the high places, broke the pillars, and cut down the Asherah... And he broke in pieces the bronze serpent that Moses had made, because until those days the people of Israel had been burning incense to it."
What Hezekiah did was practical. He recognized that God's people were mixing the worship of the Lord with other things, even worshiping the serpent alongside God. He saw that you cannot do both. You have to choose one.
Undivided Devotion
The Scripture says that Hezekiah trusted in the Lord, the God of Israel, and that there was none like him among all the kings of Judah, before or after. He held fast to the Lord and did not turn aside from following him. That is the secret of his success: his trust in the Lord.
For twenty-nine years there was a sense of joy and worship in Israel. But the people were waiting for a true and better King, and Hezekiah is only an example of what that looks like. I don't want to be Hezekiah for a moment; I want to tear down every stronghold in my life, even in this culture, and say, "Lord, everything is yours." Whatever it is, I want to take it captive for your glory.
This is not partial commitment. This is wholehearted devotion, and that is the heart of God. That is why Jesus says, "Count the cost." I can only imagine the cost that Hezekiah paid. People may have looked at him and thought he was crazy, extreme, even out of his mind. Yet he was simply trying to follow the God he believed was worthy of everything.
Bonhoeffer put it this way: when Christ calls a person, he bids them come and die. That is the call. And this is what Jesus says in Luke 14:33: whoever of you does not give up all that he has cannot be my disciple. Wholehearted allegiance to Jesus means he is first, he is the center of everything.
Faithfulness in the Small Things
How does this happen? There are two things. The first is this: you are already true disciples of Jesus when you faithfully do the small things he asks of you, every day. The life God has given you shines with light, love, and hope, and that happens in ordinary, daily things.
I'll confess that I began with a draft of this message that said, "Let's climb the hill." I wanted to rally people and say, "Come on, everything is yours, there is room for everyone." There are moments when I feel that zeal. But here is the reality: you may feel wonderful in that moment, and then on Monday, or at 1:02 on Sunday afternoon, you think, "I can't keep being extreme enough." When your whole spiritual life becomes a measure of how devoted, how extreme, or how zealous you are, even that can become an idol.
That's why it has to be about the small things, seeing the Lord's gifts: a home, a family, a job, a place where what he asks of me each day is to choose him over everything else. Bill Walsh, former coach of the San Francisco 49ers, wrote a book titled The Score Takes Care of Itself. The result takes care of itself. You cannot control the outcome. What you can control in your life with Christ are the small things he asked you to be faithful in.
And so, when Jesus is the one who began a good work in you, he will complete it. The pressure is off, friends. You are not the one who must save your story. But here is the encouragement to leave with today: choose to be bold. Choose to read God's Word when you would rather scroll, or read something you know is not good for your mind. Choose God, his Word first. Begin your day with him, and stay awake to him all day.
Choose to come to church, even when you don't feel like it. Choose to speak with your children about the kind of character they are growing in, rather than focusing on the score of the game. You are choosing a deeper path of Jesus than simply trying to fix something.
Grace That Costs Everything
As you leave today, I want you to feel that the challenge is no joke. The call is to die, to give your whole life, friends. The greatest thing is that God's grip on you, and his love for you, is stronger than your love or devotion to him. That is the beauty of Christianity: it is a call to die, yet the power of the life we live in following Christ is not in us or in our obedience, but in the Holy Spirit poured out in us.
This is the grace Bonhoeffer saw as precious. Our life in Christ is sustained by the one who gave himself for us. Galatians puts it simply: I have been crucified with Christ, and it is no longer I who live, but Christ who lives in me. The life I now live I live by faith in the Son of God, who loved me and gave himself for me.
Wherever you go this week, Christ is there. He goes before you. So my encouragement as you go is to keep praying, "Lord, I need to confess and repent. You deserve all of this. How can my life be more and more like you?"
Bonhoeffer contrasts cheap grace and costly grace, and there is no better way to end this morning than with his words: "Cheap grace is the preaching of forgiveness without requiring repentance... Costly grace is the treasure hidden in the field, for the sake of which a man will go and sell all that he has. It is the pearl of great price... It is the call of Jesus Christ, at which the disciple leaves his nets and follows him. It is costly because it costs a man his life, and it is grace because it gives a man the only true life. It is costly because it condemns sin, and grace because it justifies the sinner." Costly grace is the incarnation of God. Whatever God asks of you, he has done first. He has gone before you. And the costly grace of the life of Jesus Christ is everything.
So, friends, is this desire stronger than anything else I face this week? Is his grace enough for us? Let us pray and ask God's help in that.
Transcripción preparada con IA a partir de la grabación original; puede diferir de las palabras pronunciadas. Consulte la grabación antes de citar. Comunicar una corrección
Citar este sermón
Para lecciones, artículos y notas de estudio. Reconoce al predicador y a la iglesia y enlaza la grabación original.





